This text was produced for ProPublica’s Native Reporting Community in partnership with The Present. Join Dispatches to get tales like this one as quickly as they’re printed.
When the state of Georgia handed Deloitte Consulting a $10.7 million advertising contract final July to advertise the nation’s solely Medicaid work requirement program, the initiative was in want of significant PR.
On the time, a 12 months after this system’s rollout, lower than 2% of these eligible for Georgia Pathways to Protection had enrolled, effectively wanting state targets.
To get the phrase out, the state turned once more to the agency that it had relied on to construct and handle this system. About 60% of the advertising contract went towards creating and putting advertisements about Pathways on tv and radio, together with throughout NFL video games and morning discuss exhibits.
A lot of the rest of the seven-month contract would go towards two efforts: $250,000 monthly for Deloitte-trained groups handy out brochures and Pathways-branded merchandise at neighborhood occasions and $300,000 a month for Deloitte to supply reviews about its personal efficiency.
When Deloitte’s publicity marketing campaign resulted in February, enrollment in Pathways remained lower than 3% of the roughly 250,000 Georgians who’re doubtlessly eligible.
The advertising contract is a component of a bigger suite of companies that Georgia has commissioned from Deloitte for its Medicaid experiment. Deloitte has made a minimum of $51 million as of Dec. 31 to handle Pathways, together with creating and sustaining its problematic software program platform, as The Present and ProPublica beforehand reported. It’s also incomes a minimum of $3 million extra to supervise the state’s relationship with federal regulators, together with its software to increase the experiment past its expiration this fall.
Deloitte’s outsize — and weird — position in selling this system it has constructed has allowed the agency to maintain pulling in funds regardless of Pathways’ struggles. And there may be just about no public accounting of how effectively it’s growing enrollment, a key aim of the coverage experiment.
An excerpt of Deloitte’s advertising contract exhibits its $300,000 monthly expenditure on reviews by itself efficiency, $250,000 monthly for neighborhood outreach and $10.7 million complete funds.
Credit score:
Obtained by The Present and ProPublica. Highlighted by ProPublica.
The advertising contract, obtained by way of a public data request, permits Deloitte to cost the state practically half one million {dollars} for a last report on its publicity marketing campaign, which was resulting from be submitted in February. When The Present and ProPublica requested the month-to-month and last efficiency reviews, the state stated they wanted to be “reviewed” first and demanded $900 for that work. The information shops didn’t pay as a result of earlier responses to public data requests for Deloitte’s Pathways contracts had been closely redacted, with the overall counsel’s workplace on the Division of Group Well being citing “confidential/commerce secret.” The company didn’t cost for these data.
The state not too long ago permitted one other $10 million to Deloitte, Fiona Roberts, spokesperson for the Division of Group Well being, Georgia’s Medicaid company that oversees Pathways, stated in response to questions concerning the effectiveness of Deloitte’s advertising efforts. The new advertising contract, which runs till November, consists of extra neighborhood conferences and a textual content message marketing campaign by Salesforce Advertising Cloud rolling out in Could to doubtlessly eligible Georgians, Roberts stated.
“In 20 years of researching these sorts of packages, I can’t consider one other occasion like this” by which a state has chosen a for-profit firm to each handle and market a federal profit program, stated Joan Alker, govt director for Georgetown College’s McCourt Faculty of Public Coverage Heart for Youngsters and Households, the place researchers have concluded that Medicaid work necessities stop folks from accessing medical health insurance.
Deloitte has designed and managed Medicaid and different profit packages for a lot of states, together with Georgia, making the agency one of many nation’s specialists in authorities well being coverage. However Alker stated that when states need to educate and enroll residents in federal security internet packages, they usually choose native nonprofits which have established relationships with low-income communities. Georgia’s association with Deloitte raises questions, she stated, about “whether or not the state is extra dedicated to spending cash on consultants or poor folks.”
Deloitte, which has been in command of the Pathways communications technique for the previous three years, declined to reply questions on its Georgia Pathways work, referring requests for data to the Division of Group Well being. A contract signed in 2023 price roughly $7 million stipulates that Deloitte would “develop first draft of response to media inquiries” on behalf of the Division of Group Well being, however that responses “will probably be submitted by DCH and never Deloitte.” Deloitte’s duties additionally embody drafting speaking factors for media interviews, together with for the governor.
Roberts declined repeated requests for an interview with company officers. When requested about Deloitte’s advertising and outreach work and whether or not the agency has met the state’s targets, she described the hassle as a “sturdy, complete consciousness and outreach marketing campaign all through the state” that has generated 1.6 million guests to the Pathways web site for the reason that marketing campaign’s August 2024 launch.
“The state has invested closely in advertising and outreach to succeed in Georgians doubtlessly eligible for Pathways,” Roberts stated in a written assertion.
In 20 years of researching these sorts of packages, I can’t consider one other occasion like this.
—Joan Alker, govt director for Georgetown College’s McCourt Faculty of Public Coverage Heart for Youngsters and Households
Gov. Brian Kemp has described Pathways as an revolutionary different to increasing Medicaid, one thing 40 different states have achieved. Against this, Georgia’s program covers solely the poorest people who can show they’re working, finding out or volunteering a minimum of 80 hours a month. Congressional Republicans are pointing to related work necessities as a mannequin of their funds negotiations.
