ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of energy. Signal as much as obtain our largest tales as quickly as they’re revealed.
Since not less than April 2021, the Montana medical licensing board has had proof, together with 1000’s of pages of affected person recordsdata and medical critiques, that Dr. Thomas C. Weiner, a preferred Helena oncologist, had damage and doubtlessly killed sufferers, ProPublica and Montana Free Press have realized. But in that point, the board renewed his medical license — twice.
Weiner directed the most cancers middle at St. Peter’s Well being for twenty-four years earlier than he was fired in 2020 and accused of overprescribing narcotics, treating individuals who didn’t have most cancers with chemotherapy and offering substandard care. Weiner, who has denied the allegations, was the topic of a December ProPublica investigation, which revealed a documented path of affected person hurt and not less than 10 suspicious deaths. Most of the information cited within the story had been within the medical board’s custody for practically 4 years, St. Peter’s just lately confirmed.
The Board of Medical Examiners renewed Weiner’s medical license in March 2023 and this month, authorizing him to deal with sufferers and prescribe medication. Whereas legal professionals for the state company that oversees the medical board collected information from the hospital below subpoena, together with medical critiques that criticized Weiner’s care, that inquiry languished on the employees degree, in line with one present and one former board member. It’s unclear why Weiner’s case was not elevated to the governor-appointed board members.
Sam Loveridge, a spokesperson for the Division of Labor and Business, the board’s umbrella company, didn’t reply an inventory of emailed questions, together with whether or not the information offered by the hospital have been reviewed by members of the board.
Kathleen Abke, a lawyer representing St. Peter’s, instructed ProPublica and Montana Free Press that the hospital initially surrendered to the licensing board 160,000 pages of paperwork referring to the care of 64 sufferers; the state acquired these information in early 2021, simply months after Weiner was fired.
What We’re Watching
Throughout Donald Trump’s second presidency, ProPublica will concentrate on the areas most in want of scrutiny. Listed below are among the points our reporters shall be watching — and the way to get in contact with them securely.
We’re attempting one thing new. Was it useful?
As a part of the subpoena, St. Peter’s equipped the medical information of Scot Warwick, whom Weiner identified with Stage 4 lung most cancers in 2009. Regardless that there had not been a lung biopsy to verify that Warwick had the illness, Weiner proceeded to provide him chemotherapy and different therapies for 11 years. After Warwick died in 2020, an post-mortem — which St. Peter’s stated it gave to the medical board — discovered no proof of most cancers. Weiner maintained the affected person had terminal most cancers for 11 years and stated a pathologist and autopsy health worker missed the illness.
Lisa Warwick, Scot’s widow, sued St. Peter’s for his wrongful demise and settled for an undisclosed quantity. Warwick realized from ProPublica and Montana Free Press this month that the state had her husband’s information and different proof for years. She referred to as the state of affairs “appalling.”
“I might identical to to know what data they’re reviewing that sways their willpower to resume this man’s license,” she stated. “As a result of if they’re really doing their job and are reviewing this stuff and taking a look at all of the instances which were introduced forth — the individuals who have died, the circumstances below which they died — there isn’t any manner they’ll justify renewing this man’s license.”
Anthony Olson, one other Weiner affected person who inappropriately acquired chemotherapy for practically a decade, expressed shock when he realized Montana regulators had details about his case as early as 2021. Three biopsies confirmed that Olson by no means had most cancers, in line with court docket and medical information. That chemo created extreme well being problems for Olson.
“So they only actually don’t care?” Olson requested. “It provides me the shakes. My coronary heart’s racing, and I actually don’t know what to really feel proper now.”
Weiner blamed different medical doctors for Olson’s misdiagnosis however acknowledged he acquired poisonous therapies “needlessly.”
In Montana, medical licenses are up for renewal each two years. Just a few months after the board renewed Weiner’s license in 2023, its employees subpoenaed the hospital for extra information. Abke stated St. Peter’s offered the board with 1000’s extra inside paperwork and medical critiques. But, she stated, nobody from the hospital was referred to as by the board to testify about Weiner’s practices.
St. Peter’s confirmed that the second tranche included the medical information of Nadine Lengthy, a 16-year-old lady who, court docket and medical information present, died in 2015 shortly after Weiner ordered the injection of a considerable amount of phenobarbitala strong sedative. Weiner has denied wrongdoing within the case. Sustaining that the lady’s situation was terminal, he stated he was offering consolation.
