Daniel Kucin Jr.-Imagn Photos
Completely happy Saturday, everybody, and welcome to the primary version of the FanGraphs Weekly Mailbag! We’ve received so much to cowl right this moment, together with the right way to repair the Braves, how the Orioles would possibly fare in the event that they promote on the deadline, essentially the most enjoyable performs to guide off video games, and a lot extra.
However earlier than we get there, I’d wish to remind all of you that whereas anybody can submit a query, this mailbag is unique to FanGraphs Members. For those who aren’t but a Member and want to preserve studying, you may join a Membership right here. It’s the easiest way to each expertise the positioning and assist our workers, and it comes with a bunch of different nice advantages. Additionally, in case you’d wish to ask a query for subsequent week’s mailbag, ship me an e mail at mailbag@fangraphs.com.
OK, that’s sufficient housekeeping. Let’s get to the primary query, which involves us from certainly one of our worldwide readers!
__
I’m simply questioning if it’s bizarre that the Twins have had two seasons in a row with successful streaks equal to or better than 12 video games after a completely rubbish begin. We didn’t actually have a magic piece of preserved meat this 12 months. Can we learn into these tea leaves in any respect? Does God exist and, assuming they do exist, what has Minnesota baseball ever carried out to them? — Incomprehensibly Irrational in Eire
After performing some Stathead analysis, plainly you may not be “Incomprehensibly Irrational” in spite of everything, since you’re onto one thing right here. The Twins are the second crew within the Divisional Period to have successful streaks of 12 or extra video games in back-to-back seasons. Cleveland received 14 straight video games in 2016, from June 17 via July 1; the following 12 months, from August 24 via September 14, Cleveland ripped off 22 straight wins, the longest single-season successful streak since at the very least 1901, which is way back to Stathead’s analysis goes. These Cleveland groups have been each actually good, although. The 2016 membership went to the World Collection, and was 35-30 getting into play on June 17; the 2017 crew received 102 video games, most within the American League, and was 69-56 getting into play on August 24.
The closest comparability I may discover to those Twins are the Chicago Cubs in 1927 and 1928. Chicago received 12 straight video games in 1927, however that streak started on June 5 — later than the 2 Minnesota streaks. These Cubs began sluggish, too, although 4-7 is just not as tough a begin because the Twins of the final two years, who have been six video games beneath .500 when their successful streak started final season and as many as eight video games beneath .500 this 12 months. Additionally, by the point the 1927 Cubs started their successful streak, they have been three video games above .500, at 22-19. The subsequent 12 months, the Cubs had a 13-game successful streak, starting on Might 5, once they have been three video games beneath .500. They completed the season 91-63, good for third within the Nationwide League.
So, all that is to say the Twins are the one crew ever to start successful streaks of 12 video games or extra earlier than the beginning of June in back-to-back seasons, and in case you prolong the timeframe to the primary week of June to additionally embody the 1927-28 Cubs, the Twins are nonetheless the one crew to win at the very least 12 video games in consecutive seasons after being greater than three video games beneath .500 in every year. Positive, that’s a particular subset with plenty of qualifiers, however the Twins are a bizarre crew! Late final August, as a part of the cross-country street journey that I wrote about for FanGraphs, I ended and noticed a Twins sport at Goal Area. Regardless of their place within the standings — they have been 72-60 and held the third Wild Card spot — they appeared fully lifeless. Their outfield play was sloppy; their plate appearances have been uninspired. Watching them in opposition to the Braves, one other disappointing crew, I may really feel Minnesota’s pending collapse. Hopefully, for each you and my grandma, who’s a die-hard Twins fan from Brainerd, Minnesota, the 2025 Twins received’t endure the identical destiny down the stretch as final 12 months’s membership did. Contemplating their rotation has essentially the most WAR within the majors and Byron Buxton is (knock on wooden) wholesome and performing properly, I believe there’s a reasonably good probability that they are going to be simply nice.
