Breadcrumb Path Hyperlinks
Economic system
Donald Trump has compelled a brand new urgency on the marketing campaign path and up and down the nation to unleash the North’s potential or threat Arctic sovereignty and a northern treasure trove of sources
Printed Apr 08, 2025 • Final up to date 19 hours in the past • 16 minute learn
It can save you this text by registering free of charge right here. Or sign-in you probably have an account.
A bit of a glacier is seen from NASA’s Operation IceBridge analysis plane on March 29, 2017 above Ellesmere Island, Canada. Picture by Mario Tama /Getty Photos
Article content material
Brendan Bell is aware of what it’s prefer to be ignored. It wasn’t so many months in the past that the chief govt of West Kitikmeot Assets Corp., an Inuit-owned firm proposing to construct a street and deepwater ocean port within the Arctic, was spending a piece of every day ready for non-Arctic folks to return his cellphone calls to debate the undertaking.
Article content material
Article content material
“This street isn’t a brand new concept,” he mentioned. “Roads have a protracted historical past within the North.”
Commercial 2
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues under.
THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY
Subscribe now to learn the most recent information in your metropolis and throughout Canada.
Unique articles from Barbara Shecter, Joe O’Connor, Gabriel Friedman, and others.Each day content material from Monetary Occasions, the world’s main world enterprise publication.Limitless on-line entry to learn articles from Monetary Publish, Nationwide Publish and 15 information websites throughout Canada with one account.Nationwide Publish ePaper, an digital reproduction of the print version to view on any gadget, share and touch upon.Each day puzzles, together with the New York Occasions Crossword.
SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES
Subscribe now to learn the most recent information in your metropolis and throughout Canada.
Unique articles from Barbara Shecter, Joe O’Connor, Gabriel Friedman and others.Each day content material from Monetary Occasions, the world’s main world enterprise publication.Limitless on-line entry to learn articles from Monetary Publish, Nationwide Publish and 15 information websites throughout Canada with one account.Nationwide Publish ePaper, an digital reproduction of the print version to view on any gadget, share and touch upon.Each day puzzles, together with the New York Occasions Crossword.
REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES
Create an account or sign up to proceed together with your studying expertise.
Entry articles from throughout Canada with one account.Share your ideas and be part of the dialog within the feedback.Get pleasure from extra articles monthly.Get e-mail updates out of your favorite authors.
THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK.
Create an account or sign up to proceed together with your studying expertise.
Entry articles from throughout Canada with one accountShare your ideas and be part of the dialog within the commentsEnjoy extra articles per monthGet e-mail updates out of your favorite authors
Signal In or Create an Account
or
Article content material
Do they ever. But that historical past could be summarized as roads — and main infrastructure tasks of every type — could get proposed for the Arctic, however they typically don’t get constructed. No shock then that Bell had been contending with an totally non-urgent vibe from different folks in relation to the Grays Bay Street and Port Venture. That’s till just lately, when quite a lot of those self same folks began calling him again.
Prime Tales
Thanks for signing up!
Article content material
Given all roads result in Donald Trump these days, it’s no thriller why. In launching a commerce struggle towards Canada, america is not a pleasant ally, at the least on the high, and that may be a driving motive behind why the narrative round roads that don’t get constructed within the Arctic has shifted to at least one that Canada higher begin constructing roads, deepwater ports, naval installations, mines, energy grids and fibre-optic networks as quickly as attainable or threat ceding its Arctic sovereignty and a northern treasure home of essential minerals to a international energy.
A few of that treasure takes the type of gold, which is at present buying and selling at round US$3,000 an oz.. Canadian gold miner Agnico Eagle Mines Ltd. believes its Hope Bay property within the Nunavut may produce as a lot as 400,000 ounces per yr.
The Northwest Territories, in the meantime, is peppered with greater than 1,200 energetic mining claims, whereas Nunavut is believed to be house to as much as 30 per cent of Canada’s petroleum reserves and Yukon is ranked as a high 10 area worldwide when it comes to its mineral endowment, in accordance with the Fraser Institute’s 2023 annual survey of mining firms. All advised, the dialog round what all of the untapped northern bounty could possibly be price begins within the trillions.