In early 2024, lower than a 12 months after Pathways’ launch, nevertheless, Georgia legislators — together with a few of Kemp’s Republican allies — thought-about ending the experiment and as an alternative increasing Medicaid with none work necessities. Georgia’s uninsured price was 11.4%, or 1.2 million folks, in comparison with the nationwide common of 8% in 2023, the most recent knowledge out there, in line with KFF, a nonprofit targeted on nationwide well being points. State knowledge confirmed that Pathways enrollment was effectively underneath the first-year goal of 25,000 printed in Georgia’s settlement with the federal authorities. As of April 25, roughly 7,400 Georgians had been enrolled, in line with the Division of Group Well being.
An unbiased analysis group commissioned by the state really useful methods to spice up enrollment in a December 2024 report. The evaluators, Public Consulting Group, highlighted North Carolina’s technique of permitting residents from rural communities and communities of coloration to assist create outreach campaigns for its expanded Medicaid program in 2023. North Carolina Medicaid officers instructed The Present and ProPublica that they designed their outreach efforts to maximise participation within the new program, with a two-year goal of enrolling 600,000 folks. They achieved that aim inside one 12 months.
He Grew to become the Face of Georgia’s Medicaid Work Requirement. Now He’s Fed Up With It.
Georgia and Deloitte, nevertheless, took a special tack. The $10.7 million advertising contract doesn’t lay out particular enrollment targets as a approach of measuring the success of Deloitte’s efforts. The aim of Pathways “just isn’t and has by no means been to enroll as many Georgians as attainable,” in line with the state’s software to the federal authorities to proceed the experiment.
The contract budgeted $247,000 to create as much as 4 testimonial movies that includes glad Pathways shoppers; just one may be discovered on the state Medicaid company’s YouTube channel, the place it has obtained roughly 350 views because it was posted in January. The state didn’t reply when requested what number of testimonials Deloitte produced.
Few folks stopped by the Georgia Pathways sales space on the Washington County Well being Honest in Sandersville, Georgia, in March.
Credit score:
Nicole Craine for ProPublica
In the meantime, one other a part of Deloitte’s advertising technique has additionally didn’t catch wind: Deloitte had despatched public relations groups to dozens of neighborhood occasions together with farmers markets, a college Christmas pageant and a catfish competition to plug Pathways and encourage purposes.
In March, one such group drove two hours from Atlanta to a well being truthful in Central Georgia’s rural Washington County. On the Pathways sales space, the Deloitte group barely regarded up from their telephones for 3 hours. Residents largely bypassed the group to talk with locals staffing different kiosks the place they may obtain diapers, data on sponsored in-home nursing care and blood strain screenings. Of those that stopped on the Pathways sales space, solely a handful requested about enrollment.
Different public occasions had been tied to the state’s pursuit of federal permission to increase the Pathways program past September, when its unique five-year mandate expires. Georgia is as soon as once more paying Deloitte to make sure that occurs.
The monthslong course of, managed by Deloitte, requires alternatives for public remark. A abstract of those feedback should be submitted with the applying, which Deloitte is drafting. Well being advocacy organizations say public outreach for this effort, particularly to Black Georgians, has been superficial at greatest.
The one discover for 2 digital public conferences appeared on a Division of Group Well being net web page that was not linked from the company’s homepage. Throughout each digital occasions, well being care advocates criticized this system’s inequitable entry, however state officers didn’t interact with the audio system.
A 3rd occasion — an in-person assembly within the rural 10,000-person city of Cordele — was added later and posted on the identical web site only one week earlier than it was scheduled to happen. Solely a couple of dozen folks, some touring for greater than 80 miles, confirmed as much as the midday assembly on St. Patrick’s Day.
Georgians traveled as much as 80 miles to talk at a public assembly about Pathways held by the Georgia Division of Group Well being in Cordele in March.
Credit score:
Nicole Craine for ProPublica
The city of Cordele has a inhabitants of round 10,000 folks.
Credit score:
Nicole Craine for ProPublica
The low attendance mirrored the assembly’s out-of-the-way location and vacation timing, not a scarcity of public curiosity, stated attendee Sherrell Byrd, govt director of Sowega Rising, a neighborhood advocacy group based mostly within the majority Black city of Albany.
Contained in the one-story cinder block constructing, three state well being officers sat alongside a desk on the entrance of the largely vacant room. One after the other, attendees rose to the microphone to complain of technical glitches within the Pathways enrollment course of, the dearth of customer support and the generational well being care inequalities confronted by Black Georgians.
Tanisha Corporal, who lives roughly 140 miles away in Atlanta, was the one particular person to take part just about. She instructed the Division of Group Well being officers that she had submitted a Pathways software 3 times over the Deloitte-built digital portal solely to have her file disappear. The licensed medical social employee whose nonprofit job resulted in January 2024 stated state companies supplied her little enrollment assist.
Grant Thomas, deputy commissioner for the Georgia Division of Group Well being, sits behind the room throughout a public assembly on the Georgia Pathways program in Cordele.
Credit score:
Nicole Craine for ProPublica
The state well being officers didn’t reply to any of the audio system throughout the assembly. Grant Thomas, Kemp’s former well being coverage advisor and deputy director of the state Medicaid company, sat behind the room and didn’t work together with the attendees. Thomas declined to talk on the document.
“There’s quite a lot of disdain for real-life issues of Georgians who appear to be us,” Byrd stated.
Robin Kemp of The Present contributed reporting.
