ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of energy. Signal as much as obtain our greatest tales as quickly as they’re printed.
Reporting Highlights
Misplaced Investments: Individuals who invested with a Dallas HomeVestors franchise, as soon as touted as the most important, accuse the proprietor of working a scheme that price them tens of tens of millions of {dollars}.
Pink Flags: HomeVestors says its franchises comply with finest enterprise practices. However traders say lax oversight allowed the “We Purchase Ugly Homes” model for use to additional the scheme.
Firm Responds: HomeVestors has denied duty for the franchisee’s actions, saying its franchises are independently operated. It has sued the franchise proprietor.
These highlights have been written by the reporters and editors who labored on this story.
Ronald Carver was skeptical when his funding adviser first tried to promote him on an “ugly homes” funding alternative eight years in the past. However as soon as the Texas retiree heard the small print, it appeared like a no-lose state of affairs.
Carver would lend cash to Charles Provider, proprietor of Dallas-based C&C Residential Properties, a high-producing franchise within the HomeVestors of America house-flipping chain identified for its ubiquitous “We Purchase Ugly Homes” ads. The enterprise would then use the {dollars} to buy properties by which Carver would obtain an possession stake securing his funding and an annual return of 9%, paid in month-to-month installments.
“Worst case, I’d find yourself with a property price greater than what the mortgage was,” Carver stated of the pitch.
Carver began with a $115,000 mortgage in 2017. And certain sufficient, the curiosity funds arrived every month.
He had labored three many years at a nuclear energy plant, and retired and not using a pension and earlier than he might accumulate Social Safety. He and his spouse lived off the funding earnings.
The deal appeared so good, Carver talked his aged father into investing, beginning with $50,000. Because the month-to-month checks arrived as promised, each males elevated their investments. By 2024, Carver estimates they’d about $700,000 invested with Provider.
Then, final fall, the checks stopped. The cash Carver and his father had invested was gone.
Provider is accused of orchestrating a yearslong Ponzi scheme, bilking tens of tens of millions of {dollars} from scores of traders, in line with a number of lawsuits and interviews with individuals who stated they misplaced cash. The monetary wreckage is strewn throughout Texas, having swept up each rich traders and older individuals with modest incomes who dug into retirement financial savings on the recommendation of the identical funding advisor utilized by Carver.
As early as 2020, Provider had begun taking out a number of loans on particular person properties — a few of which he by no means owned. In instances reviewed by ProPublica, as many as 5 notes have been recorded in opposition to a single property, far exceeding the property’s worth. Provider additionally didn’t correctly file many deeds that have been imagined to safe the loans, accumulating extra debt than he might ever repay whereas traders remained unaware they’d no collateral for his or her investments.
“It’s incalculable the quantity of injury this man did,” stated one investor who misplaced about $1 million and requested to not be named to keep away from embarrassment and to not intrude with a legal investigation into Provider’s scheme. “He’s ruined some lives.”
Provider, who declined an interview request, stated in a short telephone dialog that he’s not attempting to keep away from duty for the hurt he triggered. “When this factor lastly stopped, it was utterly pushed by me saying ‘sufficient’ and going to the individuals and saying, ‘Right here’s the mess I’ve created,’” he stated. “This can be a mess created by me.”
Buyers additionally blame HomeVestors. For almost 20 years, Provider used the corporate’s rigorously cultivated model because the “largest homebuyer in the US” to achieve traders’ belief. They accuse HomeVestors of failing to supply oversight that might have prevented the fraud, regardless of claiming to carry its franchises accountable for finest enterprise practices. In its solutions to their lawsuits, HomeVestors has denied duty for Provider’s actions, claiming its franchises are independently operated, regardless of incomes lots of of hundreds of {dollars} from Provider’s enterprise.
HomeVestors revoked Provider’s franchise on Oct. 24, in regards to the time curiosity funds stopped arriving in traders’ accounts. The corporate stated it had obtained a tip on its ethics hotline — created in 2023, after ProPublica detailed predatory shopping for practices by a number of franchises. When confronted by HomeVestors, Provider admitted that “he and his enterprise had entered into money owed that they might not pay,” a HomeVestors spokesperson stated. The corporate reported him to the FBI. In Could, HomeVestors filed go well with in opposition to Provider for trademark infringement and for not indemnifying it in opposition to these lawsuits.
