ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of energy. Signal as much as obtain our largest tales as quickly as they’re printed.
Reporting Highlights
Shortchanged: Blue Cross Louisiana OK’d mastectomies and breast reconstructions for girls with most cancers however refused to pay a hospital’s full payments. For some claims, it paid nothing.
Exceptions: Blue Cross denied funds for 1000’s of procedures concerned in breast reconstruction. However it authorized particular offers for remedy for executives’ wives.
Verdict: A jury discovered Blue Cross accountable for fraud and awarded the hospital $421 million. The insurance coverage firm denied wrongdoing and has appealed.
These highlights have been written by the reporters and editors who labored on this story.
On a late afternoon in November 2017, Witney Arch advised her 1-1/2-year-old son to cease taking part in and are available inside. Upset, he grabbed her proper breast when she picked him up. She skilled a shock of ache however didn’t suppose it was something critical. Per week later, nonetheless, the ache had not subsided. After journeys to a number of medical doctors, a biopsy revealed that Arch had early-stage breast most cancers. Her surgeon advised her that it was seemingly invasive and aggressive.
By the top of January, she had made two crucial selections. She would get a double mastectomy. And she or he needed her operation on the Middle for Restorative Breast Surgical procedure in New Orleans, a medical facility famend for its extremely specialised strategy to breast most cancers care and reconstruction. The 2 surgeons who based it had pioneered strategies that used a lady’s personal physique tissue to type new breasts submit mastectomy. The concept of a pure restoration appealed to Arch. “I don’t choose anyone for getting implants, particularly for those who’ve had most cancers,” she mentioned. “However I felt like I used to be taking one thing international out of my physique, most cancers, and I didn’t need to put one thing international again in.”
Arch was a 42-year-old preschool instructor for her church, with 4 younger kids, residing in a suburb of New Orleans. The 1-1/2-year-old had been born with Sturge-Weber syndrome, a uncommon neurological dysfunction. Caring for him consumed her life. By nature upbeat and optimistic, Arch felt blessed that her son’s act of defiance had led to an early prognosis. “We’re going to hope about this and we’re going to determine it out,” she advised her husband.
Arch requested her insurer, Blue Cross and Blue Defend of Louisiana, for approval to go to the middle for her care, and the corporate granted it, a course of referred to as prior authorization. Then, per week or so earlier than her surgical procedure, Arch was wrangling little one care and meal plans when she obtained a name from the insurer. The consultant on the road was attempting to steer her to have the surgical procedure elsewhere. She urged Arch to hunt a hospital that, not like the middle, was in community and charged much less. “Do you understand how a lot that is going to price?” Arch remembered the agent asking. Arch didn’t want extra stress, however right here it was — from her personal well being plan. “I really feel very comfy with my resolution,” she replied. “My physician teaches different medical doctors all over the world how to do that.” Over the subsequent yr, Arch underwent 5 operations to rid herself of most cancers and reconstruct her breasts.
Witney Arch acquired authorization from Blue Cross and Blue Defend of Louisiana for her mastectomy and breast restoration, however the insurer didn’t pay the complete invoice from the Middle for Restorative Breast Surgical procedure.
Credit score:
Daniella Zalcman for ProPublica
Arch didn’t comprehend it on the time, however her surgical procedure would turn out to be proof in a long-running authorized battle between the breast middle’s founders, surgeons Frank DellaCroce and Scott Sullivan, and Blue Cross, Louisiana’s largest medical insurance firm, with an estimated two-thirds share of the market. DellaCroce and Sullivan had repeatedly sued the insurer, alleging that it granted approvals for surgical procedure however then denied funds or paid solely a fraction of sufferers’ payments. They pointed to calls just like the one Arch acquired as proof of the corporate’s effort to drive away sufferers. The aggressive authorized assault, they knew, was fraught. Litigation in opposition to the $3.4 billion firm would take a very long time and some huge cash. The possibilities of profitable have been slight. “You battle dragons at nice peril,” DellaCroce would inform mates. However this September, after 18 years and several other defeats in courtroom, jurors discovered Blue Cross accountable for fraud. They awarded the middle $421 million — one of many largest verdicts ever to a single medical follow exterior of a class-action lawsuit. In an announcement, Blue Cross mentioned it “disagrees with the jury’s resolution, which we imagine was incorrect on the info and the legislation. We’ve got filed an enchantment and count on to achieve success.”