Article content material
Article content material
Conservative Chief Pierre Poilievre speaks throughout a rally in Iqaluit final yr. Liberal Chief Mark Carney, proper, shakes fingers with Nunavut Premier P.J. Akeeagok throughout a gathering in Iqaluit in March. Celebration leaders are beginning to pay extra consideration to the North because the stakes rise round Canadian sovereignty. Picture by Dustin Patar, Sean Kilpatrick /The Canadian Press
Proof of this newfound sense of urgency to cease speaking in regards to the Arctic and begin doing issues retains popping up in Nunavut. Liberal Chief Mark Carney, Conservative Chief Pierre Poilievre and NDP head Jagmeet Singh have all stopped in Iqaluit in current weeks. Relying upon which get together platform you pull from, the politicians have dedicated to extra infrastructure, higher collaboration with the Inuit, elevated navy spending, investing in vitality upgrades and satisfactory housing and boosting Canada’s functionality to unleash the North’s financial potential.
“Canadians was keen on the previous Winston Churchill quote about People that they may in the end do the correct factor after making an attempt all the things else,” Bell mentioned. “However because it pertains to the Arctic, Canada has actually tried all the things else. We’ve tried ignoring it. We’ve tried underinvesting in its communities and in its infrastructure. We’ve tried letting the People be chargeable for our continental defence. And, ultimately, we are able to see now that it simply isn’t sustainable. The temper of the nation has modified.”
Being mightily ticked at Trump and expressing your patriotism by shopping for Canadian merchandise on the grocery retailer is a way more simple and cheap (comparatively talking) approach of taking management of your destiny than supercharging the financial improvement of the North. Because the previous saying goes, it’s worthwhile to begin someplace, however exterior of some mines dotted right here and there, creating the North has barely begun in any respect regardless of a long time of guarantees to make it occur.
Article content material
Whether or not the present era can drum up the desire and the money to lastly dig in and get huge, formidable tasks achieved, ones that drive Arctic and nationwide prosperity whereas safeguarding Canada from worldwide bullies, may decide the nation’s long-term destiny.
The People have at all times understood the Northwest Passage as a safety challenge, which has meant conserving the Soviets, and now the Russians, away, mentioned Rob Huebert, a political scientist at College of Calgary. With Donald Trump on the helm, that assumption has modified. Picture by Larry Wong /Postmedia
If that sounds alarmist, it’s price having a quick chat with Rob Huebert, a political scientist on the College of Calgary, in regards to the Northwest Passage. Within the days of yore, this shortcut between the Atlantic and Pacific oceans stoked the creativeness of explorers, who would set off in the hunt for an ice-free route and infrequently get caught within the ice.
These days, the passage is navigable for a stretch of time in the summertime and fall. The speculation holds that because the world warms up and extra sea ice melts, the passage will develop into an more and more engaging delivery lane, so controlling it’s key. Canada’s place is that the Northwest Passage belongs to Canada. The People, to paraphrase, have lengthy claimed the passage as worldwide waters.
In apply, the disagreement between neighbours has been a remarkably well mannered affair. A U.S. ship has by no means entered the passage with out first informing the Canadians what it’s as much as. Granted, People inform moderately than ask for permission, however in addition they sometimes request a Canadian icebreaker be someplace close by in case they run into any issues with the ice.
Article content material
“The People have at all times understood the Northwest Passage as a safety challenge, which has meant conserving the Soviets, and now the Russians, away,” Huebert mentioned.
We are actually in a state of affairs the place we’re utterly uncovered within the North
Rob Huebert, political scientist, College of Calgary
The People have additionally traditionally achieved the heavy lifting when it comes to conserving the Russians away, permitting Canada to blissfully flake out and, till final yr, classify the Arctic as an “space of remarkable” peace, regardless of Russia having an intensive community of navy bases and a number of other nuclear-powered icebreakers at its disposal.
