OTTAWA – Prime Minister Mark Carney ought to “take a web page from the Chrétien authorities’s 1994 program evaluation” and lower tens of hundreds of bureaucrat jobs, argued the Montreal Financial Institute (MEI) in a brand new paper revealed on Thursday.
The financial assume tank discovered {that a} program evaluation just like the one from 30 years in the past would consequence within the elimination of about 64,000 federal authorities jobs. This is able to result in a return to the pre-Justin Trudeau authorities per capita measurement of the forms and a everlasting discount in public spending of practically $10 billion a 12 months by 2029, MEI specialists say.
“The dimensions of the Canadian public service as soon as once more requires consideration. Regardless of the federal government belatedly acknowledging the necessity to restrain the expansion of the federal forms, extra decisive motion is required,” mentioned Conrad Eder, the affiliate Researcher on the MEI that produced the perspective.
Through the federal election, Liberal Chief Mark Carney promised to cap the dimensions of the federal workforce and to “not lower public service employment.”
“As a part of our evaluation of spending we’ll be sure that the dimensions of the federal public service meets the wants of Canadians,” reads the Liberal platform.
The Liberals additionally promised to launch a “complete evaluation of presidency spending” targeted on productiveness. The evaluation, it was mentioned, would give attention to “clear targets by departments and Crown Firms with an iterative course of that deploys finest approaches throughout the general public sector.”
For example, the federal government desires to amalgamate service supply, consolidate grants and contributions that serve comparable functions and cut back reliance on exterior consultants.
Following this evaluation, Ottawa desires to place in place a everlasting course of to “hyperlink spending and outcomes throughout departments and steady enchancment in spending management.”
“Prime minister Carney’s guarantees to evaluation federal spending give us trigger for optimism, however the lack of particulars surrounding how will probably be carried out brings us warning,” wrote Renaud Brossard, vice chairman of communications on the MEI, in an electronic mail alternate with Nationwide Put up.
In 2023, then
prime minister Justin Trudeau gave a mandate to his then President of the Treasury Board
Anita Anand to search out $15 billion in financial savings throughout the federal government by 2028, after which $4 billion yearly after that.
But, from 2015 to 2025, the variety of federal public servants elevated by greater than 110,000, a 43 per cent improve in keeping with the MEI. There are 367,772 federal staff, or 9 per 1,000 residents, in comparison with 7.2 when Trudeau took workplace.
By comparability, the UK has 7.4 federal staff per 1,000 residents and Germany 6.2 staff per 1,000 residents.
Final 12 months, the MEI famous that federal personnel prices had been on monitor to exceed $70 billion, in comparison with $40 billion in 2016-2017, the primary fiscal 12 months of Trudeau’s first mandate. In response to the MEI, this represents one in seven {dollars} spent by the federal government.
The MEI maintains that a big portion of this spending is financed by massive deficits. In 2024, the federal authorities posted a deficit of $61.9 billion, far exceeding its promise to maintain it under $40.1 billion.
“Given the dimensions of our deficit and the velocity at which the forms has grown over the past decade, a federal spending evaluation must be simply as formidable because the one undertaken beneath the Chrétien authorities within the Nineties,” Brossard mentioned.
The 1994 program evaluation has turn into an instance of excellent fiscal observe in Canadian financial circles. When Jean Chrétien was elected prime minister in 1993, Canada was grappling with persistent deficits, an unsustainable nationwide debt and a ballooning public service.
Chrétien then requested his finance minister Paul Martin to place “the home so as”.
This system evaluation evaluated federal packages primarily based on public want and monetary capability. The federal government then restructured packages and eradicated jobs within the public service. In reality, the dimensions of the forms shrunk by over 42,000 staff, or 17.4 per cent, on the time they had been finished in 1999.
“Chrétien’s reforms labored as a result of they had been focused and pragmatic,” defined Brossard. “His authorities proved that it’s attainable to offer important providers whereas tackling overspending.”
Nationwide Put up
atrepanier@postmedia.com
The Liberals had been shocked by the beneficial properties they made in Quebec’s hostile ridings
Quebec’s envoy in Ottawa leaves workplace as province seeks bigger function in Canada’s U.S. relations
Get extra deep-dive Nationwide Put up political protection and evaluation in your inbox with the Political Hack e-newsletter, the place Ottawa bureau chief Stuart Thomson and political analyst Tasha Kheiriddin get at what’s actually happening behind the scenes on Parliament Hill each Wednesday and Friday, completely for subscribers. Join right here.
Our web site is the place for the newest breaking information, unique scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and join our every day e-newsletter, Posted, right here.