St. Peter’s additionally reported Weiner’s removing to the Nationwide Practitioner Knowledge Financial institution and alerted the federal Drug Enforcement Administration to his alleged narcotics practices, in line with information and interviews.
“We offered data to each entity that had the power to do one thing about this,” Abke stated. “St. Peter’s took these allegations extraordinarily critically.”
Dr. James Burkholder, a member of the medical licensing board from 2016 to 2023, instructed ProPublica and Montana Free Press that Weiner’s identify “by no means got here up” throughout board deliberations. Burkholder, a retired household physician from Helena, stated he’s sure the case didn’t attain the board degree as a result of he is aware of Weiner professionally and would have recused himself. He additionally served on the screening subcommittee that will have first reviewed the state’s investigation into Weiner and handed it as much as the total board to be adjudicated.
Dr. Carley Robertson, a present board member, stated she’s by no means heard of Weiner.
It’s unclear what number of complaints have been filed towards Weiner, because the medical board retains details about instances that weren’t substantiated secret. ProPublica and Montana Free Press confirmed that not less than one licensing criticism towards Weiner, filed in 2021, was pending for 3 years earlier than being dismissed in December.
Marilyn Ketchum’s husband died whereas below Weiner’s care. After reviewing her husband’s medical information, she took her considerations about Weiner to the medical licensing board.
Credit score:
Melyssa St. Michael for ProPublica
Just a few months after studying native information experiences about Weiner being fired by St. Peter’s, Marilyn Ketchum determined to behave on considerations about her husband, Shawn Ketchum, who died again in 2016 whereas below Weiner’s care. After reviewing his medical information, she instructed the board that Weiner altered her husband’s code standing with out permission. If his coronary heart stopped, he needed to be a full codeshe stated, that means he needed to be resuscitated. As an alternative, when he was rushed to the hospital, Weiner maintained that Ketchum was a DNR/DNI — don’t resuscitate and don’t intubate — his medical information present. Ketchum died with out intervention quickly after, in line with the information.
In its inside critiques of Weiner’s care, St. Peter’s alleged that unilaterally altering sufferers’ code standing was a “commonplace observe” of his, which it referred to as “a severe violation of the usual of care and medical ethics.” Weiner didn’t reply to questions on Ketchum’s case and has denied that he ever modified a affected person’s standing with out permission.
Ketchum, who now lives in Arkansas, stated a state worker didn’t interview her till two years after she made a criticism towards Weiner’s license. “I used to be on their ass to do one thing about it,” Ketchum stated, emailing or calling somebody from the labor division “each couple of weeks.”
In a letter despatched in late 2024, the board offered no clarification for why it had dismissed her criticism.
Weiner has stated he’s not at present treating sufferers as a result of he can’t get malpractice insurance coverage.
Following the ProPublica investigation revealed in December, the Montana Division of Justice launched a legal inquiry into Weiner, in line with three individuals with direct information of the case. Weiner has not been charged with a criminal offense. In separate instances final 12 months, the U.S. Division of Justice sued Weiner and the hospital, alleging they defrauded federal well being care applications. The hospital settled for $10.8 million. Weiner has denied the allegations by an lawyer and petitioned the court docket to dismiss the case.
“Eat What You Kill”
Final month, Weiner misplaced an attraction of a yearslong court docket battle over his firing. The Montana Supreme Courtroom dominated that the hospital’s actions have been “affordable and warranted as a result of amount and severity of Weiner’s inappropriate affected person care.”
Nonetheless, since Weiner’s firing, many Helena residents proceed to defend himtogether with by funding billboards that proclaim “WE STAND WITH DR. WEINER.” Weiner’s supporters, usually citing his renewed medical license, have accused the hospital of orchestrating a smear marketing campaign towards a devoted oncologist. Because the winter of 2020, they’ve held protests outdoors of the hospital.
Abke stated many St. Peter’s staff are exhausted by the blowback from Weiner’s supporters and are working to regain belief in Helena. Requested about considerations that the hospital unfairly focused Weiner, Abke stated, “No hospital would need to take the monetary, the PR, the private hit for no cause.”
