ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of energy. Signal as much as obtain our largest tales as quickly as they’re printed.
Reporting Highlights
Odyssey: Rümeysa Öztürk’s arrest and detention reveal what President Donald Trump’s deportation marketing campaign appears to be like like on the road stage.
Rendition: Immigration legal professionals describe the case as a callback to the post-9/11 observe of federal brokers grabbing Muslim suspects off the road.
Course of: Öztürk was shipped from state to state — a journey, critics say, that makes authorized challenges of such instances tougher.
These highlights have been written by the reporters and editors who labored on this story.
With a line of vehicles ready behind them on the prepare station, the 2 girls hugged tightly as they stated goodbye on the finish of a spring break that hadn’t turned out to be the stress-free trip they’d imagined.
Their ladies journey had remodeled into limitless conversations about safety precautions as one of many mates, 30-year-old Turkish nationwide Rümeysa Öztürk, grew more and more nervous she would turn into a goal of the Trump administration’s deportation marketing campaign.
Öztürk, a former Fulbright scholar in a doctoral program at Tufts College, was shocked to seek out out in early March that she had been focused by a pro-Israel group that highlighted an op-ed she co-wrote final yr criticizing the college’s response to the battle in Gaza.
Her concern deepened days later with the detention of former Columbia College graduate pupil Mahmoud Khalil, a everlasting resident the federal government is making an attempt to deport over his position in pro-Palestinian demonstrations on campus.
By the point of Öztürk’s spring break journey on March 15, she was consumed with anxiousness, stated her pal E., an Arab American tutorial on the East Coast who requested to withhold her title and different figuring out particulars for safety causes.
Throughout their reunion in E.’s hometown, the primary time they’d been collectively for the reason that summer season, the chums seemed up know-your-rights tutorials and mentioned whether or not Öztürk ought to minimize brief her doctoral program. They spent their final day collectively filling out consumption kinds for authorized assist teams — simply in case.
Proper up till their final minutes collectively on the prepare station, they wrestled with how cautious Öztürk needs to be when she returned to Massachusetts. Öztürk puzzled if she ought to keep away from communal dinners, a function of Muslim social life in the course of the holy month of Ramadan.
“I instructed her to maintain going out, to be along with her neighborhood. I needed her to dwell her life,” E. recalled, her voice breaking.
“After which she acquired kidnapped in broad daylight.”
By now, a lot of the nation has seen the footage of Oztürk’s seize.
Surveillance video from March 25 reveals her strolling to dinner in Somerville, Massachusetts, close to the Tufts campus, chatting on the cellphone along with her mom when she is swarmed by six masked plainclothes officers. Öztürk screams.
Inside three minutes, she’s bundled into an unmarked automotive and whisked away, a jarring scene that confirmed the nation what President Donald Trump’s deportation marketing campaign appears to be like like on the road stage: federal brokers ambushing a Muslim lady who co-wrote an op-ed in a university newspaper.
The footage drew worldwide outrage and turned Öztürk into a strong image of the Division of Homeland Safety dragnet.
Surveillance Video of Rümeysa Öztürk’s Seize
Credit score:
Obtained by ProPublica
To piece collectively what’s occurred since then, ProPublica examined courtroom filings and interviewed attorneys and Öztürk’s shut pal, who frequently speaks to her in detention. What emerges is a extra intimate image of Öztürk and the way a toddler improvement researcher charged with no crime ended up in a crowded cell in Louisiana. The interviews and courtroom data additionally present a glimpse right into a sprawling, opaque equipment designed to deport the utmost variety of folks with minimal accountability.
Her legal professionals describe it because the story of a Trump-era rendition, a callback to the post-9/11 observe of federal brokers grabbing Muslim suspects off the road and taking them to places identified for harsh situations and shoddy oversight.
Öztürk is amongst practically 1,000 college students whose visas have been revoked, in accordance with a tally by the Affiliation of Worldwide Educators. And she or he is amongst a number of college students and professors who’ve been detained.
Her detention was distinctive, immigration attorneys stated, as a result of it was caught on digital camera. What’s scariest, they are saying, is how briskly the removals occur and the way little is thought about them.