Frustration with insurers is at an all-time excessive. The December deadly taking pictures of United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson allegedly by Luigi Mangione serves as an excessive and tragic instance. Medical doctors and insurers are locked right into a perpetual battle over well being care prices, with sufferers caught within the center. Medical doctors accuse insurance policy of blocking funds for well being care therapies that may save the sufferers’ lives. Insurance coverage firms insist they shouldn’t pay for procedures that they are saying are pointless or overpriced. It’s simple to emerge from an examination of the American well being care system with a cynicism that each side are damaged and corrupt.
Nevertheless, interviews with scores of medical doctors, sufferers and insurance coverage executives, in addition to opinions of inner paperwork, regulatory filings and educational research, reveal a basic reality: The 2 sides will not be evenly matched. Insurance coverage firms are gamers within the battle over cash, and they’re additionally the referees. Insurers produce their very own pointers to find out whether or not to pay claims. When a health care provider appeals a denial, insurers make all of the preliminary selections. In authorized settings, insurers are sometimes given favorable standing of their potential to set what circumstances they’re required to cowl. Federal and state insurance coverage regulators lack the assets to pursue particular person complaints in opposition to multibillion-dollar firms. Six main insurers, which embrace a few of the nation’s largest firms, cowl half of all Individuals. They’re pitted in opposition to tens of 1000’s of medical doctors’ practices and huge hospital chains.
The Blue Cross trial gives a uncommon alternative to show intimately the ways in which medical insurance firms wield energy over medical doctors and their sufferers. Blue Cross executives testified that the breast middle charged an excessive amount of cash — typically greater than $180,000 for an operation. The middle, they mentioned, deserved particular consideration as a result of it had a historical past of questionable fees. However the insurer’s protection went even additional, to the very that means of “prior authorization,” which it had granted ladies like Arch to pursue surgical procedure. The authorization, they mentioned in courtroom, acknowledged {that a} process was medically essential, but it surely additionally contained a clause that it was “not a assure of cost.” Blue Cross was not obliged to pay the middle something, high executives testified. “Let me be clear: The authorization by no means says we’re going to pay you,” mentioned Steven Udvarhelyi, who was the CEO for the insurer from 2016 to 2024, in a deposition. “That’s why there’s a disclaimer.
From 2015 by way of 2023, the Baton Rouge-based insurer paid, on common, lower than 9% of the fees billed by the breast middle for greater than 7,800 particular person medical procedures — despite the fact that it had approved all of them. 1000’s of such claims have been by no means paid in any respect, in keeping with courtroom data. Testimony revealed that the well being plan by no means thought-about 1000’s of appeals filed by the middle. Company paperwork confirmed Blue Cross executives had arrange secret processes for approving operations and reimbursing the clinic and its medical doctors that resulted in lowered charges and cost delays. One profitable technique: A national-level coverage allowed Blue Cross Louisiana to take a lower of any financial savings it achieved in paying the breast middle on behalf of sufferers lined by out-of-state Blue Cross firms, that means the much less the insurer paid out, the extra it earned.
Let me be clear: The authorization by no means says we’re going to pay you. That’s why there’s a disclaimer.
—Steven Udvarhelyi, former Blue Cross and Blue Defend of Louisiana CEO
In Sullivan’s phrases, the insurer was hypocritical, “morally bankrupt.” Blue Cross had stranded most of the middle’s sufferers with excessive payments, quantities that it had absorbed through the years. On a number of events, although, Blue Cross executives had signed particular one-time offers with the middle, referred to as single case agreements, to pay for his or her wives’ most cancers remedy. To Sullivan, it appeared the insurer was prepared to pay the middle when sufferers had connections however would battle when sufferers didn’t.
Blue Cross declined to touch upon any particular person circumstances however mentioned in an announcement that single case agreements have been “frequent within the business” and have been out there to all members when wanted to entry out-of-network suppliers.
