ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of energy. Join Dispatches, a publication that spotlights wrongdoing across the nation, to obtain our tales in your inbox each week.
Reporting Highlights
Large Cash: School athletes can earn money from using their title, picture and likeness — referred to as NIL.
No Oversight: Athletes are presupposed to disclose their NIL offers. However on the College of Illinois, that has didn’t occur, a violation of state legislation.
Susceptible Athletes: By not holding athletes accountable, U of I directors are failing to guard them from monetary and different pitfalls.
These highlights had been written by the reporters and editors who labored on this story.
Amid a standout season final 12 months, College of Illinois males’s basketball stars discovered themselves in excessive demand as they reached the Elite Eight within the 2024 NCAA Match.
Three gamers appeared in a industrial for a neighborhood BMW dealership.
One did an Instagram submit for TurboTax.
One other promoted an condominium advanced close to the Urbana-Champaign campus.
However not a kind of endorsements — that are allowed now that student-athletes can revenue from their private manufacturers — was reported to the college, as state legislation requires.
Actually, all the Illini crew reported simply $9,100 in title, picture and likeness offers throughout the 2023-24 season, in line with information obtained by the Chicago Tribune and ProPublica. By comparability, the common earnings reported for a male basketball participant within the Large Ten and the three different largest faculty conferences had been greater than $145,000 throughout that faculty 12 months, in line with information that establishments voluntarily supplied to the NCAA.
The Illini basketball crew’s lacking disclosures mirror an indifference to documenting NIL offers throughout the athletic division, the information organizations discovered. Athletes from 20 sports activities mixed have reported incomes solely about $1.2 million in three-plus years, in contrast with the $20 million Ohio State College’s soccer crew reportedly obtained in a single 12 months, or a College of Missouri quarterback who alone is estimated to have made greater than $1 million in NIL offers.
By shrugging its shoulders at Illinois’ reporting necessities, the college is failing to compile a whole image of how its college students — a few of them nonetheless youngsters — are navigating a comparatively new terrain rife with authorized, ethical and monetary pitfalls.
“I discover that maddening and irresponsible,” mentioned Invoice Carter, founding father of Scholar-Athlete Insights, which offers NIL consulting providers. “It appears unethical to me to permit 18-to-23-year-olds to take part in one thing life-altering like this however present no construction, no help, no route.”
A College of Illinois cheerleader rallies followers firstly of a girls’s basketball sport in February. The lead sponsor of the state’s legislation on faculty athletes’ title, picture and likeness offers mentioned one aim of the obligatory reporting provision was to look at potential gender gaps in compensation.
Credit score:
John J. Kim/Chicago Tribune
Officers from the Division of Intercollegiate Athletics say they inform the college’s athletes of their duties however acknowledge they don’t implement compliance, regardless of the Illinois legislation requiring athletes to reveal all offers to their colleges. The officers downplayed these failures by asserting that reporting is spotty nationwide.
Athletes “ought to simply disclose the offers, however each right here and throughout the nation, they simply type of don’t actually do this,” Kamron Cox, a U of I assistant athletic director and the college’s NIL specialist, mentioned in an interview.
In a three-page response to questions, the athletic division acknowledged college students are underreporting their earnings and didn’t dispute any of the figures on this story. The assertion famous it’s college students’ duty to report NIL agreements and mentioned the college has fulfilled its obligations below the legislation by paying for an app that permits athletes to take action. It referred to as the state’s disclosure guidelines — which the college had advocated for — “ineffective,” noting the legislation carries no penalties and arguing that punishing gamers internally would hurt the establishment’s popularity.
“Our program, like most throughout the nation, is doing its greatest to navigate in uncharted waters,” the assertion mentioned. It contended that 70% of NIL offers nationwide go unreported, citing one trade insider whose estimates have diversified. “Blind adherence to an untenable course of doesn’t seem like the expectation of the state, the NCAA, or our trade.”
Directors additionally mentioned they have no idea how a lot cash Illini basketball gamers — or any of the student-athletes — are receiving by means of NIL, regardless that at this time’s collegiate market requires understanding the quantities wanted to recruit and retain star athletes.
That lack of understanding “is just not potential and it’s not plausible,” Carter mentioned.
Greater than 20 states, together with Illinois, handed legal guidelines requiring athletes to reveal their offers after the U.S. Supreme Court docket dominated 4 years in the past that collegiate opponents have the proper to earn money. ProPublica and the Tribune obtained information of the offers reported by U of I athletes from July 2021 by means of October 2024 by way of the Freedom of Info Act, providing the general public a uncommon take a look at the shortage of accountability within the big-money world of school sports activities.
