Dana is mother to a son who, when he was 14, skilled a speedy decline in his psychological well-being. A couple of months later, she got here to grasp that he had change into deeply influenced by predatory on-line networks that encourage susceptible folks, particularly minors, to hurt themselves and others. NPR isn’t utilizing Dana’s full identify or revealing her id as a result of it stays unclear whether or not those that focused her son proceed their actions.
Joanna Kulesza for NPR
disguise caption
toggle caption
Joanna Kulesza for NPR
The start of ninth grade was already shaping as much as be a bumpy transition for then-14-year-old Elliott. His longtime buddy group from preschool days had fractured. His mother and father had been separating. And, he was beginning highschool. Along with his new smartphone, Elliott more and more sought group on-line, in areas the place different customers shared his musical pursuits. And it was there that he ultimately fell underneath the affect of predatory networks that may upend his and his relations’ lives.
NPR isn’t utilizing Elliott’s full identify as a result of he’s nonetheless a minor and it stays unclear whether or not people who could have focused him on-line proceed their actions.
Dana, Elliott’s mom, mentioned that when she gave him his iPhone, she took precautions that she thought can be wise. She arrange parental controls to restrict how a lot time he may spend on-line; he was not allowed on social media platforms; and he was barred from visiting sure web sites. Nonetheless, between his smartphone and his school-issued Chromebook, she mentioned Elliott appeared to search out methods round each restriction.
Over time, she started to look at disturbing modifications to her son’s persona.
“(He was) feeling like a burden … isolating, withdrawing from issues that he discovered pleasurable prior to now, speaking lots about … demise,” she recalled. “And he additionally began to speak about very violent, gory issues.”
It wasn’t till Elliott was hospitalized, in early 2024, that Dana shaped a extra full image of how strangers on-line had introduced him to the purpose of intensive self-harm and repetitive ideas of suicide. She got here to grasp that unhealthy actors had been lurking within the boards the place he was on the lookout for group, whereas they had been on the lookout for susceptible victims whom they might manipulate into dangerous behaviors for the aim of profitable clout inside poisonous on-line networks. And it was lastly then that Dana realized about a few of these networks, similar to 764 and CVLT (pronounced “cult”), which have been linked to random violent assaults, arson, little one sexual abuse materials, little one sexploitation, bomb threats, plots to homicide and no less than two deaths within the U.S. and overseas.
“The entire time interval that he was into this stuff on-line, it was like he was taken hostage and brainwashed,” she mentioned.
Now, greater than a 12 months after Elliott was hospitalized, Dana lastly feels able to share the story of what her household went via, within the hope that it might assist different mother and father perceive a few of the risks that kids could encounter on-line. After months of intensive remedy, she mentioned, Elliott is doing significantly better. He has relinquished his smartphone in favor of a easy flip telephone; he additionally has returned to hobbies, similar to making music, that had beforehand been an essential a part of his id. Nonetheless, Dana acknowledges that the content material he was led to devour on-line, together with pictures and movies of violent gore, has modified him.
“It is a type of coercive management. It is that drip, drip, drip. And you do not understand how unhealthy it’s till possibly you are out of it,” mentioned Dana. “And I believe in lots of methods, he nonetheless would not understand how unhealthy it was. He has been desensitized in lots of methods.”
A speedy spiral into darkness
Previous to Elliott’s darkish on-line odyssey, Dana mentioned, she did not fear about his digital actions.
“He had all the time managed his time on-line, (and his) time taking part in video video games, rather well on his personal, as a result of he had so many pursuits that weren’t digital,” she mentioned. “He performs music, he performs drums, he performs guitar, he sings, he attracts, he writes, he reads.”
Nonetheless, she arrange what she thought-about to be common sense safeguards when her son acquired his iPhone, and he or she did occasional spot-checks on his exercise.
However she mentioned the social and familial shifts in Elliott’s life within the fall of 2023 had been destabilizing. A fan of black metallic music, he began frequenting on-line boards the place others shared his curiosity. However in these areas, Dana mentioned, there have been additionally predators on the lookout for susceptible folks. At first, she mentioned, they gave the impression to be pleasant and supportive to her son. However ultimately, they started to direct Elliott to darkish on-line content material, often called “gore” websites, that reshaped his notion of the world round him.
“They get you to comply with these completely different accounts and examine these completely different web sites, and the algorithms simply assist that course of alongside,” Dana mentioned. “And it creates — the place you are so flooded with this content material — it desensitizes you to violence.”