Dr. Scott Sullivan, left, and Dr. Frank DellaCroce, the founding surgeons of the Middle for Restorative Breast Surgical procedure and St. Charles Surgical Hospital
Credit score:
Daniella Zalcman for ProPublica
Chapter 1
The Middle
No one would take the breast middle and its adjoining hospital as an unusual medical institution. The 2 services take up a metropolis block alongside St. Charles Avenue, the thoroughfare well-known for its streetcars, Mardi Gras parades and Queen Anne mansions. Sufferers entry the advanced — created by merging a former legislation workplace, funeral residence, automobile dealership and Dunkin’ Donuts — by driving round again the place a porte cochere leads right into a hovering atrium. Mild pours in by way of home windows set within the excessive ceiling. Preparations of white orchids are scattered amongst comfy couches and chairs. Right here, ladies seek the advice of with medical doctors to plan their remedy. Surgical procedures are carried out on the 39-bed hospital, which has an Icee machine in a household room. New-age music performs softly all through the constructing. Rooms are designed to be as homey as potential, with medical gear hidden away and seascapes by a neighborhood artist hanging on the wall. One affected person’s husband referred to it as a “spa-spital.”
The concept of mixing the posh really feel of an upscale cosmetic surgery follow with the mission-driven zeal of a medical clinic got here to DellaCroce and Sullivan whereas they have been younger surgeons. The 2 grew up in Louisiana. Sullivan spent a lot of his childhood in Mandeville, a suburb of New Orleans on the north facet of Lake Ponchartrain, his dad employed within the oil and fuel business. His mom needed him to be a priest or a health care provider. “I undoubtedly was not going to turn out to be a priest,” he mentioned. DellaCroce’s father labored on the paper mill in West Monroe within the state’s northern neck. His mom, a nurse, gave him an appreciation for medication as a profession that was “significant and difficult.”
They turned mates whereas working on the Louisiana State College medical middle, the place they earned the nickname “the Sushi Brothers” for his or her favourite lunch. They have been drawn to microsurgery and breast reconstruction as a result of it was an rising area that was innovating and enhancing care. Each males turned board-certified in cosmetic surgery. Sullivan, 60, is the hard-charging businessman, stocky, direct and blunt. DellaCroce, 58, with a ponytail, goatee and gentle drawl, is extra the diplomat, affected person and cerebral. The pair have lectured all over the world and written quite a few medical journal articles.
A affected person room within the St. Charles Surgical Hospital in New Orleans
Credit score:
Daniella Zalcman for ProPublica
They opened their first workplace in 2003 in a single room rented from a fellow physician at what was then referred to as Memorial Medical Middle, the hulking personal hospital in New Orleans. They carried out operations at services all through the area however discovered that almost all gave little consideration to their sufferers’ consolation. They needed to construct a unique type of hospital. “Can we give them that little bit of additional with out breaking the price range to make the expertise much less terrible? Can’t make it nice, however are you able to make it much less terrible?” DellaCroce defined. “Are you able to attend to the human facet of this affected person and provides them the added worth of peace and confidence?” Hurricane Katrina set again their building plans, and the brand new edifice, named the St. Charles Surgical Hospital, didn’t open its doorways till 2009. It boasts of being the one hospital within the nation devoted solely to look after breast most cancers sufferers who’ve acquired mastectomies. The middle doesn’t present radiation or chemotherapy therapies. The vast majority of sufferers come from out of state.
Ladies in search of to have their breasts restored after a mastectomy face two paths. Some select a comparatively easy surgical process utilizing implants stuffed with silicon or one other gel. The middle specializes within the different possibility, what’s referred to as autologous tissue reconstruction, the place a lady’s personal fats is taken from one a part of the physique, like the underside or the abdomen, and used to rebuild the breast. The process requires an extended restoration time, however the brand new breasts turn out to be a part of the physique.
The transplant surgical procedure is prolonged and sophisticated. Operations can last as long as 12 hours with large medical groups concerned. One surgeon performs the mastectomy whereas one other creates a brand new breast by knitting collectively layers of fats and tissue. Focus is intense. The surgeons stare by way of glasses with microscopes to attach new blood vessels with a needle that’s thinner than an eyelash, utilizing thread lower than half the width of a human hair. DellaCroce and Sullivan invented strategies, for instance, permitting tissue to be taken from a number of websites when a lady didn’t have sufficient fats in a single a part of her physique for a full restoration.