Homeland Safety spokespeople didn’t reply to requests for remark.
The video of Öztürk’s arrest surfaced as a result of Boston-area activists had arrange a hotline for locals to report interactions with Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The decision that got here in about Öztürk reported a “kidnapping,” stated Fatema Ahmad of the Muslim Justice League, a part of the advocacy community that obtained the footage.
“What broke me was her screaming. And figuring out that the identical factor had simply occurred to nearly 400 folks within the Boston space the week earlier than,” she stated, referring to a latest six-day ICE operation.
After her arrest, Öztürk was held by ICE incommunicado for practically 24 hours, her attorneys stated, throughout which period she suffered the primary of 4 bronchial asthma assaults.
Solely later, via courtroom filings and conversations with Öztürk, her attorneys realized that in the midst of a single evening she was taken from Massachusetts to New Hampshire after which Vermont, the place the subsequent morning, she was loaded onto a airplane and flown to an ICE outpost in Alexandria, Louisiana.
Her final cease was a detention middle in Basile about an hour away, the place she stays, certainly one of two dozen girls in a humid, mouse-infested cell constructed to carry 14, in accordance with courtroom filings.
ICE officers say in courtroom paperwork they couldn’t discover a mattress for Öztürk in New England, including that out-of-state transfers are “routinely performed after arrest, because of operational necessity.”
Immigration attorneys say the late-night hopscotch was an ICE tactic to complicate jurisdiction and thwart authorized makes an attempt to cease Öztürk’s elimination. Louisiana and Texas, they are saying, are favored locations as a result of the courts there are seen as friendlier to the Trump administration’s MAGA agenda, issuing selections limiting migrant rights.
“It was like a relay race, and he or she was the baton,” Öztürk’s lawyer Mahsa Khanbabai stated.
“Entire Different Degree of Terror”
On March 4, two weeks earlier than their spring break reunion, Öztürk texted her pal E. to say she’d been “doxxed” by Canary Mission, a part of an array of shadowy, right-wing Jewish teams which can be criticized for utilizing cherry-picked statements and distorted context to painting even delicate criticism of Israel as antisemitism or help for terrorism.
For greater than a decade, hard-line pro-Israel teams have publicized the names of pro-Palestinian activists, teachers and college students, usually with scant or doubtful “proof” to again allegations of anti-Jewish bigotry. The aim, civil liberties advocates say, is to silence protesters via campaigns which have value targets jobs and led to demise threats. On its web site, Canary Mission stated it’s “motivated by a want to fight” antisemitism on faculty campuses. It says it investigates people and teams “throughout the North American political spectrum, together with the far-right, far-left and anti-Israel activists.”
The trouble was stepped up in the course of the wave of pupil protests that erupted in opposition to the battle in Gaza.
Öztürk’s entry on the Canary Mission website, posted in February, claims she “engaged in anti-Israel activism in 2024,” citing the op-ed she co-wrote greater than a yr in the past that accused Tufts of ignoring college students’ calls to divest from firms with ties to Israel over human rights issues.
“I cannot imagine how a lot time folks have,” Öztürk texted her pal when she noticed the put up.
E. responded with an open-mouthed “shocked” emoji. The Canary Mission entry, she stated, had unlocked “a complete different stage of terror” for Öztürk.
“It was that feeling of getting your privateness be so violated — for folks to spend all this time and power on one op-ed,” E. stated.
The op-ed printed in The Tufts Every day was signed by 4 authors, together with Öztürk, and endorsed by greater than 30 different unnamed college students. The language echoed the statements of United Nations officers and worldwide battle crimes investigators concerning the demise toll in Gaza, which in accordance with well being officers there has handed 50,000, with a couple of third of the casualties beneath 18.
Öztürk, an advocate for youngsters in communities tormented by violence, was personally heartsick over pictures of burned and mangled Palestinian kids. However she was not a distinguished activist or a fixture at campus protests, her mates and attorneys say.
Öztürk’s attorneys, who’re scheduled to seem Monday earlier than a federal decide in Vermont, say the only foundation for revoking her visa seems to be the op-ed highlighted by Canary Mission.
