Washington, DC – Jewish college students concerned in protests at Columbia College say their pro-Palestinian activism is pushed by their religion – not regardless of it.
On Tuesday, a gaggle of Jewish pupil activists met with members of america Congress in Washington, DC, to inform their tales, which they are saying have been not noted of mainstream narratives about anti-Semitism on faculty campuses.
As pupil protests towards Israel’s battle in Gaza swept the nation final yr, Columbia College in New York turned a flashpoint.
The college noticed one of many first pupil encampments within the nation, erected to demand an finish to investments in corporations complicit in human rights abuses. Shortly after the tents began popping up, the campus additionally witnessed a number of the first mass arrests of pupil protesters within the Palestinian solidarity motion.
That visibility has made Columbia a focus for President Donald Trump’s efforts to crack down on what he known as “unlawful protests” and campus anti-Semitism.
Earlier this yr, Columbia pupil Mahmoud Khalil turned the primary pupil activist to be detained by the Trump administration and focused for deportation.
Tuesday’s delegation of Jewish college students got here to Congress to push the case that Khalil and others like him ought to by no means have been detained of their identify. They met with at the least 17 Democratic legislators from each the Home of Representatives and the Senate.
Al Jazeera spoke to a number of college students who participated within the lobbying day, which was organised by Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP) Motion, an advocacy organisation. Listed below are a few of their tales:
Tali Beckwith-Cohen
Raised in upstate New York, historical past main Tali Beckwith-Cohen stated she grew up in a group the place Zionism was the norm. She remembers being advised “myths” about Palestine as “a land and not using a individuals for a individuals and not using a land”: a slogan used to justify the institution of Israel.
However as she started to study Palestinian historical past and meet Palestinians, Beckwith-Cohen stated her beliefs have been challenged.
Ultimately, after the battle in Gaza started in October 2023, she turned concerned in Palestinian rights activism.
Human rights teams and United Nations specialists have discovered proof that Israel’s ways in Gaza are “per genocide”. Greater than 52,615 Palestinians have been killed within the battle to date.
“For a very long time, I had this sort of feeling of discomfort, this sense of wrestling, this sense of perhaps cognitive dissonance, and the way can I reckon these values I maintain expensive with Zionism?” Beckwith-Cohen advised Al Jazeera.
“We’re seeing the bombing, the disregard for human life, for kids, for hospitals, for faculties. It compelled me to choose.”
She burdened that the protests have been areas of solidarity, the place college students of all backgrounds have been dedicated to the concept that their security is intertwined.
“There’s a lot within the media narrative about what’s taking place on Columbia campus that’s simply disingenuous and simply so unfaithful to what we’ve skilled,” Beckwith-Cohen stated.
“So we’re right here right now to inform our Congress people who what we’re seeing on campus is clearly an authoritarian, fascist crackdown on all dissent, not solely college students peacefully advocating for an finish to genocide.”
Pupil activists Carly Shaffer and Raphie on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC, on Might 6 (Ali Harb/Al Jazeera)
Carly Shaffer
When Carly Shaffer voiced concern in regards to the Israeli escalation in Gaza on a college WhatsApp chat, a few of her fellow college students questioned her Judaism.
Out of the tons of of individuals on the chat, she remembers that Khalil – the activist arrested for deportation – was the one one who contacted her on to reject the feedback she was subjected to.
As she obtained to know Khalil, she got here to view him because the “embodiment” of somebody who cared in regards to the security of all college students on campus.
Shaffer advised Al Jazeera that she felt “sick” and “horrified” when Khalil was arrested. Her discomfort was then compounded when she noticed that the Trump White Home celebrated his detention on social media with the phrase “Shalom, Mahmoud” – a Jewish greeting repurposed as a taunt.
Shaffer, who’s pursuing a grasp’s diploma in human rights and social coverage, grew up in California and was raised by a single mom in a low-income family.
She stated talking out towards injustice – together with in Palestine – is a follow rooted in her Jewish religion.
“The Columbia protest motion, it’s a motion of affection. It’s a motion of solidarity,” Shaffer stated. “And Jewish college students are additionally integral and essential to this motion.”
She stated that, when Jewish pupil protesters held non secular occasions on campus, their friends from the encampment joined them and inquired about their traditions.
“These are the identical college students who’re being portrayed as anti-Semites, who’re going out of their solution to go and study Passover and have a good time a Jewish vacation with their Jewish buddies,” Shaffer advised Al Jazeera.