Sullivan operates on a affected person at St. Charles Surgical Hospital.
Credit score:
Daniella Zalcman for ProPublica
One afternoon final fall, DellaCroce strode right into a cavernous working room to test on a affected person. On the desk in entrance of him, a lady lay lined in curtains of blue surgical fabric, solely her torso uncovered. Earlier within the day, a surgical oncologist had eliminated her proper breast as a part of a mastectomy to deal with her most cancers. Later, one other surgeon had taken flaps of fats from her abdomen and interlaced them with blood vessels to create a brand new breast to switch the misplaced one. Now, within the fifth hour of surgical procedure, a doctor’s assistant leaned over her midsection, closing an incision alongside her facet with some last stitches. Nurses hurried across the area, getting ready to wrap up the operation. Paul Simon’s “You Can Name Me Al” performed within the background. The scent of burnt flesh hung within the air. A blue mild signaled that the brand new arteries have been efficiently pumping blood. “Wow, that girl appears to be like actually good,” DellaCroce advised the doctor’s assistant. “Good job.”
There isn’t any denying that the middle’s high-end remedy means excessive prices. The median cost for an operation and hospital keep is about $165,000. DellaCroce and Sullivan employed consultants to assessment different well-regarded practices, who suggested them their costs have been aggressive with their friends. “We weren’t asking to be paid Lebron James, better of the most effective, despite the fact that we really feel we’re within the high 1 or 2% of the nation,” Sullivan mentioned. “We simply needed one thing honest.”
Chapter 2
Blue Cross and Blue Defend
It is among the quirks of the American well being care system that insurers virtually by no means pay the costs for procedures demanded by medical doctors and hospitals.
To grasp why requires a tour of the grand cut price on the coronary heart of the medical insurance system. Insurance coverage firms negotiate with hospitals and medical doctors to low cost reimbursements on medical procedures, like workplace visits or MRI scans. Suppliers who signal these contracts are in community. Insurance coverage firms like in-network medical doctors as a result of they will price range for well being bills and set premiums accordingly. Medical doctors and hospitals comply with be in community as a result of they get a gradual stream of insured sufferers.
DellaCroce and Sullivan held contracts with insurers that resulted in common funds to the middle’s medical doctors within the $20,000 to $30,000 vary. However DellaCroce and Sullivan by no means got here to an settlement with Blue Cross. That made them an exception in Louisiana — the insurer is so dominant that 97% of native physicians and hospitals are in community. DellaCroce and Sullivan mentioned the corporate was not providing them sufficient cash — in some circumstances not even sufficient to cowl the price of the surgical procedures, they argued in courtroom paperwork. The medical doctors and their hospital remained out of community, that means they charged Blue Cross the complete value for his or her procedures.
Such fees are controversial. Insurance coverage firms and lots of well being specialists say they’re too typically inflated and untethered from precise prices. Physicians and hospitals say their charges are justified, reflecting the true value of medical care. Ultimately, insurers — particularly in states like Louisiana, with few opponents — use their market energy in negotiations to set reimbursements at what they need to pay, not what medical doctors cost.
At Blue Cross, Dwight Brower was charged with reviewing the payments from the breast middle. He had labored as a doctor at a small household follow in Baton Rouge after which at a neighborhood hospital earlier than becoming a member of Blue Cross as a medical director. He helped oversee prior authorizations. Whereas many sufferers assume that an approval means an insurer can pay for an operation, it’s merely a recognition {that a} process is medically essential. Federal legislation mandates that non-public insurers cowl breast restorations for girls who bear mastectomies due to most cancers or genetic threat. And sufferers, on the whole, are allowed to decide on their very own medical doctors.
Nevertheless, for the reason that middle was out of community and had no contract with the insurer, Blue Cross decided how a lot it might pay for the remedy, and Brower believed that the breast middle’s payments have been exorbitant. “I didn’t suppose that they have been affordable,” he would later testify. Surgeons doing lung transplants or mind surgical procedure hardly ever billed Blue Cross greater than $50,000 for his or her work. Why ought to DellaCroce and Sullivan get a lot extra? “Don’t get me incorrect. The surgeons on the middle are extraordinarily expert,” he acknowledged. The operations have been typically prolonged. “However so are open-heart surgical procedures,” he mentioned. “Relative to a few of the different extraordinarily difficult surgical procedures accomplished by different surgeons in different areas of the physique, it simply appeared like their price schedule was extraordinarily excessive.”