The primary indicators that one thing was unsuitable had been situations of self-harm. Dana mentioned it began with small cuts to his arms — one thing she initially attributed to Elliott’s breakup with a girlfriend. Dana introduced it up with Elliott’s therapist, whom he had been seeing even earlier than this started, and so they labored out a security plan. Dana locked up gadgets that Elliott may use to hurt himself.
“So we went via with that,” she mentioned. “But it surely appeared like one way or the other he saved discovering different gadgets to hurt himself.”
Typically, Dana mentioned, he would come to her for assist after slicing himself, saying he felt like he was uncontrolled.
On the identical time, Dana was more and more involved about what she thought-about to be excessive political views that Elliott was beginning to categorical. He parroted the ideology of accelerationist extremists, who body Western civilization as decadent and corrupt and who promote the concept that complete societal collapse is important to ascertain a brand new fascist order. At instances, he would discuss wanting to start out “an order.” He went on tirades towards LGBTQ+ folks, which Dana mentioned was shockingly out of character.
“We have now, you realize, trans, nonbinary, homosexual, lesbian folks in our household. Most of his buddy group was LGBTQIA,” she mentioned. “So this was like, the place is that this coming from? (It was) utterly out of left discipline.”
She mentioned it was additionally upsetting to listen to Elliott succumb to a type of nihilistic worldview that he had by no means beforehand held.
“He was speaking lots about there was no that means to something. It was hopeless. All the pieces was meaningless. There was no goal,” she mentioned. “And that was, once more, very in contrast to him. He is all the time been very clear about having that means and goal.”
Nihilistic violent extremism
In March, the FBI issued a public service announcement warning of “violent on-line networks,” similar to 764 and CVLT, that focus on minors and different susceptible people. It has additionally shared informational reels on Instagram to coach mother and father and educators about these teams and share warning indicators that younger folks could also be underneath these networks’ affect. The messaging makes an attempt to convey the weird breadth of actions and motives discovered inside these networks, spanning from sexual gratification to constructing clout inside these on-line areas.
The FBI has just lately targeted on a comparatively new motive inside this space, for which it has coined the time period “nihilistic violent extremism.”
“The time period Nihilistic Violent Extremism (NVE) refers to what’s motivating a few of these topics to commit legal acts,” the FBI wrote in a press release to NPR. “They wish to sow chaos and facilitate the destruction of society.” The company shared that it’s pursuing no less than 250 investigations tied to violent on-line networks. The FBI didn’t comply with an interview with NPR.
Since 2021, these networks have been linked to almost 50 circumstances all over the world, in accordance with information from the Accelerationism Analysis Consortium, in addition to data gathered by NPR. Within the U.S., they’ve been linked to no less than 20 crimes, together with college shootings and a June arson spree in Wisconsin that allegedly concerned a 12-year-old suspect.
A makeshift memorial sits in entrance of Plentiful Life Christian College in Madison, Wis., on Dec. 17, 2024, the day after a taking pictures there. A number of folks had been reported shot and three died after a pupil opened hearth within the college. The coed was linked to nihilistic violent extremism on-line networks.
Scott Olson/Getty Photographs
disguise caption
toggle caption
Scott Olson/Getty Photographs
An unknown variety of suicides are additionally linked to those on-line communities. Reporting from The Washington Submit has discovered situations the place predators inside these networks sought to spice up their affect by encouraging victims to livestream their suicides, and by then sharing these movies.
Many legal circumstances linked to those networks contain the grooming of minors, little one sexual exploitation and the manufacturing or distribution of kid sexual abuse materials. And in some situations, the crimes have crossed into terrorism. Brazilian police declare that they stopped a coordinated plan to set off a number of explosives at a free Girl Gaga live performance at Copacabana Seaside in Might. An grownup and a young person had been arrested in reference to the alleged plot. In Canada, additionally in Might, authorities arrested a 15-year-old underneath suspicion of planning terrorism-related offenses.
“There’s a huge combination of harms which are occurring on this ecosystem,” mentioned Matthew Kriner, government director of the Institute for Countering Digital Extremism and the Accelerationism Analysis Consortium. “There are people who’re collaborating with each other throughout transnational strains, utilizing any and each ideological framework they will to push folks into harming others (and) harming themselves.”
