The Supreme Courtroom
Andrew Harnik/Getty Photos
conceal caption
toggle caption
Andrew Harnik/Getty Photos
The U.S. Supreme Courtroom on Wednesday left in place a decrease court docket determination that blocked a part of a Florida legislation making it a criminal offense for undocumented immigrants to cross into the state. The statute imposed numerous necessary jail phrases for violating the legislation.
The excessive court docket’s motion got here in a one sentence order, with none elaboration and with none famous dissents.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis signed the state laws into legislation in February, and simply two months later the legislation made nationwide headlines when Florida’s Freeway Patrol arrested Juan Carlos Lopez-Garcia, an American-born U.S. citizen, for crossing into the state from Georgia. Lopez-Garcia was detained for twenty-four hours earlier than his launch.
Immigrant rights organizations and undocumented immigrants sued, arguing that the brand new Florida legislation conflicted with federal immigration legislation, and underneath longstanding Supreme Courtroom precedent, states should bow to federal legislation within the occasion of such conflicts.
Florida, nonetheless, maintained that state laws is critical to curb the “evil results of immigration,” and that state legislation works in tandem with federal legislation. Till now, nonetheless, the Supreme Courtroom has held that federal legislation occupies the immigration subject if there’s a battle.
Florida will not be the primary state to go a legislation to criminalize unlawful immigration, solely to be blocked by the federal courts. Lately, federal judges have blocked comparable state efforts in Oklahoma, Iowa, and Idaho—every time deciding {that a} state legislation criminalizing unlawful immigration would battle with present nationwide legal guidelines. In 2024, the conservative Fifth Circuit Courtroom of Appeals blocked Texas’s efforts to implement an analogous legislation.
Whereas Wednesday’s Supreme Courtroom order blocked components of the Florida legislation championed by DeSantis, the immigration problem stays a successful proposition for the governor. In Could, he introduced that in collaboration with the U.S. Division of Homeland Safety, Florida led a “first-of-its-kind statewide operation” arresting greater than 1,000 undocumented immigrants in lower than per week.