Blue Cross Louisiana executives testified that they didn’t even contemplate medical doctors’ invoices when making selections on what to reimburse as a result of such fees have been “unregulated” and “nonstandard.” As an alternative, they paid “an quantity we set up” — except the physician’s invoice was cheaper. Ultimately, the insurer mentioned it settled on reimbursing the breast middle about the identical as in-network medical doctors performing comparable operations, despite the fact that DellaCroce and Sullivan didn’t profit from having sufferers referred to them. In follow, that meant the insurer paid out a fraction of the breast middle’s payments. Of the 7,837 medical procedures in dispute within the lawsuit, involving 1,680 sufferers, Blue Cross paid about $43 million on invoices totaling $500 million. Some 60% of the claims weren’t reimbursed in any respect. The distinction between the invoice and the cost might be putting. For instance, within the case of Arch, Blue Cross paid $8,580 out of $102,722 for one operation. For an additional, it paid $3,190 out of $34,975.
Essentially, I feel their drawback was that we have been medical doctors who had management. That was thought to be a menace.
—Dr. Frank DellaCroce, Middle for Restorative Breast Surgical procedure co-founder
Executives mentioned the Blue Cross reimbursements have been honest, designed to maintain premiums low for the almost 2 million Louisianans who trusted the insurer to cowl their well being care. Paying the breast middle’s full charges would add to its clients’ burden, they mentioned. “If we have been to simply comply with any charges or any costs set by physicians or any suppliers, it might trigger price to be exorbitantly excessive for each the plan and for members notably, as a result of we wouldn’t be capable of forecast or make sure that these plans are literally sound,” mentioned Curtis Anders, the vice chairman of supplier networks for Blue Cross. “Premiums would enhance.”
For a lot of out-of-network medical doctors, funds decrease than their invoices are an infuriating a part of doing enterprise. They soak up the prices, or move them on to their sufferers, a follow referred to as stability billing that can lead to medical debt. DellaCroce and Sullivan have been the uncommon physicians with the tenacity to battle. The middle collected cash from each insurers and sufferers — but it surely carried the unpaid portion of invoices on its books. That quantity grew yearly because it battled Blue Cross.
DellaCroce and Sullivan have been satisfied that Blue Cross had singled them out for his or her obstreperousness, however that they had no proof. Then, throughout a cellphone name at some point, an worker for the middle was speaking to a Blue Cross consultant to acquire a previous authorization. The consultant let slip that the request required particular dealing with. The breast middle’s medical doctors have been flagged on an inner roster. It was referred to as the focused record.
Chapter 3
Discoveries
On Dec. 8, 2023, a number of dozen attorneys and paralegals from Chehardy Sherman Williams, one among New Orleans’ high legislation corporations, have been celebrating their annual vacation social gathering. They’d gathered in a personal eating room with gilded mirrors and shimmering chandeliers at Arnaud’s restaurant, a bastion of Creole delicacies within the coronary heart of the French Quarter. The waiters served shrimp remoulade, prime rib and turtle soup. Small speak stuffed the air.
Abruptly, a number of attorneys’ cellphones buzzed as all of them acquired the identical electronic mail, a message from the legal professionals for Blue Cross. It contained discovery for the case, greater than 42,000 pages of inner paperwork, emails and insurance policies. Matthew Sherman, one of many attorneys representing the middle, turned to a colleague. “Are you able to imagine this?” he requested. It was like one thing from a John Grisham novel, the type of factor he and his mates had joked about at legislation college, a doc dump at Christmas time. By lengthy custom, lots of New Orleans’ largest legislation corporations maintain their vacation events on the identical Friday afternoon in December. Afterward, rival attorneys from round city collect for drinks beneath a flag of truce at a neighborhood bar. Sherman realized there can be no afterparty this yr. Nor a lot of a vacation trip.