“The Russian menace is clearly understood,” Huebert mentioned. “Now, impulsively, you get Trump again and he has proven a willingness to throw his allies beneath the bus, and he’s additionally threatening the existence of Canada. We are actually in a state of affairs the place we’re utterly uncovered within the North.”
Issues are unhealthy, however that could possibly be good for West Kitikmeot’s Grays Bay Street and Port Venture. The corporate has obtained dribs and drabs of federal funding through the years to conduct street feasibility research and the like, however there aren’t any bulldozers on the instant horizon.
The proposal to construct a 230-kilometre all-weather street in the course of a mineral-rich space of the central Arctic, one that will tie into ice roads and in the end join a proposed deepwater port, that includes a bunch of bells (upkeep sheds) and whistles (an airstrip), to Yellowknife and southern Canada requires some chicken-and-egg-type pondering.
Article content material
Article content material
A polar bear walks alongside the ice circulate within the Franklin Strait within the Northwest Passage. The passage, as soon as impregnable, is now open to ship navigation in the summertime and a part of the autumn. The speculation holds that because the world warms up and extra sea ice melts, the passage will develop into an more and more engaging delivery lane, so controlling it’s key. Picture by Jonathan Hayward /The Canadian Press
The foremost mineral deposits — copper, zinc, gold and silver — don’t have to be found. Mining firms have been conscious of their existence for many years. Bell’s rivalry is that in case you construct the primary street, department roads resulting in new mines will observe because the economics of creating a mine go from, “We all know the copper is there, however we simply can’t get to it,” to, “We all know the copper is there and we now have a approach of getting it to market.”
The proposed deepwater port may additionally serve a twin goal. In any case, the Canadian navy goes to want someplace to dock provided that the Nanisivik Naval Facility, first introduced by prime minister Stephen Harper in 2007 and repeatedly scaled again since then in scope and stricken by development delays, together with a sinking wharf and a lead contractor going bankrupt, in addition to rife with boneheaded, impractical design parts, comparable to unheated gasoline tanks, nonetheless doesn’t have a gap date.
Had been the Royal Canadian Navy to decide to a long-term lease settlement with West Kitikmeot, the corporate may take it as proof of future income as a way to elevate capital from the personal sector in an association Bell foresees being cut up 75-25 between private and non-private.
Article content material
On that entrance, he has been assembly with the Division of Nationwide Defence to know the scope of the navy’s wants. There’s progress. Shifting ahead, a street may embody a fibre-optic communications hall and probably even a liquefied pure gasoline pipeline.
No one goes to make an funding privately on hypothesis that mines sooner or later will come alongside
Brendan Bell, CEO, West Kitikmeot Assets
“No one goes to make an funding privately on hypothesis that mines sooner or later will come alongside; they’re going to want one thing extra concrete than that,” he mentioned. “That’s actually the following piece for us to resolve.”
In fact, the uncomfortable query is, how a lot is the street going to price?
Bell hesitates to provide a tough quantity as a result of the quantity he’s working with is a projection based mostly on a research from 2018, however he figures in case you begin at $1 billion, and throw in one other $400 million or so for the port, you then could be heading in the right direction.
Constructing something within the Arctic goes to contain some sticker shock. Additionally required is a eager understanding that the bottom beneath no matter will get constructed — a street, port, faculty, city or mine — could soften. As a substitute of the form of bedrock structural engineers favour when sinking development pilings, the Arctic, significantly the western portion, is full of permafrost, or completely frozen floor that’s now within the strategy of completely unfreezing at an alarming fee.
Article content material
“Once we speak about constructing within the Arctic, basis designers should begin to contemplate how a lot overdesigning we’re going to should do to anticipate what a constructing will want in 30 years’ time,” Chris Burn, a bodily geography professor at Carleton College, mentioned. “If we construct issues to right this moment’s code, all goes to be effectively, it’ll be simply high quality, however then in 15 years there’s going to be an issue.”
Brendan Bell, proper, is chief govt of West Kitikmeot Assets Corp., an Inuit-owned firm proposing to construct a street and deepwater ocean port within the Arctic. Picture by Handout /West Kitikmeot Assets Corp.