“We take all allegations of misconduct extremely severely as demonstrated by our decisive motion,” the spokesperson stated. “It’s really disheartening for us that anybody who lent Mr. Provider cash was misled or harmed by his alleged fraudulent exercise.”
Now, Provider is below investigation by the Division of Justice, in line with a recording of an April name between the lead prosecutor and potential victims. (The FBI and DOJ declined to remark.) A choose in one of many many lawsuits in opposition to Provider has deemed allegations of fraudulent loans to be true as a result of Provider by no means answered the grievance. And the traders are in a race with each other to recoup even a small quantity of what they misplaced, by both ready for the DOJ to pay restitution, suing Provider or attempting to foreclose on properties nonetheless left in his portfolio.
Simply months after studying they’d misplaced all of their investments, and earlier than any restitution may very well be paid, Carver’s father died.
5 notes for a property on Glen Forest Lane in Dallas given to traders between 2019 and 2023. Two of the notes weren’t recorded till 2024.
Credit score:
Obtained, collaged and highlighted by ProPublica
A High-Performing Franchise
In 2005, Provider opened a HomeVestors franchise in Dallas, the place HomeVestors is headquartered. Within the early days, data present, he relied on a handful of institutional lenders to finance his home purchases. Quickly, the Wharton College of Enterprise MBA who had come to house-flipping following a profession at Pepsi and a meals service tools firm, began cultivating his rich buddies for loans.
Provider didn’t match any stereotype of a glad-handing huckster with a nasty mortgage to promote. Those that knew him describe him as a critical particular person, “cordial however very direct.” He at all times had information in entrance of him, consistently specializing in his enterprise. It made him appear reliable, one investor stated.
At HomeVestors, he was held up as a mannequin franchise operator. C&C Residential Properties routinely made the highest quantity and prime nearer lists and was even named franchise of the yr. Provider led coaching classes at firm conferences and described his enterprise as “the most important and most profitable HomeVestors franchise in the US” — a declare that remained on the web site for Provider’s enterprise by early Could.
“Chas Provider, for possibly 15 years, was one of many golden boys at HomeVestors,” stated Ben Ahern, who over 20 years labored for a HomeVestors franchise and later owned one earlier than leaving the corporate in 2021. “Internally, it was like, ‘Do no matter Chas Provider’s doing.’”
It isn’t uncommon for HomeVestors franchises to depend on personal traders to finance their house-flipping. Banks aren’t usually occupied with house-flipping loans, which are sometimes short-term and riskier than an ordinary mortgage. Due to that threat, traders who lend to house-flippers earn a considerably larger return.
To additional decrease their threat and guarantee they’d a reputable possession stake in the home, savvy traders would confirm the transaction with an impartial title firm to analysis whether or not there have been different liens in opposition to the property after which file the deed with the county recorder. However a lot of Provider’s traders, after years of constant funds led them to belief him, let Provider deal with recording the deeds and didn’t verify that he’d accomplished so.
As Provider grew his enterprise, he started relying extra on particular person traders. ProPublica recognized by public data not less than 124 individuals who have lent cash to Provider since 2009. Not all of them have misplaced cash.
Provider’s seek for new traders was aided by Robert Welborn, an funding adviser in Granbury, Texas, southwest of Dallas. Welborn had constructed a community of purchasers in Granbury, a metropolis of about 12,000 individuals on the Brazos River, by church, friendships and referrals. Lots of his purchasers have been older and had modest nest eggs, which Welborn stated have been “effectively diversified.” He stated he constructed a relationship with Provider in 2012, after researching his background for about two months. That Provider was a profitable franchisee lent him credibility, Welborn stated.
“I by no means imagined the No. 1 franchisee with a fast-growing franchise firm, HomeVestors,” would defraud traders, he stated.
On the time, Welborn additionally solicited new traders with invites to steak dinners the place they’d hear his pitch. An funding in Provider’s enterprise, in line with Welborn’s gross sales materials, which additionally featured the HomeVestors caveman mascot, Ug, was each profitable and safe. “Your funding is protected,” the gross sales materials assured potential purchasers.
For loans he despatched Provider’s approach, Welborn earned a 2% fee, he stated. Welborn had not less than two dozen purchasers who invested with Provider, most of whom had a number of loans to him, in line with a public data search. He wouldn’t touch upon what number of of his purchasers invested with Provider.