The supply of the paperwork was a Christmas reward almost 20 years within the making. DellaCroce and Sullivan’s first lawsuits in opposition to Blue Cross, involving 88 breach-of-contract claims filed in a Louisiana civil courtroom starting in 2006, have been dismissed due to a federal courtroom ruling relating to jurisdiction. A second lawsuit, which lasted from 2010 by way of 2017, resulted in restricted discovery and a two-day trial in federal courtroom. Jurors discovered that Blue Cross had failed to inform the middle how a lot it might pay for procedures, however additionally they dominated the middle had not been financially harmed. A choose dismissed the remaining claims.
DellaCroce and Sullivan launched their third lawsuit in February 2017 with a novel authorized principle: They accused Blue Cross of fraud. They contended that for years the insurer had issued prior authorizations with out the intention of paying the precise payments. Their legal professionals had sought the focused record throughout discovery to assist show the case. Blue Cross denied it existed.
However now, as Sherman and fellow legal professional Patrick Follette started poring over the 1000’s of paperwork, they came across a spreadsheet that mentioned “Focused Supplier Listing.” The primary names on the record have been DellaCroce and Sullivan. It was labeled “confidential” and dated June 2007 — a couple of yr after the pair had filed their first lawsuit in opposition to Blue Cross alleging nonpayment. Extra digging turned up different paperwork. There was a “blocked” record that additionally featured the 2 medical doctors.
A company coverage doc supplied what DellaCroce and Sullivan thought-about probably the most revealing rationalization for Blue Cross’ monetary motivation. Blue Cross insurers are unbiased firms that function beneath a standard algorithm, much like franchisees in a fast-food chain. When an individual lined by Blue Cross of their residence state receives remedy in one other state, the Blue Cross the place the remedy happens pays the supplier after which recoups the price from the home-state plan. What the attorneys found was that Blue Cross Louisiana would obtain a share of any financial savings it might generate for the home-state plan. Say, for example, Blue Cross Alabama was dealing with a invoice of $5,000 for a process. If Blue Cross Louisiana as a substitute paid $1,000, it saved the Alabama plan $4,000. The coverage allowed Blue Cross Louisiana to earn 16% of the financial savings — on this state of affairs, $640.
For DellaCroce and Sullivan, the revelations cemented their perception that Blue Cross was a nasty company actor extra excited about energy and management than well being care. The proportion price incentivized the insurer to pay the medical doctors as little as potential. The larger the financial savings, the extra Blue Cross made. “It’s win-win,” DellaCroce mentioned. “That’s their pay day.”
Because the trial approached, Blue Cross tried to settle the case. DellaCroce and Sullivan refused the provide as too low.
James Williams, left, and Matthew Sherman, the legal professionals who represented DellaCroce and Sullivan of their swimsuit in opposition to Blue Cross and Blue Defend of Louisiana
Credit score:
Daniella Zalcman for ProPublica
Chapter 4
The Trial
On the afternoon of Sept. 5, 2024, the case — St. Charles Surgical Hospital, L.L.C. and Middle for Restorative Breast Surgical procedure, L.L.C. v. Louisiana Well being Service & Indemnity Firm D/B/A Blue Cross/Blue Defend of Louisiana, Blue Cross & Blue Defend of Louisiana, Inc. and HMO Louisiana, Inc. — opened in Division C of the Orleans Parish Civil District Courtroom, a high-ceilinged room with darkish brown benches and tables, pretend marble columns and fluorescent lights. James Williams, the chief litigator for the hospital, had already impressed the 45 potential jurors by memorizing all their names and backgrounds throughout jury choice. Now, he stood up and positioned a soccer on the plaintiff’s desk in entrance of the 12 chosen to strive the case, which included a 3rd grade instructor, a film stunt double and a lodge supervisor. He warned them that they might hear numerous “insurance coverage speak” from Blue Cross. “I’m going to ask you, girls and gents on the jury, preserve your eye on the ball. Maintain your eye on what this case is about,” Williams advised them. “If they begin saying issues like, ‘Nicely, oh, we paid them what we thought was honest, 9%,’ preserve your eye on the ball, proper?”