Burn is a Brit and attended a sequence of lectures on permafrost as an undergraduate within the Nineteen Seventies. Midway via the second, he knew what he needed to do together with his life, and the place to do it, at the least for an English-speaking scholar, was the Canadian Arctic.
He went on to develop into president of the Worldwide Permafrost Affiliation for a time, and he’s considerably of a legend in Canadian Arctic permafrost analysis circles. He’s additionally the man that northerners name to seek the advice of with on constructing tasks, together with the Inuvik-Tuktoyaktuk Freeway.
The 138-kilometre, two-lane, all-weather gravel street tying the group of Tuktoyaktuk on the Arctic coast to the remainder of Canada’s street community opened in 2017. The value tag was $300 million and its completion allowed Canada, 150 years post-Confederation, to assert it was linked by street from coast to coast to coast.
Article content material
The ice within the floor is what holds the permafrost collectively
Chris Burn, geography professor, Carleton College
However beneath the proudly Canadian optics of tethering the nation north to south was the chilling actuality of constructing infrastructure within the permafrost zone.
“The ice within the floor is what holds the permafrost collectively,” Burn mentioned.
Consider the ice because the glue. A brand new, hypothetical four-storey constructing constructed to serve an equally new, hypothetical Arctic outpost would sometimes be constructed on pilings. Present engineering knowledge permits that after pilings are sunk within the permafrost, a constructing is successfully frozen in place. However because the permafrost thaws, and the glue unsticks, the constructing could possibly be on the transfer: sinking, shifting or toppling over altogether.
Roads are much more dicey. Buildings have small footprints, however future Arctic roads will traverse a number of constructing environments and the quantity of ice-glue within the floor will range relying on the placement, Burn mentioned.
Article content material
The Inuvik-Tuktoyaktuk Freeway, the 138-kilometre, two-lane, all-weather gravel street tying the group of Tuktoyaktuk on the Arctic coast to the remainder of Canada’s street community opened in 2017. The value tag was $300 million and its completion allowed Canada, 150 years post-Confederation, to assert it was linked by street from coast to coast to coast. Picture by James MacKenzie /The Canada Press
In a panorama that’s buzzing with, say, mining tasks, the ice-glue might want to help the burden of industrial-scale vehicles. So long as the glue sticks, all will probably be effectively, however ought to the glue lose its stickiness as a result of temperature will increase, the street could be in huge hassle and wish substantial repairs whereas those that journey upon it could possibly be put at grave threat.
Article content material
“Realizing the amount of ice beneath the street is a very essential a part of the knowledge wanted to design the street as a result of the designers should determine how they’re going to maintain that ice frozen,” Burn mentioned.
One brilliant concept has been to refrigerate the permafrost. The Shakwak hall is a essential stretch of the Alaska Freeway connecting the state, by way of Yukon and British Columbia, to the decrease 48 states. Canada and the U.S. have lengthy co-operated in sustaining the freeway, and a giant chunk of that job in current a long time has been determining what to do in regards to the thawing permafrost inflicting gargantuan potholes, bumps and cracks, in addition to warping guardrails on the freeway’s edge.
The group of Beaver Creek in western Yukon piloted a undertaking involving thermosyphons: image a white pipe caught within the floor subsequent to the street that’s designed to vent warmth from beneath the street whereas carrying chilly again into the permafrost. The devices are a comparatively low-tech approach of addressing thawing permafrost, however low-tech shouldn’t be confused with cheap.
We’re not going to be constructing roads for $8 million a kilometre. We do not try this in Canada
Chris Burn, geography professor, Carleton College
“Beaver Creek’s thermosyphon undertaking price $4 million and that was for 400 metres of street, which might work out to about $8 million per kilometre,” Burn mentioned. “We’re not going to be constructing roads for $8 million a kilometre. We don’t try this in Canada.”