__
What’s the most enjoyable play to guide off a sport? – Ben Lederman
Such a pleasant query, Ben! I instantly considered an inside-the-park house run, and I imply a clear one, with none errors that will put the “little league house run” asterisk on it. Give me Oneil Cruz at Coors Area, rocketing a line drive into the right-center hole in a sport when the Rockies are giving Brenton Doyle the time off. Cruz blasts the ball so exhausting that it caroms off the wall at a bizarre angle, and due to the surprising route of the ricochet, it takes backup middle fielder Mickey Moniak just a little extra time to choose it up. Cruz is rounding third when Moniak unleashes an ideal throw to cut-off man Ezequiel Tovar, who fires a virtually flawless one-hopper house. In a single movement, catcher Hunter Goodman snags it off the bounce, drops to his knee, and swipes his mitt to his left. Concurrently, in an try to keep away from the tag, the 6-foot-7 Cruz leaps head first towards the world the place Goodman had been squatting earlier than the pitch and extends his left hand to the purpose of the plate. It’s bang-bang. The umpire alerts protected!
I additionally requested a few of my FanGraphs colleagues what they thought. Right here’s what they needed to say:
Davy Andrews: I’d argue for a loopy wild pitch, one which hits approach up excessive on the web or sails approach behind the batter. It actually makes you marvel what’s going to occur subsequent, and whether or not the sport goes to get bizarre instantly.
Ben Clemens: I’m a defense-first man, so I wish to see this: Leadoff hitter hits a ball within the hole and will get thrown out attempting to stretch it to a double.
James Fegan: A brawl to guide off a sport actually places you on look ahead to the following 9 innings.
Jay Jaffe: I’ll go together with just a little league house run.
Esteban Rivera: I at all times love an extended at-bat to begin a sport, like at the very least 10 pitches.
Leo Morgenstern: I’m going easy. I believe it’s only a no-doubter, first-pitch house run.
Kiri Oler: I do know it’s not technically a “play,” however I like a pleasant bee delay to begin a sport.
Davy Andrews: Yeah, I’d like to alter mine to that one.
Kiri Oler: I simply suppose we are able to all use a pleasant reminder that as a lot as we’d wish to suppose we’re in management, Mom Nature nonetheless runs issues round right here.
Jake Mailhot: A house run (little league or customary fare) might be the fitting reply, however I’ll argue for a three-pitch strikeout with three whiffs. Instantly places you on discover that the pitcher is feeling it right this moment, and one thing could be cooking.
Lucas Kelly: Bunt single.
__
As a Braves fan, my query is concerning the Braves offense – particularly, how do you repair it? With so many lineup regulars locked into multi-year contracts, and nothing of observe within the minors, is there something even to be carried out besides wait it out? The Braves fired their third base coach and introduced again Fredi González, which looks as if the form of transfer that was solely made as a result of Alex Anthopoulos has an excessive amount of respect for Brian Snitker to fireplace him midseason. I’m afraid that what we’ve seen from the Braves in 2024 and 2025 is nearer to what they really are, versus the great 2023. Ought to I’ve any motive for optimism that they are going to rebound? — Matt W., Nashville
The Braves are in a troublesome place in the event that they wish to repair their offense. They don’t have plenty of prepared assist in the minors, as you observe, and don’t seem to have plenty of surplus expertise to commerce, however one place the place they might afford to make a transfer is at catcher… the place they did simply get assist from the minors and created a surplus. With prime prospect Drake Baldwin breaking camp with the crew and thriving in tandem with Sean Murphy, the Braves have an enviable pair of backstops, however which may be a luxurious they must forgo to fill different wants. They may promote excessive on Murphy, who has rebounded from a tough 2024 to hit for a 123 wRC+ and is signed via 2028. Good catching is at all times in brief provide, and the Braves do have James McCann, a reliable if unspectacular backup, stashed at Triple-A Gwinnett. Positive, it will be a bummer to commerce a productive hitter away from an offense that wants assist, however with Marcell Ozuna parked at DH, both Baldwin or Murphy is sitting on most days.
Moreover, the Braves do have just a few below-market contracts, which provides them some room to maneuver; they’ll shake issues up in the event that they wish to. Ozzie Albies is making $7 million this 12 months with choices on the similar value for every of the following two. A crew that’s extra dedicated to successful than bean-counting may simply eat his remaining dedication or promote low and commerce for a greater second baseman — not that it may be simply carried out with out weakening another a part of the roster or system. Michael Harris II, who’s signed via 2030, has been horrible on the plate, however velocity and protection give his worth a ground, making him a buy-low risk for a crew keen to provide extra quick assist in return.