Over 10 days — interrupted by a two-day break to permit a hurricane to move throughout Louisiana — Williams made his case that Blue Cross had defrauded his purchasers by making guarantees to pay however failing to ship.
A lot of Blue Cross’ protection had relied on the discover {that a} prior authorization was no assure of cost. The insurer had not dedicated fraud, it mentioned, because it by no means explicitly promised the middle to reimburse something. Udvarhelyi, the previous CEO, had insisted on that. However on the stand, Blue Cross witnesses supplied a extra nuanced rationalization. They acknowledged that the disclaimer was not meant as a common excuse to free the corporate from paying payments. A previous authorization “often” resulted in a cost, testified Brower, who reviewed the middle’s payments. He mentioned that the discover was supposed for particular conditions. As an illustration, Blue Cross wouldn’t cowl a lady who dropped out of her insurance coverage earlier than the operation. Nor wouldn’t it pay something if a affected person had not met her deductible. However in any other case, Brower mentioned, Blue Cross supposed to compensate for a process that it had approved. “It’s inappropriate for us as an organization to approve a code after which flip round and deny it,” Brower mentioned.
In the course of the trial, Williams advised jurors to “preserve your eye on the ball.”
Credit score:
Daniella Zalcman for ProPublica
Over time, the middle had appealed 1000’s of reimbursements for being too low. It employed further staff to handle the paperwork. On the trial, Blue Cross revealed that it had by no means thought-about any of the appeals — nor had it ever advised the middle that they have been pointless. “An enchantment is just not out there to assessment an underpayment,” acknowledged Paula Shepherd, a Blue Cross government vice chairman. The insurer merely issued an edict — the cost was right.
This was the core of the case. The insurer set the principles. The insurer set the costs. Medical doctors might enchantment to a state insurance coverage regulator. But when that failed, and it typically did, the one recourse was a protracted, expensive lawsuit.
Williams summed up for the jury the middle’s remedy by the hands of Blue Cross: “Our funds are sluggish pay, low pay or no pay.”
In countering these arguments, Blue Cross witnesses defined that the insurer was dedicated to paying for Louisianans’ well being care and retaining prices low. As a nonprofit, it directed any extra income from operations again into the enterprise. (Udvarhelyi, the CEO, did acknowledge that his wage, over $1 million, included bonuses that trusted hitting income targets and rising membership.)
Brian West, a Blue Cross government who monitored funds, mentioned the middle had engaged in “egregious” billing practices. “They’re dangerous actors within the billing world,” he mentioned. However firm witnesses supplied solely a handful of examples. Generally the middle mistakenly coded its payments in a approach that appeared to cost for 4 separate breast reconstructions in a single operation. In different circumstances, the middle requested for cost for 2 surgeons within the room on the identical time. However Blue Cross, following Medicare pointers, would pay two surgeons solely 20% greater than the reimbursement for a single surgeon.
An enchantment is just not out there to assessment an underpayment.
—Paula Shepherd, Blue Cross Louisiana government vice chairman
Blue Cross didn’t accuse the middle of any intentional miscoding — however the sloppy billing led to further scrutiny, the corporate’s witnesses mentioned. The focused record, a witness testified, had been created particularly for the middle, requiring all prior authorization requests to bypass regular routes for a particular assessment by firm medical doctors. The blocked record meant that every invoice from the middle acquired a handbook scrub by cost specialists earlier than reimbursement. Blue Cross acknowledged the cautious checking typically resulted within the want for extra data from the middle, which might lead to slower processing of claims. However the lists, executives insisted, weren’t designed to cut back funds. “Principally, no hurt was accomplished,” mentioned Becky Juncker, who was concerned in approving surgical procedures.
Firm witnesses defined that the 16% acquired in saving cash for out-of-state Blue Cross insurers was a price to cowl the prices of dealing with changes of the declare — although they weren’t in a position to clarify why Blue Cross didn’t cost a flat price for its companies.
Blue Cross additionally defended itself in opposition to the accusation that it had paid nothing for 60% of the fees for particular person procedures. Witnesses mentioned the insurer had adopted business follow in bundling fees to make a single cost for an operation. An legal professional for the middle famous that it had by no means agreed to take bundled funds — Blue Cross had imposed them.