Michael LeRoy, a College of Illinois professor who has studied title, picture and likeness offers in collegiate athletics, mentioned he wonders why the Illinois athletic division hasn’t carried out extra to make sure compliance with NIL reporting necessities.
Credit score:
John J. Kim/Chicago Tribune
The information the U of I supplied to the Tribune and ProPublica included 1,037 offers throughout all sports activities with the names of the athletes redacted by settlement. Sponsored social media posts had been, by far, essentially the most frequent method athletes reported incomes cash, adopted by autograph signings and private appearances.
On this far-from-complete information, offers ranged from a male basketball participant’s $326,000 association with a Porsche dealership in Kentucky to $10 for a monitor athlete to endorse a males’s cleaning soap referred to as “Freshticles.”
The Illinois legislation on NIL requires athletes to offer their colleges with copies of contracts when the offers are valued at $500 or extra. Illini athletes reported greater than 175 offers that meet that normal. However when the information organizations filed a public information request in search of contracts for 12 of the most important reported offers, a college administrator responded that the campus didn’t have any of them.
“There may be nothing within the Illinois legislation that will be troublesome for any Large Ten athletic program to comply with,” mentioned Michael LeRoy, a labor and employment relations professor at U of I and former chair of the college’s athletic board. “However they’re clearly selecting to not do it. It’s important to surprise why.”
The NCAA declined to talk with reporters for this story, but it surely has issued a number of statements stressing the necessity for transparency in NIL agreements. It established a coverage final 12 months to encourage athletes nationwide to report offers to their establishments, so colleges might then present the knowledge to the NCAA to make obtainable on a public dashboard supposed to assist college students navigate the NIL market.
However to date, there have been no penalties for athletes or establishments that fall brief.
That might quickly change. Subsequent week, a $2.8 billion settlement of a class-action lawsuit introduced by student-athletes towards the NCAA is anticipated to achieve remaining approval, shifting the panorama once more. Underneath the deal, referred to as the Home settlement after one of many plaintiffs, a college would be capable of pay its athletes immediately from a revenue-sharing finances capped at $20.5 million for the subsequent faculty 12 months.
Colleges additionally could possibly be immediately concerned in negotiating NIL offers for his or her athletes, and offers value no less than $600 and people made with collectives would have to be reported to an out of doors entity. That entity would consider whether or not the funds align with a good market worth and make sure the cash is just not a pay-to-play deal. These stories will not be anticipated to be made public.
The 4 largest conferences — the Atlantic Coast Convention, Large Ten, Southeastern Convention and Large 12 — have mentioned they plan to create a corporation that will each implement and implement the foundations because the NCAA’s oversight position shrinks. It additionally might concern penalties.
“The ante has been upped,” mentioned Joshua Lens, a College of Iowa sports activities administration professor who has studied NIL extensively. “It is going to require disclosure like we’ve all alongside, however now … the colleges and athletes could possibly be penalized.”
Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker, proven at State Farm Heart on the College of Illinois campus, signed laws in 2021 that permits faculty athletes within the state to earn money off their model whereas requiring them to report such offers to their faculty.
Credit score:
Anthony Zilis/The Information-Gazette
Face Wash and Bodily Remedy
The NIL period in Illinois started on June 29, 2021, on the State Farm Heart on the College of Illinois campus. Gov. JB Pritzker signed the groundbreaking laws, referred to as the Scholar-Athlete Endorsement Rights Act, whereas surrounded by a number of Illini athletes, together with gymnast Dylan Kolak.
Illinois was among the many first states to move an NIL legislation, and Kolak was able to seize the second. He had begun making TikTok movies throughout the pandemic to advertise males’s gymnastics and health, amassing greater than 500,000 followers in just a little over a 12 months.
When corporations approached him about the opportunity of endorsement offers, Kolak mentioned he both ignored their messages or defined that NCAA guidelines prohibited him from incomes cash that method. For Kolak, a partial-scholarship athlete who excelled on the flooring train and vault, it stung every time he handed up a proposal.
Former Illini gymnast Dylan Kolak reported his NIL cope with Athletico, a bodily remedy supplier, to the college, consistent with state legislation.
Credit score:
TikTok video obtained by ProPublica and the Tribune
He’s the kind of athlete state Rep. Kam Buckner, a former Illini defensive lineman, had in thoughts when the Chicago Democrat sponsored laws codifying moneymaking alternatives for student-athletes. He was joined by two former Northwestern College athletes, state Sen. Napoleon Harris and Illinois Home Speaker Emanuel “Chris” Welch.
