Mining firm Sio Silica has supplied Brokenhead Ojibway Nation a 5 per cent share of income from its proposed sand-extraction operation, promising the Winnipeg-area First Nation $20 million in annual income as soon as the challenge is working at full capability.
The Alberta-based firm, whose plan to extract as much as 33 million tonnes of high-grade silica from the under the floor of southeastern Manitoba over 24 years was rejected by the NDP authorities in 2024, has held a collection of conferences with Brokenhead members since final fall as a part of a revised effort to acquire an environmental licence for its operation.
In a presentation at Winnipeg’s Membership Regent resort on Monday night time, Sio Silica officers displayed a slide stating its mining operations will convey “important monetary advantages” for the First Nation, which has 2,307 members dwelling each on and off reserve.
These advantages embrace employment, coaching and academic alternatives, Sio Silica chief govt officer Feisal Somji stated on the assembly.
“We acknowledge that when a brand new challenge and a brand new course of comes into the world, you are not mechanically certified or educated on learn how to to work and profit from that,” Somji stated in an handle to Brokenhead members.
“Now we have to make sure that there’s correct coaching, correct schooling and correct assets for everybody to reap the benefits of that.”
The sand Sio Silica hopes to extract doesn’t lie under Brokenhead’s reserve lands. Sio Silica president Carla Devlin stated the band is being consulted as a result of it’s the closest First Nation to the wells her firm intends to drill throughout a broad swath of land in southeastern Manitoba.
“We consider First Nations must be on the desk earlier than approval, not after. And if we’re severe about true reconciliation, then it is about partnership,” Devlin stated Tuesday in a phone interview.
She wouldn’t verify whether or not a proper partnership with Brokenhead is on the desk or whether or not the advantages promised to the neighborhood rely on formal band assist for the challenge.
“Proper now, I can not communicate to that. I can let you know that we’re actively partaking in respectful dialogue and we’re encouraging financial reconciliation for First Nations,” she stated.
The areas in yellow demarcate Sio Silica’s subsurface mineral claims in southern Manitoba, in keeping with paperwork filed with Manitoba’s Clear Surroundings Fee. (CBC Information Graphics)
Brokenhead Chief Gordon Bluesky additionally didn’t verify whether or not a proper partnership is on the desk.
In an announcement, Bluesky stated it is necessary Brokenhead members perceive the total scope of a challenge proposed for its territory, the place he stated generations of improvement have impacted land and water with no profit to the nation or the well-being of its members.
“This can’t proceed,” Bluesky stated. “If we’re really going to advance financial reconciliation on our territory, it should occur on our phrases.”
Taylor Galvin, a Brokenhead member who lives in the neighborhood and opposes to the sand extraction proposal, stated she and different band members had been instructed Tuesday night time the band has already employed an official to work on an impact-benefit settlement between the First Nation and Sio Silica.
“Lots of people who had been there did not understand that we had been even at that stage, contemplating there isn’t any licence and there isn’t any signed agreements but,” Galvin, a graduate pupil in environmental research, stated Tuesday in a phone interview.
“They’re already transferring ahead on affect advantages and have any individual who’s engaged on this file already.”
Sio Silica proposes to drill fewer wells, at first
Sio Silica’s authentic software for an environmental licence was rejected by the province over issues in regards to the potential results on water high quality and the geological stability of the aquifer containing ultrapure crystalline quartz, which can be utilized to supply photo voltaic panels, new batteries and semiconductors.
The corporate proposed to drill as much as 7,200 wells to the east and southeast of Winnipeg to extract the sought-after substance from about 50 metres under the floor.
The Clear Surroundings Fee, an arm’s-length provincial physique, raised issues in regards to the proposal and suggested the federal government solely to approve it after making use of many situations to the proposal and to insist it proceed in phases, with only some mines drilled at first.
“As a normal precept, full-scale manufacturing ought to solely proceed if and when the physique of scientific and engineering proof confirms that the dangers are adequately understood and manageable,” the fee suggested in its report.
Sio Silica now proposes to drill 25 wells throughout its first 12 months of operation and 75 wells the next 12 months, in keeping with its Monday presentation. Somji additionally steered the corporate erred in its earlier public-relations efforts by describing its sand-extraction course of as using new know-how.
A check properly close to the proposed Sio Silica processing web site close to a tarped mound of extracted silica, within the RM of Springfield. (Bartley Kives/CBC)
“One of many errors that we made up to now is we talked about it being a patent pending course of and that was actually simply a component of benefit that we may have on our rivals,” he stated at Monday’s assembly.
“However the precise course of itself is just not new, it isn’t novel. It is simply taking a a course of that is getting used, utilizing air to carry sand and utilizing that to extract the fabric.
Because the province rejected Sio Silica’s licence software, the mining firm has rebranded its challenge as SiMBA, amended its plans to contain extra gradual drilling and began partaking with Brokenhead.
Brokenhead member Galvin stated she needs to know why Sio Silica didn’t seek the advice of First Nations throughout its first try to safe an environmental licence and questioned the sincerity of the corporate’s present effort.
“It is a political checkbox that all of them need to, all of us need to, abide by these days, proper? It makes them look good,” Galvin stated.
“They’re simply making an attempt to dot their i’s and cross their t’s to make the whole lot appear to be they’re following by way of on session, engagement and all these various things with the closest First Nation.”
How the mining would work
How Sio Silica hopes to extract sand from under the floor of southeastern Manitoba.
Tangi Bell, who leads a non-Indigenous group against Sio Silica’s extraction plans, referred to as the corporate’s ongoing effort to acquire an environmental licence “merely absurd.”
Bell, the Springfield-based president of Our Line In The Sand, stated if one other licence software is filed, she needs the NDP authorities to make sure the Clear Surroundings Fee holds a public listening to and offers funding for members, one thing she stated didn’t occur when the earlier software was thought-about underneath the previous Progressive Conservative authorities.
The province has not acquired any new or revised licence functions from the corporate, in keeping with a spokesperson for Surroundings and Local weather Change.
Sio Silica president Devlin stated the corporate intends to file a brand new software this calendar 12 months.
Devlin can be the mayor of East St. Paul, the place Brokenhead owns 194 hectares of land, together with a three-hectare reserve established twenty years in the past and one other 25-hectare parcel that can develop into a brand new Brokenhead reserve.
She stated she would think about recusing herself from any future East St. Paul selections associated to Brokenhead developments ought to the First Nation develop into a proper associate with Sio Silica.
Galvin, the Sio Silica opponent, stated she doesn’t belief Devlin as a result of she wears each hats.
“It is a very clear and open battle of curiosity on her half,” Galvin stated.
In a 100-page report issued in Might, Manitoba’s ethics commissioner decided former Manitoba premier Heather Stefanson and two of her PC cupboard ministers violated the province’s conflict-of-interest regulation and must be fined for pushing for the approval of the Sio Silica proposal after the Tories misplaced the 2023 election to the NDP.
Sio Silica was not sanctioned in that report.
What silica mining critics worry
What critics worry may occur if silica mining in southeastern Manitoba is authorized.
Supply hyperlink