Ramzi Kassem, a lawyer representing Öztürk, stated pro-Israel teams are offering the administration with lists of targets for its deportation marketing campaign in opposition to noncitizen pupil protesters. “The sequence of occasions,” he stated, “is op-ed, doxxing, detention.”
Professional-Israel teams, together with Canary Mission, have boasted about their affect on the Trump administration’s focusing on of pupil protesters. Immigration officers insist that they make their very own elimination selections primarily based on a variety of components, together with a tough line on criticism of Israel.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio says he has revoked greater than 300 pupil visas, together with for Khalil and Öztürk, beneath the Immigration and Nationality Act, which allows the deportation of noncitizens who’re deemed “adversarial to the overseas coverage and nationwide safety pursuits” of america.
“We gave you a visa to return and research and get a level, to not turn into a social activist who tears up our college campuses,” Rubio instructed a information convention final month in response to a query about Öztürk’s detention. “On daily basis I discover certainly one of these lunatics, I take away their visa.”
A spokesperson stated the State Division doesn’t touch upon ongoing litigation.
In a name with reporters on Thursday, lawyer Marc Van Der Hout of Khalil’s authorized group stated the authority Rubio cites was meant for uncommon events involving high-level diplomatic issues, “not for use to go after folks for First Modification-protected exercise.”
In a single day Odyssey
Surrounded by masked officers on March 25, Öztürk had no thought who was seizing her or the place she was being taken, in accordance with an announcement filed on Thursday in federal courtroom. The operatives have been wearing civilian garments, she wrote, so at first she nervous they have been vigilantes spurred by Canary Mission.
“I had by no means seen police method and take somebody away like this,” she wrote. “I assumed they have been individuals who had doxxed me and I used to be afraid for my security.”
Öztürk’s assertion particulars her harrowing evening being shuttled throughout New England with little meals after a day of fasting for Ramadan. She describes being shackled by her ft and abdomen after which pushed to totally different websites for conferences with unidentified males, some in uniform and a few not. One group so unsettled her, Öztürk wrote, that she “was certain they have been going to kill me.”
At one other cease, described within the assertion as an remoted parking zone, Öztürk repeatedly requested an officer if she was in bodily hazard.
“He appeared to really feel responsible and stated ‘we aren’t monsters,’” Öztürk wrote.
On the final cease in Vermont, Öztürk wrote, she arrived famished and with “loads of movement illness from all of the driving.” Officers took her biometric knowledge and a DNA pattern.
She would keep there for the evening, in a cell with only a arduous bench and a rest room. Officers gained entry to her cellphone, she wrote, together with private images of her with out her non secular headband.
“Throughout the evening they got here to my cell a number of instances and requested me questions on wanting to use for asylum and if I used to be a member of a terrorist group,” Öztürk wrote. “I attempted to be useful and reply their questions however I used to be so drained and didn’t perceive what was taking place to me.”
Round 4 the subsequent morning, she wrote, she was shackled once more in preparation for a visit to the airport. She was instructed the vacation spot was Louisiana. Her assertion to the courtroom recounts the parting phrases of certainly one of her jailers: “I hope we handled you with respect.”
At practically each stage of her detention, Öztürk, who takes each day preventative medicine for bronchial asthma, skilled bronchial asthma assaults, which she says are triggered by fumes, mildew or stress, courtroom information say.
Throughout one in Louisiana, Öztürk wrote, a nurse took her temperature and stated, “It’s essential to take that factor off your head,” earlier than eradicating her hijab with out asking. When Öztürk protested, the nurse instructed her, “That is to your well being.”
By her fourth wheezing episode, Öztürk wrote, she didn’t hassle to hunt consideration from her jailers in Louisiana: “I didn’t really feel secure on the medical middle.”
After the portrait Öztürk paints of ICE detention, her assertion turns again to her outdated life, a reminder of how abruptly her world has shifted. From her cell in Louisiana, she described the plans she had within the coming months. Finishing her dissertation. A convention in Minnesota. College students to mentor. A summer season class to show.
“I need to return to Tufts to renew all of my cherished work,” she concluded.
Reunion Interrupted
Öztürk and E. bonded in 2018 after assembly at a Muslim research group in New York, the place they have been each attending Columbia College.