Past that, there’s motive to attend — and even be optimistic. Jurickson Profar shall be eligible to return from his 80-game PED suspension on June 29. That ought to assist in left area, the place Alex Verdugo and associates have mixed for -1.0 WAR. It’s additionally not unreasonable to hope for some optimistic regression from Matt Olson and Austin Riley, each of whom have scalded the ball however are properly wanting their anticipated numbers. Ronald Acuña Jr. has hit properly since coming again, and whereas it hasn’t coincided with a team-wide offensive outburst but, the percentages of 1 are actually higher with him within the lineup. — Jay Jaffe
__
Quite a lot of readers are most likely well-versed on the 20-80 scouting scale, however are you able to give us extra context on what that interprets to on the main league degree? It’d be fascinating to listen to some examples of fifty/60/70 shortstops, who has a 30 hit software, who has 70 energy, and so on. — Satya
I believe there are helpful trendy functions for the standard scouting scale. It’s a concise approach to paint a reasonably detailed image of a participant’s ability set. This type of scale (the place 50 is common and every integer of 10 represents an ordinary deviation from the typical) was constructed to assist describe distributions throughout any type of inhabitants, like the dimensions and shade variation in carrots, or the charges of site visitors accidents at completely different instances of day, or, in our case, the distribution of expertise throughout high-level beginner and professional baseball.
We’ve got a lot extra information to contemplate now then we did when this scale was initially conceived as a possible technique of speaking scouting info throughout a division of individuals with out computer systems. Listed here are among the statistical baselines and distributions that I take advantage of as a reference when interacting with in-kind minor league information for place gamers — we are able to do pitchers one other time. I’m usually capable of pull this info from FanGraphs; there’s typically an enormous league equal to no matter minor league information I’ve gotten my palms on that’s accessible utilizing our leaderboards and customized reviews.
Listed here are the league-wide averages throughout the final 10 years for most of the statistical classes I believe are significant when assessing gamers. The upward pattern in among the energy metrics is a reminder that these scales shift and alter. You can too play with the person positions to get an thought of simply how excessive the bar is at first base in comparison with catcher or middle area.
Let’s begin with some metrics that assist measure a participant’s hit software:
Hit Instrument Metrics
Z-Contact%
Contact%
ChaseContact%
MLB
17.6%
74.5%
55.2%
Professional Common
20.0%
71.7%
52.9%
StDev
6.6%
7.3%
11.3%
Listed here are some examples by place, utilizing full-season 2024 numbers:
70- or 80-grade Hit Instruments
It is a crude evaluation. Observe that there are many hitters towards the backside of the contact charge leaderboard who’ve excessive batting averages. These guys are crushing the baseball once they make contact and netting extra hits per ball in play; a hitter’s power and energy additionally affect the way in which their hit software really performs. These metrics are extra indications of pure barrel really feel, and I believe that’s supported by the above listing of names.
Subsequent let’s take a look at uncooked energy:
Energy Metrics
90thEV
HardHit%
MaxEV
MLB
103.8
38.6%
110.4
Professional Common
101.1
30.6%
107.6
StDev
3.7
11.6%
4.3
The league-wide common has been steadily creeping up over the past 10 years or so at each place however first base. Listed here are position-by-position deltas for hard-hit charge over the past 10 years:
MLB Place-by-Place HardHit%
Place
2015
2025
Delta
C
32.0%
41.4%
9.4%
1B
39.1%
42.8%
3.7%
2B
29.0%
36.2%
7.2%
3B
35.0%
39.8%
4.8%
SS
28.0%
38.2%
10.2%
LF
32.7%
40.5%
7.8%
CF
32.1%
37.9%
5.8%
RF
36.2%
42.5%
6.3%
Bear in mind these deltas are in proportion factors, not percentages. For shortstops, it is a 33% enhance on balls put in play at 95 mph or extra since 2015. Listed here are the gamers with prime marks in these statistical classes:
There are not any actual surprises right here. You possibly can play with the leaderboards throughout positions, handedness, age, or varied home windows of time and be taught extra. As soon as you understand the massive league common and the usual deviation, you may principally ballpark everybody’s uncooked energy as you surf round. Once more, it’s crude, nevertheless it’s a chunk of the puzzle for any prospect.