She decried the “weaponisation of anti-Semitism”, saying that the problem is getting used to close down conversations about Israeli atrocities in Gaza.
“Jewish college students are getting used as pawns in Trump’s political agenda,” she stated. “And the weaponisation of anti-Semitism to dismantle this motion isn’t just a risk to Jewish college students; it’s a risk to all of us. That’s why it’s so essential for us as Jewish college students to instantly appropriate this false narrative.”
Sarah Borus says Trump is utilizing the concern of anti-Semitism to focus on non-citizens and free speech within the US (Ali Harb/Al Jazeera)
Sarah Borus
Barnard School pupil Sarah Borus, who was arrested through the crackdown on the Columbia encampment, stated she grew up in an anti-Zionist household in a “very Zionist group”.
She felt it was essential for Jewish college students like herself to convey their experiences on to the individuals in energy in Washington, DC.
“We’re speaking to members of Congress to inform them our tales which can be not noted of mainstream information,” Borus advised Al Jazeera.
“Trump’s mission shouldn’t be about defending Jewish college students. It’s about utilizing fears of anti-Semitism – due to the best way that the Gaza solidarity encampment was portrayed final yr – so as to goal non-citizen pupil activists, so as to goal tutorial freedom, free speech, and actually put many, many individuals in peril.”
When requested how she feels in regards to the potential backlash to her activism, Borus acknowledged that the present political local weather left her fearful.
“I’m scared, however within the grand scheme of issues, I’m pleased with the alternatives I’ve made,” she stated. “I might not make any totally different ones, and I’m prepared to tackle the dangers, if that’s what should be executed.”
Shay Orentlicher says pupil protests have helped shift the general public discourse within the US (Ali Harb/Al Jazeera)
Shay Orentlicher
Shay Orentlicher has no regrets about collaborating in Columbia College’s encampments, regardless of the executive and political crackdowns.
Orentlicher stated Christian nationalists are attempting to erase the angle of pro-Palestine Jewish college students and outline Judaism in a approach that matches their political functions.
However protesting towards the killing of Palestinians, Orentlicher stated, is an expression of each Jewish and humanist values. And Orentlicher believes that Columbia’s demonstrations have helped increase consciousness nationwide.
“Regardless of the oppression we’ve confronted, regardless of the struggling, and regardless of the despair of worrying that we’ve not executed sufficient to cease the genocide, to face up for Palestinians in Gaza and the West Financial institution, I believe we’ve shifted the general public discourse in a very essential approach,” Orentlicher stated.
“And we even have constructed a very lovely group. And I don’t remorse what I did in any respect. I wouldn’t change something.”
Raphie
Raphie, who selected to establish by his first identify solely, stated he grew up “very Zionist”. However as he discovered extra in regards to the battle between Israelis and Palestinians, he felt he had been deceived.
“The Jewish elementary college I went to, as an example, had a map of Israel, and it was like a diamond – no West Financial institution or Gaza on it,” he stated.
“After I noticed the precise map with the occupied territories, I used to be like, ‘Wait, I used to be lied to.’ And that sort of made me go on this entire journey of exploring what Zionism is, what occupation is, what settler colonialism is.”
Raphie, who’s learning maths, stated the battle on Gaza, the campus protests and the backlash the coed protesters confronted all made him really feel a “private accountability to combat for what is correct”.
In his expertise, the demonstrations have been welcoming, not anti-Semitic. What was anti-Semitic, he stated, was the truth that the college focused Jewish pupil protesters for his or her political beliefs.
A number of college students, together with Raphie, stated Columbia refused to grant college students related to Jewish Voice for Peace the permission mandatory to carry non secular celebrations in public areas. They described that rejection as a type of discrimination.
The college didn’t reply to Al Jazeera’s request for remark by the point of publication.
Raphie additionally drew a distinction between feeling uncomfortable about concepts that problem one’s worldview and truly being unsafe.
“It’s regular in faculty to come across new viewpoints, new views. That’s how I turned extra pro-Palestinian and anti-Zionist,” he stated. “I initially felt uncomfortable after I encountered anti-Zionist views, however then I grew to know them. That’s regular.”
Raphie burdened that the actual struggling is going on in Gaza.
“The scholars who should not secure proper now, after all, are the scholars in Gaza. Each college in Gaza has been destroyed. They haven’t had meals for 60 days.”