Article content material
On high of that, street upkeep in areas of thawing permafrost is already six instances pricier than sustaining roads in areas the place the permafrost “is secure or absent,” in accordance with the Yukon authorities. Burn mentioned extra thawing permafrost is within the playing cards, so extra Arctic architects, street designers, upkeep sorts and accountants will presumably be puzzling over what to do about it and tips on how to price range for it.
Taken as a complete, a terrific, imagined Arctic infrastructure build-out might sound a bit daunting, however Canada has not at all times been afraid of dreaming huge. Contemplate John Diefenbaker’s Northern Imaginative and prescient.
The nation’s so-called Prairie populist prime minister uncorked a barnburner of a speech earlier than a packed home on the Winnipeg Civic Auditorium throughout a 1958 election marketing campaign that his Conservatives went on to win in a blowout. Diefenbaker, whose oratorical chops have been substantial, was by no means finer nor extra fiery that day as he spoke of a “new” Canada infused with a way of nationwide goal and future.
Natan Obed, president of Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, delivers remarks on the Nationwide Press Theatre in Ottawa in 2023. Obed mentioned, whereas the Inuit are the primary Canadians, they view themselves as Canadians first. Picture by Spencer Colby /The Canadian Press
“What number of of you right here knew the pioneers in Western Canada?” he mentioned. “I noticed the early days right here, right here in Winnipeg in 1909, when the huge motion was happening into the Western plains — that they had creativeness. There’s a new creativeness now. The Arctic.”
Article content material
This new Canada could be a “Canada of the North,” linked by a community of northern roads, lit up by energy grids, airports, mines and hydroelectric tasks, you title it, all constructed to tame — and exploit — the final nice Canadian frontier whereas creating lots of of 1000’s of jobs and safeguarding the nation’s “independence” from you understand who to the south.
It needs to be famous that the Inuit didn’t view their house as some wild, untamed frontier, nor have been they consulted about Diefenbaker’s grand plan, an oversight that will have been way more egregious had the North he envisioned been constructed.
In actuality, after a short-lived burst of exercise, which produced about 100-kilometres price of street and a railway connecting a lead and zinc mine within the Northwest Territories to a railway junction in northern Alberta that right this moment serves as a recreation path, Diefenbaker’s imaginative and prescient succumbed to ballooning prices and a refrain of barbs from its critics, together with the Liberals, whose quip that he was constructing roads from “igloo to igloo” resonated with the much less enlightened Canada of the age.
I do not suppose any of us have ever shied away, on the Inuit aspect, from speaking about what it will take to carry the Inuit into Canada
Natan Obed, president, Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami
Six-plus a long time later, the Arctic has re-emerged as a nationwide precedence, leaving the Inuit to surprise what took us so lengthy.
Article content material
“I don’t suppose any of us have ever shied away, on the Inuit aspect, from speaking about what it will take to carry the Inuit into Canada,” Natan Obed, president of the Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, mentioned. “The prices concerned are going to be huge.”
He mentioned there are some fundamental info about Inuit that southern Canadians want to concentrate on. At the start, whereas the Inuit are the “first Canadians,” they view themselves as “Canadians first.” In brief, they’re simply as patriotic, if no more so, than most.
Obed performed school hockey within the U.S. He just lately purchased a brand new pair of blades for an unprintable sum for his weekly pick-up skates in Ottawa, and he mentioned watching Canada beat the Soviet Union within the ultimate of the 1987 Canada Cup was among the many most defining recollections of his childhood.
Again then, he was in North West River, a small, predominantly Inuit city in Labrador, and had by no means been to an NHL sport, not to mention to Ontario, however cheering for his nation linked him to the nation past his entrance door, he mentioned. There’s a deep and affectionate bond for Canada within the North, and it’s one which southern Canadians can at instances seem oblivious to, assuming they even hassle to consider the Arctic within the first place.
Article content material
What the Arctic isn’t, Obed mentioned, is an incomprehensibly huge, unmanageable area. It’s house to 51 Inuit communities and its residents found out tips on how to dwell there eons in the past. They view it not as a northern “wasteland,” however as a homeland with “huge potential” that they’re eager to develop.