Buckner mentioned he remembered what it was wish to be a university athlete and want additional money for requirements.
“In a method, it had the underlying air of indentured servitude the place you don’t even personal your personal area,” Buckner mentioned. “And so for me, this was about equity.”
The state legislation’s guidelines for NIL are easy: Athletes can’t take cash from the playing, tobacco or alcohol industries. They will’t use a college emblem with out permission. They will’t put on their uniforms in commercials except they’ve prior approval from their establishments.
They usually should report their NIL offers to their colleges. From Buckner’s standpoint, that clause supplied universities and their athletes a baseline for understanding what sort of offers — and what sort of {dollars} — had been obtainable on this new and unfamiliar world. The info additionally might assist determine any gender or racial gaps that emerged, Buckner mentioned.
By all accounts, the college took the reporting requirement significantly to start with.
“We had been advised to report our offers always,” Kolak mentioned. “We had been advised we might lose our eligibility if we didn’t. No one needed to danger that.”
Kolak mentioned he reported the whole lot that got here his method, together with $900 for an Instagram submit a few face wash, $1,300 for selling males’s footwear on TikTok and $2,375 for documenting his bodily remedy at Athletico.
Illinois state Rep. Kam Buckner, a former Illini soccer participant, was a chief sponsor of the state’s NIL laws. He mentioned he remembers what it was wish to be a university athlete and want more money for requirements.
Credit score:
Brian Cassella/Chicago Tribune
The reporting requirement grew to become so ingrained in Kolak and his teammates in these early NIL days that the boys’s gymnastics squad logged 128 offers in 2021 and 2022. It was essentially the most of any Illini males’s crew, with solely girls’s softball recording extra offers.
The quantity dropped considerably, nonetheless, by 2023 and 2024, after the college stopped stressing the significance of reporting. The boys’s gymnastics crew reported simply 44 offers in these years — nonetheless essentially the most reported by any males’s crew.
Cox, the U of I assistant athletic director, mentioned he commonly reminded college students in regards to the disclosure guidelines throughout the first 12 months of NIL. However after the NCAA in October 2022 barred colleges from arranging or negotiating NIL offers for athletes, the division stopped stressing the significance of reporting, in line with Cox.
The autumn 2022 steering didn’t say to cease, nonetheless. Actually, it acknowledged, “when permitted by relevant state legal guidelines — colleges can and may require student-athletes to report NIL actions to the athletics division.”
Roger Denny, the U of I athletic division’s chief working officer, mentioned in an interview that the division nonetheless conducts a number of shows annually for athletes to go over contracts, taxes and disclosure guidelines. The division’s assertion mentioned it sends weekly emails to athletes and conducts periods with an NIL advisor. Requested for an instance of the emails, the division shared the newest publication, through which the final merchandise reminded athletes to reveal their NIL offers.
Buckner, the Illinois lawmaker, mentioned that he was unaware of the reporting practices and the foundations must be adopted so athletes perceive the enjoying area. “I don’t imagine in simply throwing arbitrary mechanisms into coverage that aren’t adopted,” he mentioned. “In the event that they’re not doing what they’re supposed to do, we’ve obtained to determine tips on how to change that.”
The college’s lack of consideration to college students’ reporting is clear within the faculty’s information, which reveals the reported worth of NIL offers dropped by 85% on the Urbana-Champaign campus within the 2023-24 tutorial 12 months. In keeping with the information, student-athletes reported making a complete of simply $103,000 that 12 months, down from $702,500 in 2022-23.
First picture: College of Illinois gymnast Sam Phillips pets his cat, Richard Parker, at his condominium in Champaign. Phillips, who just lately injured his Achilles tendon, mentioned his former faculty, the College of Nebraska, exercised extra oversight over his NIL agreements than the U of I does. Second picture: Phillips shows an Instagram promotion he did for Diploma deodorant.
Credit score:
John J. Kim/Chicago Tribune
Illini gymnast Sam Phillips, a two-time All-American who transferred from the College of Nebraska final 12 months, mentioned NIL guidelines had been talked about at a gathering for brand new U of I athletes. However there hasn’t been extra dialogue about NIL, he mentioned. Against this, at Nebraska, Phillips mentioned he commonly obtained recommendation from an athletic division compliance officer who reminded him to reveal his offers to the college.
He did so by means of an app that many universities use referred to as Opendorse, which helps athletes discover NIL offers and report them to college officers. U of I is spending $260,000 on a contract with Opendorse by means of mid-2026, which the athletic division mentioned fulfills its obligation below the state’s NIL legislation to facilitate reporting.