Many traders have been pleased for years — in some instances, greater than a decade. The curiosity funds got here in like clockwork. Numerous Welborns’ purchasers relied on the funds for retirement earnings.
“I used to be actual tickled with it,” stated Tom Partitions, 85, who stated he misplaced $50,000 of his retirement financial savings by investing with Provider.
Some traders seen small issues — a cost that arrived just a few days late or an error on the paperwork to safe the mortgage. However Provider at all times mounted the issues promptly, traders stated.
“When you could have this 10-year steady, nice and mutually helpful relationship, you construct up a substantial amount of belief,” stated John Moses, who estimates he misplaced greater than $1 million to Provider.
Wanting again, the traders who spoke with ProPublica stated they wished they’d taken these warning indicators extra severely.
Credit score:
Max Erwin for ProPublica
“He Simply Pencil Whipped These Deeds”
By fall 2024, Provider’s funds to his lenders stopped. That’s when the home of playing cards fell.
Provider had spent that summer time scrambling for cash. Not solely did Provider need to make mortgage funds to scores of traders, however he additionally wanted to maintain up with the HomeVestors franchise charges and promoting funds. The corporate requires its franchises to make common studies on gross sales and to open their books for audits, to supply monetary statements when requested, and to report all belongings and liabilities. Any of these studies might have known as into query Provider’s capability to remain solvent. However, in line with former franchise homeowners and staff, HomeVestors’ audits of its franchises are largely geared towards guaranteeing they’re paying all their franchise charges, that are based mostly on gross sales.
Earlier than Provider’s tangle of fraudulent loans collapsed and was uncovered in court docket, there have been indicators of hassle.
In 2016, Provider was fined by the Texas Actual Property Fee for managing properties and not using a license. The HomeVestors franchise settlement requires homeowners to comply with all legal guidelines and rules, notably actual property rules. In 2020, two title insurance coverage firms issued particular alerts on Provider’s enterprise, advising their title officers to not enter into transactions with him with out additional authorized and underwriting evaluate. Provider hasn’t paid taxes on a few of his properties since early 2023, in line with court docket and public data, one other violation of his franchise settlement. Regardless of the obvious violations, HomeVestors didn’t terminate Provider’s franchise settlement.
“I don’t actually suppose they do have a lot in place to forestall one thing like this,” Ahern, the previous HomeVestors franchise proprietor, stated of the corporate. “HomeVestors on the time didn’t appear to have an inner system policing how franchises finance shopping for properties.”
A HomeVestors spokesperson stated the corporate focuses on its franchise clients’ experiences promoting their houses and doesn’t “dictate” how franchises increase capital. “The greater than 950 franchises of HomeVestors are impartial companies with all kinds of finance choices accessible to them,” the spokesperson stated.
Final spring, Provider started borrowing in opposition to his future receipts in trade for money advances with exorbitant charges and annualized rates of interest that he later claimed ranged as excessive as 600%. Between Could and October, he did this not less than seven instances, racking up greater than $1.2 million in debt past what he owed his traders, displays included with court docket filings present. By fall, he owed greater than $75,000 in funds per week, in line with the unique phrases. Seven firms filed go well with over the cash-advance agreements, accusing him of default. Provider has denied the allegations of default and has countersued 4 of the businesses, claiming he was charged unreasonably excessive rates of interest.
The lending scheme seems to have fallen in a grey space for state and federal securities rules. It’s unclear whether or not the promissory notes Provider issued to traders meet the definition of a safety, two specialists advised ProPublica.
In October, Provider’s traders started to confront him in regards to the lacking funds, together with Jeff Daly and Steve Needham, two of Provider’s largest traders who had been lending him cash for years. Provider got here clear to Daly, admitting he had been operating a lending scheme for “a number of” years, in line with a lawsuit Daly and Needham filed. He advised Needham he had taken out a number of loans on particular person properties with out disclosing them to the traders, in line with the lawsuit. The 2 males claimed of their lawsuit, which resulted in default judgments in opposition to Provider, that mixed they’d misplaced $13.5 million to Provider.
The investor who spoke to ProPublica and requested to not be named stated in an interview that Provider broke down in tears when confronted about dropping greater than $1 million of the investor’s cash. Provider admitted the loans paid for his working bills, not for purchasing and refurbishing homes, the investor stated.