Kriner has testified as an knowledgeable witness in federal circumstances towards folks accused of involvement with these networks. He mentioned the digital areas that contributors in these networks use are suffused with neo-Nazi and neo-Nazi satanic symbols and language. However he says that nihilistic terrorism is a singular class.
“They’ve a really clear, distinct differentiation between these two ecosystems there. They don’t talk,” he mentioned. “There is perhaps some connectivity between people, however as motion areas, they aren’t aligned.” Notably, mentioned Kriner, people who’re inculcated with a way of nihilism don’t commit crimes to realize an ideological aim. As an alternative, the violence is solely for the sake of violence.
Whereas the crimes range extensively, Cynthia Miller-Idriss says there may be consistency within the manipulative ways utilized by unhealthy actors inside these networks. Miller-Idriss is a professor at American College and runs its Polarization & Extremism Analysis & Innovation Lab (PERIL).
“While you consider why would a child be susceptible to this … they’re already more and more desensitized to violence,” she mentioned. “And then you definately take youngsters who’re moreover susceptible, the place adults are utilizing profitable, manipulative ways to make them assume that they are linked, that they are cared for … and telling them then to chop their identify on their pores and skin on digital camera or do one thing that demonstrates their loyalty. After which they use these movies to additional exploit them.”
Maybe most regarding, say researchers of on-line extremism, is that minors focused in these areas are sometimes inspired to victimize different kids. In consequence, mentioned Kriner, the attain of those harms has mushroomed. Regardless of the welcome consideration from regulation enforcement in current months, they are saying that it’s unlikely to stem the unfold of this exercise. As an alternative, they are saying native, state and federal governments must formulate a public well being method to forestall and mitigate the unfold of those harms.
A disaster level
By winter of his freshman 12 months, Dana was on the lookout for assist for Elliott. She had introduced up his spiraling melancholy and self-harm along with his therapist, solely to be advised that this was “regular” teenage habits. His anti-LGBTQ+ rants made her suspicious that he had been “red-pilled” on-line, that means he had adopted a misogynistic worldview.
“I felt like I wanted to escalate outdoors of her present care crew as a result of no one was listening to me. No one was taking this significantly,” she mentioned.
Dana began on the lookout for a brand new therapist for her son. She additionally contacted a corporation that helps information folks out of violent extremist actions. However earlier than these sources got here collectively, Elliott’s scenario escalated.
“My youthful daughter had discovered that my son was in possession of a big looking knife. (It) turned out he had ordered this on Etsy,” she mentioned. “It was very lengthy and had been custom-made with the inscription ‘Loss of life.’ It had a intestine hook. And she or he … introduced it to me lower than 5 minutes earlier than I wanted to depart to select him up from college.”
Dana mentioned her thoughts began to race.
“Does he have one other weapon on him in school proper now? Does he have a weapon at dwelling? Is he going to harm … someone else or himself? What is going on?” she remembered considering.
A big looking knife with the inscription “Loss of life,” belonging to Elliott, was discovered by Dana’s daughter.
Household picture
disguise caption
toggle caption
Household picture
Simply then, the pediatrician’s workplace known as her. It was getting again to her a few advice for a brand new therapist. Dana advised the workplace in regards to the discovery of Elliott’s knife. The workplace suggested her to select up her son and take him instantly to the kids’s hospital for a psychological well being analysis. In addition they suggested her to succeed in out to the varsity useful resource officer and native police division to every have somebody current on the pickup, in case Elliott reacted poorly.
Dana mentioned Elliott was stunned to be questioned by police at pickup. They decided that he was not, at that second, harmful to himself or others. She mentioned the drive to the hospital was very tough.
“He was crying,” she mentioned. “He was very indignant that he had been known as out, (saying) that we had been all being ridiculous and making too massive of a deal of nothing.”
However on the hospital, it shortly turned obvious that Elliott’s situation had gotten very critical. Medical employees knowledgeable Dana that his higher physique, together with his torso and arms, was coated with cuts that he had inflicted upon himself. A few of them, the employees mentioned, had been more likely to go away everlasting scars. Dana mentioned many of the marks had been made throughout the prior week.
“Upside-down crosses, pentagrams. Sure symbols that had been related to the Order of 9 Angles,” she mentioned, referring to a satanic neo-Nazi terrorist group. “I later came upon that a few of these symbols could presumably have been callout indicators to 764. They encourage their victims to carve sure symbols to name out sure members.”