Nebraska’s compliance officer reviewed every of Phillips’ agreements at that faculty, in line with the app, however as of December there was no indication U of I had examined the offers Phillips had reached since his switch, together with with Abbott, Diploma deodorant and Savage X Fenty underwear. The college mentioned its athletic division critiques offers submitted by means of Opendorse however that it doesn’t doc it on the app and it isn’t required to.
“I haven’t spoken to anybody in (the U of I) administration in any respect,” mentioned Phillips, a nonscholarship athlete who makes use of the cash to pay for dwelling bills. “It has been by myself.”
Quattrone, who owns 5 auto dealerships within the Champaign space, has autographed sports activities memorabilia on show in his workplace at Serra Buick GMC in Savoy. Quattrone mentioned he has bought automobiles to student-athletes at hefty reductions, amongst different compensation, in trade for his or her appearances and participation in advertisements.
Credit score:
John J. Kim/Chicago Tribune
“A Ridiculously Good Deal”
At Illinois, the reporting failures are greatest exemplified by means of the college’s marquee males’s sports activities: soccer and basketball.
Counting on social media, information releases and media interviews, ProPublica and the Tribune recognized dozens of endorsements that weren’t included within the database supplied by U of I. The lacking endorsements embody a number of promoted throughout March Insanity in 2024, together with the TurboTax advert from basketball participant Marcus Domask and a preferred industrial for a Serra Champaign automobile dealership that featured three of his teammates.
In that advert, Terrence Shannon Jr., Coleman Hawkins and Ty Rodgers wore Groucho Marx glasses as they sought an autograph from Illini teen superfan Tommy Rouse. The gamers, who’ve all pushed luxurious autos from Serra, had their automobiles cleaned whereas they shot the video within the showroom, in line with dealership proprietor Ben Quattrone.
Quattrone, a longtime supporter of the athletic division, mentioned he has bought automobiles to athletes at hefty reductions in trade for his or her appearances and participation in advertisements, in addition to supplied automobile washes in trade for signed basketballs, all permitted below the NIL guidelines. He estimates he has spent about $150,000 up to now few years to buy TV advertisements and different media promotions that includes Illini athletes.
Illini athletes have posted movies on social media exhibiting them driving BMWs, together with a BMW XM, an SUV with a sticker worth of $160,000. “I make them a ridiculously whole lot,” mentioned Quattrone.
Data on NIL offers reported to the College of Illinois didn’t embody this 2024 industrial for a Champaign automobile dealership through which Illini gamers Coleman Hawkins, Terrence Shannon Jr. and Ty Rodgers appeared in Groucho Marx glasses.
Credit score:
Obtained by ProPublica and the Tribune
No Illinois athlete, nonetheless, has disclosed a cope with Serra to the college, information present. Quattrone mentioned he reminds athletes to put aside cash to pay taxes on their NIL offers however mentioned he was not sure of their reporting obligations to the college.
Across the similar time because the Serra advert got here out, the Pacifica on Inexperienced — a brand new condominium advanced that caters to college students — additionally tried to capitalize on the success of the college’s basketball crew and its soccer program. The Tribune and ProPublica recognized no less than six soccer and males’s basketball gamers featured on the condominium advanced’s Instagram, together with then-Illini ahead Dain Dainja, who appeared in a number of posts all through the 2023-24 season.
In a single submit, which celebrated the crew advancing to the Elite Eight, Pacifica gave a signed Dainja jersey to a tenant who renewed his lease throughout March Insanity. An earlier photograph confirmed Dainja signing the jersey for the renewal promotion whereas sporting an olive inexperienced Pacifica T-shirt.
No males’s basketball or soccer gamers disclosed receiving any type of cost from the advanced. Just one Illini athlete — a feminine basketball participant — advised the college about receiving compensation from Pacifica: greater than $16,000 for Instagram reels, in line with the information.
Former Illini basketball participant Marcus Domask promoted TurboTax in a “paid partnership” Instagram submit final 12 months. The deal was not included within the NIL information supplied by the college.
Credit score:
Display recording by ProPublica. Cropped by ProPublica.
Not one of the athletes within the Serra, Pacifica or TurboTax promotions or their representatives agreed to remark for this story. A Pacifica consultant additionally didn’t reply to interview requests.
The failure by many male athletes to reveal their offers additionally makes it troublesome to evaluate variations in NIL compensation between female and male college students at U of I — a acknowledged aim of the Illinois legislation’s lead sponsor.