For velocity, Statcast’s dash velocity is a good way of measuring a runner’s prime velocity. It’s providing you with toes/second within the runner’s quickest one-second window. Base-to-base instances (mostly home-to-first instances) offer you just a little higher thought of a runner’s velocity over an extended distance. You get some mixture of top-end velocity and acceleration within the home-to-first instances, although watch out for the jailbreak-style hitters whose instances are higher than their pure velocity. House-to-first instances are most frequently what’s producing the velocity grades you see in scouting reviews. The gamers with 30 feet-per-second dash speeds and home-to-first instances hovering round 4.10 seconds are who you may safely name 80-grade runners. Most of these guys will run 4 flat or beneath on their greatest bolts.
As for protection and throwing, that’s one thing I gauge visually. I typically take a look at Clay Davenport’s website and scope out the actually huge numbers in both route as a flag that I must assess a participant’s protection, both via tape research or by speaking with scouts. Right here is one completely subjective instance of defenders at every grade and place (please excuse my identify abbreviations):
Eric’s Subjective Defensive Grades
Place
80
70
60
50
40
30
C
P. Bailey
A. Hedges
C. Raleigh
A. Rutschman
F. Alvarez
C. Wong
1B
C. Walker
C. Santana
P. Goldschmidt
R. Mountcastle
R. Hoskins
DH
2B
B. Turang
A. Giménez
N. Hoerner
J. Cronenworth
Okay. Marte
N. Gorman
3B
Okay. Hayes
M. Chapman
M. Garcia
A. Riley
M. Muncy
R. Devers
SS
N. Allen
B. Witt
G. Perdomo
J. Wilson
T. Turner
C. Abrams
LF
D. Varsho
S. Kwan
A. Roden
I. Happ
B. Reynolds
T. Soderstrom
CF
PCA
M. Harris
J.H. Lee
P. Meadows
J. Bleday
LF/RF
RF
F. Tatis Jr.
W. Abreu
Corbin Carroll
J. Sánchez
J. Soto
N. Castellanos
— Eric Longenhagen
__
Assuming they’re wholesome on the commerce deadline (not a given in the mean time), what can be a good return for every of Cedric Mullins and Ryan O’Hearn? Can the Orioles count on/hope to get Prime 100 pitchers for them? – Ben from Boston, FG Member since 2021
If O’Hearn and Mullins are each wholesome come July and their efficiency hasn’t disappeared, I can think about the O’s doing properly in short-term returns. A Prime 100 pitching prospect is a reasonably huge ask, since you’re solely buying and selling two months with out an additional 12 months because the kicker, and round 100, you’re at names like Carson Whisenhunt or Tink Therefore. It’s not fully exterior the realm of risk, after all, as a result of proper now there don’t seem like plenty of sellers with expertise to focus on, as groups just like the White Sox and Rockies have a reasonably empty cabinet. Fairly than specializing in one specific pitching prospect, the Orioles would possibly use such a commerce to as an alternative choose up just a few lower-ranked pitchers who’ve some form of believable upside, and see how issues shake out. If the O’s are nonetheless struggling to crack .500 in late July, and Mullins and O’Hearn stay on the roster and unsigned to extensions, it will most likely be malpractice if they begin August in orange and black. — Dan Syzmborski
__
This query is for any of the weblog writers, however I had Michael Rosen in thoughts: How typically do you end up 5-10 hours into researching an article after which attain a null speculation? Do you attempt to publish these anyway in another format? This additionally doubles as a query about your course of for choosing analysis matters after which pursuing them: Do you do them one after the other? A number of irons within the hearth? How (if in any respect) do you collaborate with the opposite writers on workers? — Kevin Li
I attempt to keep away from extreme dead-end analysis as a lot as doable by doing a bunch of labor on the entrance finish. If I discover one thing that appears promising, I’ll pitch the story and begin writing in earnest, however for each thread that’s value pulling on, there are a bunch extra the place I write, like, 10 traces of code and understand I’m working towards a lifeless finish. And the opposite writers have been tremendous useful once I’ve received a spot in my data of some particular space of study, like hitting mechanics. I believe I’ve despatched over half the workers a Slack message in some unspecified time in the future asking for assistance on one query or one other. — Michael Rosen