Dana mentioned medical employees assessed that Elliott was at average/excessive danger of suicide, however as a result of he did not intimate a plan for suicide, the employees wished to ship him dwelling after treating his wounds. However Elliott’s crew on the pediatrician’s workplace was adamant that Dana not return dwelling with him that night time, citing concern that he may hurt himself or others. Dana managed to get him transferred to a different well being facility within the county that night time.
It wasn’t till the following morning that Dana started to study in regards to the violent on-line networks that apparently had been influencing her son.
“I acquired a name from the varsity violence division, a police officer there, who requested me some questions on what had occurred,” Dana mentioned. “I simply knew what he had been speaking about and the self-harm that he had. And she or he mentioned instantly, I think that your son is being extorted or has been contacted by a gaggle known as 764.”
The officer advised Dana that the FBI can be getting concerned to find out whether or not Elliott had been contacted straight by anybody within the community. The priority was that if he had shared his deal with or different private data, the entire household might be in danger. Victims of those networks have, at instances, been targets of hoax “swatting” calls, the place somebody fraudulently studies against the law at a house location so as to draw a big and aggressive regulation enforcement presence there.
Police additionally requested Dana to look via Elliott’s telephone to see whether or not she discovered proof of direct contact.
“I spent roughly two hours going via his telephone, and I nonetheless have nightmares about it,” she mentioned. However having to look via Elliott’s detailed actions and messages lastly introduced into focus a extra full image of his on-line exercise.
“He was spending about 12 to 14 hours a day … on Reddit, YouTube, TikTok, Discord,” she mentioned. However most annoying, mentioned Dana, had been particular web sites he was frequenting within the “gore” class. “I simply pulled up a number of of those web sites, and simply a number of thumbnails on the homepage, I had nightmares. I nonetheless have nightmares — it is over a 12 months later — from seeing 4 or 5 thumbnails.”
Gore web sites characteristic graphic depictions of real-world and AI-generated violence. Violent on-line networks encourage victims to view this content material, to desensitize them to surprising and inhumane habits. It may be a precursor to persuading them to mutilate themselves or to harm others.
Additionally deeply troubling had been the images she discovered on Elliott’s telephone, of himself.
“I noticed my son had taken a whole bunch of images that had been categorized as little one self-harm sexual content material,” she mentioned. “In order that they began with, here is just a bit scratch on my arm. Here is a much bigger scratch. Here is some throughout my arm. And on the finish, it was cuts throughout his torso, thighs, arms. And he was absolutely bare.”
Dana mentioned she and regulation enforcement representatives discovered proof that there had very just lately been some direct messaging with somebody whom they might not establish. However they had been unable to conclusively decide the extent to which that occurred. Elliott has not absolutely disclosed what he was as much as, which Dana says could also be partly because of disgrace he feels about the entire episode.
The FBI advised Dana that Elliott wanted inpatient look after 30 to 60 days, primarily to “detox” from the dangerous networks wherein he had immersed himself for a lot of months. However Dana mentioned no care facility was conversant in the harms he had skilled or was in a position to accommodate a chronic keep. In the long run, she says, he spent lower than two weeks in inpatient care. After that, he was partially hospitalized, sleeping at dwelling however receiving seven hours of remedy every day.
Nonetheless, she is satisfied that she acquired assist for her son at a essential second.
Dana flips via a pocket book that she used to doc notes throughout her son’s time in a partial hospitalization program.
Joanna Kulesza for NPR
disguise caption
toggle caption
Joanna Kulesza for NPR
“That is laborious to say about your individual child, however he was the goal of a superb little bit of bullying in school, oftentimes with a social media part,” she mentioned. “And … I fear that if he would have saved viewing this content material, the police officer was very emphatic that we had been most likely days away from a really horrible end result. Both, you realize, him harming someone else or himself, and undoubtedly direct contact with a person from the group.”
Elliott’s progress since he acquired intensive assist has not been linear, she mentioned. However a 12 months after his hospitalization, Dana mentioned she lastly seems like that chapter of Elliott’s teenage years is behind them. And she or he has reached a degree the place she feels prepared to talk extra brazenly about what occurred.
“I really feel like after I discuss it, I get one in every of two reactions. One is, ‘That may by no means occur to us as a result of we now have parental controls, the display time (limits), and our child would by no means do one thing like that,'” she mentioned. “Or two, ‘I had no concept that one thing like this might occur. Please inform me extra. I wish to study.'”