{That a} gender hole exists is evident, regardless of the flawed nature of the information. Within the three-year interval examined by the Tribune and ProPublica, male athletes accounted for greater than $1 million in reported earnings, in contrast with $160,000 complete for feminine athletes.
However within the 2023-24 faculty 12 months, after directors stopped stressing the significance of reporting, males disclosed solely $44,500 in NIL offers, in contrast with $58,500 for the ladies.
The falloff in reporting additionally obscures the position performed by a boosterlike nonprofit group referred to as the Icon Collective in elevating NIL cash for Illinois student-athletes. Such collectives have grow to be widespread at many universities, elevating thousands and thousands of {dollars} paid to gamers in trade for group service similar to volunteering at a meals financial institution.
Icon is meant to be unbiased from the U of I’s athletic division, although information present they work collectively on the whole lot from athlete appearances to the beer bought at Memorial Stadium.
Reporters recognized no less than six U of I athletes who promoted the Pacifica on Inexperienced condominium advanced on Instagram, however just one cope with Pacifica, involving an unnamed girl, was included within the NIL information from the college.
Credit score:
John J. Kim/Chicago Tribune
In asserting Icon’s launch in early 2023, a college press launch mentioned the collective had raised greater than $1.5 million supposed for student-athletes.
However Illini athletes reported receiving solely about $99,000 from Icon between February 2023 and October 2024, with the majority of it — $75,000 — going to Illini soccer gamers. No males’s basketball gamers reported receiving any cash by way of the collective, although the group commonly makes use of photos of males’s gamers in its advertising and marketing materials.
Icon’s president, Kathleen Knight, a former athletic division worker, declined to reply questions in regards to the inconsistencies between the athletes’ stories and her group’s purported fundraising.
In a short assertion, Knight mentioned Icon doesn’t publicly share its monetary info.
Cox, the assistant athletic director and NIL specialist, mentioned he doesn’t understand how a lot cash Icon has distributed to its athletes, partly due to the shortage of disclosures.
The college made an analogous assertion on Thursday. Management of the athletic division “stays unaware of the phrases of Icon’s agreements with most of our student-athletes,” it mentioned.
A number of consultants advised ProPublica and the Tribune that the concept an athletic division wouldn’t know the sum of money a collective gave to its athletes defies credulity, given the well-known monetary calls for of the school market and the usually shut relationships between collectives and athletic departments.
“It’s not even placing their head within the sand,” mentioned Carter, the NIL knowledgeable. “It’s patently false.”
A video board on the College of Illinois’ State Farm Heart shows an commercial for a brand new Icon Collective membership drive. The collective raises NIL cash to learn Illini student-athletes.
Credit score:
John J. Kim/Chicago Tribune
The Way forward for Transparency
At a congressional listening to final month, Illini athletic director Josh Whitman talked about the way forward for NIL and the significance of making nationwide requirements for revenue-sharing and NIL offers as an alternative of a patchwork of state-by-state laws.
“We definitely don’t have an curiosity in micromanaging these alternatives for our scholar athletes,” he advised federal lawmakers. “However it will be important that we do attempt to create some system to watch that, to create some degree of transparency. Our student-athletes need that transparency.”
U of I directors, nonetheless, have argued towards public transparency in terms of NIL offers. Cox, additionally an adjunct professor on the college’s legislation faculty, wrote in a legislation publication final 12 months that “one of the best transfer for all establishments to help student-athletes is to refuse disclosure of student-athlete NIL info as a matter of coverage.”
Directors then succeeded in getting a legislation handed that they contend exempts NIL information from the Freedom of Info Act, severely hindering any additional public evaluation or accountability. Certainly, the U of I mentioned in early January that it will not launch the kind of information obtained by the Tribune and ProPublica for this investigation.
“Our place is that that’s not the general public’s enterprise,” Whitman advised a reporter final 12 months.
Representatives Demand Housing Company Halt Any Cryptocurrency Experiments
The Illinois athletic division additionally referenced the FOIA exemption in its three-page response to ProPublica and the Tribune, saying that though there’s public need for NIL info, “the privateness of scholars is the extra urgent concern.”
However at the same time as Illinois directors pushed to alter the legislation final 12 months, the requirement that athletes report the offers to their establishments remained. And athletes can be required to reveal their offers below the Home settlement — a mandate the college celebrated in its written assertion.
Within the face of “sturdy and swift accountability,” officers mentioned, their athletes would comply.
Joe Mahr of the Chicago Tribune contributed information evaluation. Mariam Elba of ProPublica contributed analysis reporting.