As to the calls to ladies like Arch? That was an effort to save lots of members cash. “Our medical space would attain out to our members who have been using out-of-network suppliers to assist them perceive the, I’d say, the monetary implications,” mentioned Shepherd, the Blue Cross government vice chairman, in a deposition. “It might be financially catastrophic to a member to have an out-of-network declare that they’re financially answerable for. It’s an enormous distinction.”
In summing up the case, Kim Boyle, the lead legal professional for the corporate, advised jurors that Blue Cross had not dedicated fraud. It had acted to make sure the corporate and its members paid a good value for the middle’s companies, she mentioned. “There’s no scheme. There’s no plot. There’s no mafia. There are not any Blue Cross staff of Louisiana which can be sitting in some smoke-filled room in Baton Rouge, plotting in opposition to these plaintiffs on St. Charles Avenue in New Orleans,” Boyle mentioned. “It’s fiction; it’s fancy; it’s utterly made up.”
On Sept. 20, at 1:57 p.m., Choose Sidney H. Cates IV despatched the jurors to deliberate. The middle attorneys retreated to a close-by lodge to await the decision. About two hours later, they have been summoned again to Division C. Williams put his head down and swore. He anxious that such a fast return within the legally advanced case meant victory for Blue Cross.
The middle’s legal professionals paid shut consideration to Cates as he reviewed the jurors’ resolution. It was a two-page type. If the jurors present in favor of Blue Cross, the choose would don’t have any purpose to learn on. Cates flipped to the second web page: The jurors had discovered Blue Cross accountable for fraud. “Please categorical in {dollars} the entire financial compensation, if any, Blue Cross owes the hospital and the middle for the damages,” Cates mentioned, studying from the decision. “Web damages, $421,488,633.” The middle’s legal professionals stood and shook palms because the insurer’s attorneys ready to depart the courtroom.
DellaCroce was in surgical procedure on the hospital, having anticipated an extended deliberation. Sullivan was within the courtroom to listen to the decision. Afterward, jurors approached and thanked him for his work. He teared up. “We’d have given extra if we had been requested for extra. That’s how egregious the fraud was,” Juliet Laughlin, a 58-year-old property supervisor who served as forewoman, later mentioned. “There had been incorrect accomplished.”
“Not Medically Crucial”: Contained in the Firm Serving to America’s Largest Well being Insurers Deny Protection for Care
Blue Cross has appealed the decision. A medical insurance commerce group has warned that the discovering units a harmful precedent. If allowed to face, insurance coverage firms in Louisiana could discover themselves compelled to pay no matter value is demanded by out-of-network medical doctors — which in flip might increase medical insurance premiums throughout the state, the Louisiana Affiliation of Well being Plans mentioned in an announcement.
For DellaCroce and Sullivan, the decision was vindication. They’d refused to signal contracts they thought unfair. They’d rejected settlement gives they thought too low. The trial had revealed Blue Cross’ domineering conduct. “Essentially, I feel their drawback was that we have been medical doctors who had management,” DellaCroce mentioned. “That was thought to be a menace.”
Within the months for the reason that judgment, Blue Cross has not modified its practices, the medical doctors mentioned. It has not approached with a proposal that will carry the hospital in community. It nonetheless points prior authorizations for girls’s surgical procedures. And it nonetheless pays solely a fraction of the billed charges.
How We Reported the Story
This account is predicated on a assessment of 1000’s of pages of trial transcripts, depositions, federal and state courtroom data, and inner company paperwork from Blue Cross and Blue Defend of Louisiana, the Middle for Restorative Breast Surgical procedure and the St. Charles Surgical Hospital; scores of interviews with medical doctors, sufferers and insurance coverage executives; medical data; regulatory filings; and studies by lecturers, specialists and the Louisiana state Senate. Some company paperwork mentioned in courtroom have been positioned beneath seal after the trial’s conclusion. Blue Cross and Blue Defend of Louisiana was supplied an in depth record of questions and responded with a written assertion, cited partly within the story. The corporate declined to make any staff out there for an interview. Former Blue Cross CEO Steven Udvarhelyi declined to remark, and former worker Dwight Brower didn’t reply to cellphone calls or emails.
Freelance photographer Daniella Zalcman contributed reporting.