They have been of their 20s then, two bookish cat lovers who have been critical about their research and their religion. They went on nature walks and preferred afternoon naps.
“Previous women,” E. stated with amusing.
They remained shut and took turns visiting after Öztürk left for Tufts and E. moved away from town. Through the years, the pressures of grad college and distance had made their visits much less frequent, E. stated, so that they’d been wanting ahead to their three-day spring break catch-up.
Throughout the go to, E. stated, the ladies broke their quick collectively and visited a mosque for late-night Ramadan prayers. They stopped by a kids’s library Öztürk needed to go to. They stayed up late speaking, gaming out the best way to hold Öztürk secure from the Trump administration’s crackdown.
“She stated, ‘I feel that is going to be the final time I get to go to you,’” E. recalled. “I instructed her, ‘No, no, you’re going to have the ability to come once more, don’t fear, and I’m going to return go to you.’ That each one turned out to be unsuitable.”
The chums had stored in contact each day after parting on the prepare station. They exchanged mundane texts and voice notes about doing taxes and consuming cookies. E. despatched Öztürk a photograph of the park the place they’d walked throughout their go to. “Rümeysa! The timber are beginning to bloom once more,” she wrote.
They final texted on March 25, a pair hours earlier than Öztürk was detained on the way in which to dinner in Somerville.
E. didn’t discover out what occurred till the subsequent morning, when she stumbled off the bed earlier than daybreak for the early meal Muslims eat earlier than the each day Ramadan quick. Sipping her tea, E. scrolled via her cellphone and noticed a message that stated, “Have you ever seen this?” alongside an alert about Öztürk’s arrest.
“It was like: ‘Is that this actual? Am I nonetheless asleep?’” she recalled.
E. stated the thought of her light pal being swept into ICE custody nonetheless didn’t appear actual till later that morning, when the video was launched and he or she noticed a well-recognized determine, in the identical white jacket she’d worn on her go to.
“It was totally nauseating to observe,” E. stated. “So horrifying and so heartbreaking to see her should be so violently taken that method.”
E. and Öztürk
Credit score:
Courtesy of E.
Attempting to Be a “Good Detainee”
Two days after Öztürk’s switch to Louisiana, E. acquired a name from an odd quantity that got here up on her cellphone as “Jail/Jail.” It was Öztürk, within the first of what would turn into common check-ins at random instances of the day.
In interviews, E. confirmed ProPublica corroborating images, textual content messages and voice notes of her interactions along with her pal.
“She all the time begins with, ‘Is that this an excellent time to speak?’ And I’m, like, ‘I’ve been ready for this,’” E. stated.
Some days, Öztürk sounds upbeat. Turkish diplomats, she instructed E., had delivered her a brand new hijab. Öztürk discovered a cookbook and famous a citrus salad recipe she would possibly strive sometime. She cracked jokes about being too outdated to climb right into a bunk mattress each evening.
In a single name, Öztürk expressed reduction that she’d filed her taxes earlier than getting detained — an ideal instance, E. stated, of her overachieving pal’s wry humorousness.
“She learn the detainee handbook two instances,” E. stated. “She stated, ‘I’m making an attempt to be an excellent detainee.’”
Different calls will not be as simple, E. stated, including that she didn’t need to reveal specifics out of respect for her pal’s privateness. In these more durable talks, E. stated, she needs she may “be there to inform her it’ll be OK, give her a hug.”
NOAA Scientists Are Cleansing Bogs and Reconsidering Lab Experiments After Contracts for Primary Companies Expire
Their conversations are sprinkled with reminders that Öztürk’s nightmare may not finish quickly. She requested for assist canceling appointments and returning library books. She’s additionally within the technique of requesting a single paperback, per detention rules.
If authorised, she desires E. to seek out her a information for writing kids’s literature, ideally with workouts she may do from her cell. E. stated her coronary heart ached when Öztürk requested her to make the e book an extended one.
The calls and duties ease emotions of helplessness, E. stated, an antidote for the guilt that sneaks up on her when she walks outdoors on a sunny day.
“How is it that we’re transferring ahead,” she stated, “whereas my closest pal is rotting on this place?”