Merely put, the locals need in on the useful resource improvement motion, and improvement begins with with the ability to entry the sources, which requires constructing infrastructure of the sort Diefenbaker was speaking about again within the Fifties.
The Inuit have already got fashionable treaties and a constructive framework in place for useful resource improvement with the Canadian authorities. The bureaucratic heavy lifting has been achieved. What has been lacking, Obed mentioned, is the collective will to roll up our sleeves and get at it.
Article content material
Aaju Peter, a 65-year-old, Greenland-born Inuit activist, lawyer, artisan and language preservation instructor in Iqaluit, mentioned there’s not a lot in the best way of fundamental providers designed to boost the scaling-up of a small enterprise, or any enterprise within the Arctic. Picture by Michelle Valberg
“As Inuit, we’re at all times invoking the creation of the nation, and the creativeness of the founders had for constructing east-west connections,” he mentioned. “Sooner or later, the railway that was constructed throughout the nation would have been thought of so much like what we’re proposing with constructing infrastructure that connects north and south. Sure, it will price some huge cash, however it’s a nation-building train, and if Canada significantly talks about being an Arctic nation state, it’s time that Canada actually understands what which means and responds to it.”
Article content material
For instance, think about you might be an Inuit entrepreneur or, higher but, think about you might be Aaju Peter, a 65-year-old, Greenland-born Inuit activist, lawyer, artisan and language preservation instructor in Iqaluit.
When she isn’t educating Inuktitut to daycare employees on the native school or doing on-line coursework for a diploma via the College of Victoria, she makes sealskin clothes, all the things from males’s ties to sealskin mitts to beaver hats, with fox fur trim, that retail for $495. She mentioned her stitching machine is in regards to the measurement of a coffeemaker and weighs 50 kilos, however she has to both ship it to Ottawa when it wants servicing, lug it onto a aircraft and fly it down herself or troubleshoot the issue and repair it.
Her level? There is no such thing as a appropriate restore store in Iqaluit, and never a lot else in the best way of fundamental providers designed to boost the scaling-up of a small enterprise, or any enterprise, and that extends to the obtainable technique of getting merchandise to market.
There is no such thing as a street to Montreal or Toronto. For delivery, it’s Canada Publish or bust, whereas on-line gross sales depend on a expensive satellite tv for pc web community supplier that may have reliability points. Different challenges are much more instant, Peter mentioned, comparable to how do you price range for groceries when a field of macaroni prices 10 instances what it does within the south?
Article content material
The hassle to easily get by within the Arctic could be vital.
Peter is in her sixties, so she has expertise in dealing with what life throws at her and may handle a heavy workload. However for a younger Arctic striver, making an attempt to determine tips on how to pay hire, go to highschool and juggle a job or two can appear overwhelming. She isn’t advocating for handouts, however a few of the fundamentals have to be addressed when folks speak about constructing infrastructure within the North.
“How will you have true sovereignty in case you’re not implementing the identical requirements as in the remainder of Canada and in case you don’t have correct infrastructure?” she mentioned. “Canada must need the Inuit to be Canadian, however to get there, we have to have higher alternatives, higher dwelling situations, correct financing and help. If our lives have been made a bit simpler, we might have a a lot more healthy and better-educated inhabitants.”
The knock-on impact could be a northern, homegrown workforce for the imagined roads, faculties, daycares, machine restore jobs, authorities places of work, mines and ports of the Canadian Arctic future, and who would even be stakeholders, if not outright house owners, of regardless of the enterprise occurs to be.
The problem will probably be determining tips on how to pay for it, and never over the course of a single political cycle, however over a long time, whereas keeping track of the final word prize of constructing an Arctic that isn’t an afterthought, however a northern financial engine boosting the nation’s total wealth.
For these wishing to debate additional, Brendan Bell is anticipating your name.
• E mail: joconnor@postmedia.com
Bookmark our web site and help our journalism: Don’t miss the enterprise information it’s worthwhile to know — add financialpost.com to your bookmarks and join our newsletters right here.
Article content material
Share this text in your social community
