A screenshot from Sydney Sweeney’s controversial advert that has since been deleted from American Eagle’s social media.
American Eagle
disguise caption
toggle caption
American Eagle
As a lot because the information media serves to tell the general public, we’re additionally right here to present you one thing to speak about. Studying concerning the world round us gives the connective tissue for spirited interactions and rising deeper bonds with one another.
What are you going to convey up on the dinner desk to get the dialog flowing? Did you learn that article everyone has been speaking about, too?
Who or what’s it? This week, it is Sydney Sweeney and her controversial advert marketing campaign with retailer American Eagle, through which she stares into the digicam along with her child blues, and whispers:
“Genes are handed down from mother and father to offspring, typically figuring out traits like hair shade, persona and even eye shade. My denims are blue.”
The video has since been faraway from American Eagle’s social media channels, however can nonetheless be discovered on-line.
What is the large deal? The corporate’s inventive selections have prompted some to say the advert marketing campaign promotes eugenics, a discredited scientific concept well-liked amongst white supremacists that the human race could possibly be improved by breeding out much less fascinating traits. Others are saying the uproar is the tradition’s response from a society hellbent on sexualizing ladies.
And lots of people are taking problem with the hypersexualized nature of the adverts, particularly for the reason that firm says the advert marketing campaign is meant to lift home violence consciousness, a trigger Sweeney is enthusiastic about — and 100% of the acquisition value of the denims might be donated to Disaster Textual content Line, a charity that gives psychological well being companies.
The unique video was posted final week on social media, a part of a marketing campaign that focuses on, effectively, – American Eagle denims, and Sweeney’s well-known determine carrying them.
In a number of different clips, Sweeney talks concerning the denims she’s carrying or teases the viewer concerning the digicam lingering on her chest for too lengthy. However the video that induced this discourse is the one embedded above, through which Sweeney recites a monologue that performs on the phrase “genes.”
Laden with controversy
The general public advert marketing campaign that referenced genetics at this second — when President Trump’s White Home has pushed onerous to slash range efforts within the federal authorities and goal immigrants — was already tripping some alarm bells for viewers.
But when that wasn’t sufficient, the monologue inside this newer advert can be a nod to an notorious Calvin Klein marketing campaign from 1980 that starred a then-15-year-old Brooke Shields.
For Shields’ advert marketing campaign, the supply of the backlash wasn’t a lot the lesson on genetics, however extra the overt sexualization of a minor in an commercial, with some labeling it little one pornography.
In her 2023 documentary Fairly Child, Shields took inventory of how damaging this public notion was to her improvement, and famous that she was so younger on the time she did not even perceive the innuendos within the advert marketing campaign.
What are folks saying? Some persons are mad. And others are mad that they are mad. The web is an extremely various place!
Instantly after Sweeney’s marketing campaign went reside, many on social media famous that they felt the language behind the advert felt promotional of eugenics and expressed discomfort and disdain.
Rattling I assumed you all have been joking however that Sydney Sweeney advert actually does say “genes decide persona.” Our tradition is totally cooked
– Erik Baker (@erikmbaker) July 26, 2025
Others are saying persons are overreacting — that they are too woke and the criticism is coming from triggered liberals.
Vice President Vance even chimed in on the matter throughout a current podcast interview:
🚨 LMAO! JD Vance simply reacted to leftists melting down over Sydney Sweeney
“My political recommendation to Democrats is proceed to inform everybody who thinks Sydney Sweeney is enticing is a NAZl” 🤣
“You guys, did you study NOTHING from the 2024 election?! I truly thought one among… pic.twitter.com/qp3zLxU9lG
— Nick Sortor (@nicksortor) August 1, 2025
NPR’s Mia Venkat spoke to Sarah Banet-Weiser, dean of the College of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg College for Communication. Banet-Weiser famous that the concept that intercourse sells has all the time been a golden rule of promoting. Sweeney has develop into identified for taking roles or partnerships the place her sexiness is the focal point and he or she will get lots of flack for that..
“It is an consideration financial system right here that’s centered on her,” Banet-Weiser stated. “However additionally it is concerning the profitability of anger and profitability of hate. And we see this again and again.”
So, what now?
The model’s inventory soared instantly within the wake of the viral fervor, nevertheless it’s nonetheless too quickly to inform if the corporate will see any actual profit from the advert marketing campaign.
On Friday afternoon, the retailer launched an announcement addressing the controversy saying the marketing campaign, “is and all the time was concerning the denims. (Sweeney’s) denims. Her story. We’ll proceed to have a good time how everybody wears their AE denims with confidence, their approach. Nice denims look good on everybody.”
Sweeney’s representatives didn’t reply to NPR’s request for remark.
Sweeney’s flood of economic gigs has remained regular along with her rising profile. She’s starred in advert campaigns for manufacturers like Hey Dude, Laneige, Baskin-Robbins and Samsung.
They’re no bathwater cleaning soap adverts, nevertheless it’s sincere work.