“He simply pencil whipped these deeds on the finish,” the investor stated, explaining that Provider drew up paperwork however didn’t file them. As a result of the deeds have been by no means recorded, the investor had no lien on the properties and subsequently no collateral. Some deeds have been for homes that Provider didn’t personal or by no means purchased, the investor stated. “It was a whole fabrication.”
Welborn’s purchasers, who usually invested a lot smaller quantities with Provider, additionally discovered of the house-flipper’s collapse within the fall, when their funds stopped. Carver stated that Welborn known as him a few days after the October cost was due and stated, “Hey, I’m sorry to inform you this, however Chas has known as me and admitted to fraud.”
Carver stated he obtained within the automobile and drove to Welborn’s workplace, the place he discovered the nightmarish reality that every one the cash Provider had taken was gone.
“A Life-Altering Hit”
Buyers are deploying a wide range of methods to get their a reimbursement — a few of which pit greater traders in opposition to smaller ones and early traders in opposition to newer ones. Those that acted rapidly are recovering some cash by foreclosures and lawsuit settlements. Though Provider is denying allegations in lawsuits introduced by the cash-advance firms, he’s not combating particular person traders who’re suing him. Three of their lawsuits have resulted in judgments in opposition to Provider, and he has to date not defended himself in opposition to the others.
Welborn stated he’s doing his finest to assist his purchasers get well their cash by offering the mandatory paperwork, connecting them with consumers for the homes used as collateral and researching lien histories on the houses. When he first discovered of the scheme, Welborn tried to persuade his purchasers to signal on along with his lawyer to sue Provider. The lawyer, Anthony Cuesta, hoped a court docket would seize Provider’s belongings to assist get well the traders’ misplaced funds. However he rapidly discovered there have been too many traders and never sufficient fairness within the properties to fund the litigation. Now, a lot of Welborn’s purchasers are ready for the FBI and DOJ to behave, whereas wealthier traders are foreclosing on properties and making them ineligible for use for restitution. Welborn stated a few of his purchasers have been paid restitution by a DOJ-appointed actual property agent’s sale of Provider’s properties, however he declined to supply particulars.
Carver isn’t optimistic: “We’re not going to get a dime.”
A minimum of one investor went after Welborn individually. In line with a Securities and Change Fee disclosure, the declare was settled for $130,000. In his response to the SEC disclosure, Welborn denied breaching fiduciary obligation to the consumer and stated he “resolved the declare to keep away from controversy.” Welborn advised ProPublica that $120,000 of the settlement got here from the sale of the home used as collateral for the household’s mortgage and he paid $10,000 for his or her legal professional charges.
Welborn stated he’s “devastated” by the lack of his purchasers’ cash. “However day-after-day I drag myself to work with God’s assist and spend most of my day serving to lenders with their very own private restitution battles,” he stated.
Some traders stated they should return to work after having retired or are scrambling to search out some approach to substitute their misplaced earnings.
Carver needs he had paid extra consideration to crimson flags, like paperwork errors. However the month-to-month checks have been so dependable, he didn’t hearken to his intestine. Or his spouse.
“Each time I added cash, my spouse would say, ‘Don’t do it,’” Carver stated. “My mom, too. She would push on my dad to not add any extra. However he appreciated getting the month-to-month verify.”
Carver’s dad, Larry, believed it was one of the best performing funding he had ever made. When the cash disappeared, Carver went to work attempting to recoup a few of it. Possibly he might write it off on his taxes, he thought. He needed to get not less than one thing again for his dad. However Larry was in in poor health well being, and in February, he died.
“We Purchase Ugly Homes” Firm Overhauls Insurance policies within the Wake of ProPublica Investigation
“My dad handed considering he misplaced all of his cash to this man,” Carver stated, including he hopes Provider “goes to jail for a really very long time.”
The investor who requested to not be named stated the loss was “a life-changing hit.” He had retired at 53, after sticking it out in a job he hated till his inventory choices vested. When he lastly give up, he put the cash into Provider’s enterprise and lived off of the month-to-month funds. He might have to return to work.
“He was an boastful son of a bitch,” the investor stated. “It was gone earlier than he advised anybody there was an issue. That’s the unforgivable piece. He squandered all of it away. And he needed to get backed right into a nook earlier than he admitted it was all gone.”
Byard Duncan contributed reporting.
