A naturalization ceremony on the Nevins Library in Massachusetts on Oct. 30, 2024.
David L. Ryan/The Boston Globe through Getty Photos
cover caption
toggle caption
David L. Ryan/The Boston Globe through Getty Photos
Over the previous 20 years, it is turn into a convention for every president to craft their very own speech to welcome new residents.
These video messages, performed at naturalization ceremonies nationwide, are transient however specialists in presidential rhetoric say they’re vital — not solely are they significant to newly naturalized residents, however they supply perception on how every president values immigration and their broader imaginative and prescient for the nation.
President Trump, whose second time period has been marked by his hard-line strategy to immigration, launched a brand new naturalization ceremony video final month.
“At this time you obtain one of the vital priceless items ever granted by human fingers. You turn into a citizen of the US of America,” Trump mentioned.
Trump went on to welcome new residents into the “nationwide household,” including that they now have a accountability to “fiercely guard” and protect American tradition, together with the liberty of speech, faith and the correct to bear arms.
“ That matches into his bigger narrative, however that is not often what you see at an American naturalization ceremony. It is far more of a celebration and I am not saying that Trump does not have fun these concepts, nevertheless it’s much less celebratory than his predecessors,” mentioned Jason Edwards, a communications professor at Bridgewater State College in Massachusetts who has studied presidential welcomes to new residents.
Departure from previous presidents’ remarks
Solely a handful of presidents have delivered remarks at naturalization ceremonies, both by way of video or in particular person. That features Gerald Ford, George W. Bush, Barack Obama and Joe Biden.
Edwards mentioned most have centered their message on how immigrants enrich and renew the nation, whereas Trump’s remarks emphasised what the U.S. has to supply new residents.
“Regardless of the place you come from, you now share a house and a heritage with a number of the most distinctive heroes, legends and patriots to ever stroll the face of the Earth,” Trump mentioned in his speech.
“ There isn’t any heterogeneity, there isn’t any celebration of range, there isn’t any celebration of previous immigrants,” Edwards mentioned.
A spokesman for the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Providers, or USCIS, which launched Trump’s video, mentioned his message is “a vital one” and could be a part of naturalization ceremonies shifting ahead.
That message: “U.S. citizenship is a privilege and reserved for individuals who respect our legal guidelines, tradition, and historical past,” USCIS spokesman Matthew Tragesser mentioned in a press launch concerning the video.
In each his first and second time period, Trump prevented utilizing the phrase “immigrant” altogether in his video message congratulating new residents. That additionally strayed from his predecessors, who typically known as the U.S. a nation of immigrants and acknowledged the journey that newcomers took to turn into Americans.
Biden, for instance, spoke about immigrants’ sacrifices and braveness, including that his personal ancestors immigrated to the U.S. from Eire.
“I do not wanna say it is an erasure, nevertheless it’s desirous to form of erase that concept — you are now not an immigrant, you’re a citizen,” Edwards mentioned, referring to Trump’s remarks.
As an alternative, Trump shifted the main focus to the concept of a “nationwide household,” which regularly implies loyalty and obligation, based on Matthew Eshbaugh-Soha, a political science professor on the College of North Texas.
Eshbaugh-Soha added that the emphasis on household and the specific reference to the correct to bear arms are in keeping with conventional conservative values — which can be uncommon for ceremonial speeches like naturalization occasions.
“That concept of American household may be very a lot consistent with this concept of America first,” he mentioned.
Typically, Trump’s rhetoric on immigration has intensified throughout his second time period, particularly throughout his most up-to-date presidential marketing campaign, based on Jennifer Mercieca, a historian of American political rhetoric at Texas A&M College.
“ The metaphors that he used about immigration, whether or not it was an invasion, whether or not immigrants had been poisoning the blood of the nation and issues like that,” Mercieca mentioned. “These are very salient methods of speaking about immigration and very totally different from the ways in which earlier presidents have performed.”
