ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of energy. Signal as much as obtain our greatest tales as quickly as they’re revealed.
Reporting Highlights
Sinister Affect: An easygoing DJ led a twin life as an internet propagandist for white supremacist hate and, prosecutors say, impressed followers to kill LGBTQ+ folks and other people of colour.
Producer of Hate: For years, Matthew Allison took benefit of lax moderation on the social media platform Telegram to churn out movies — round 120 in complete — celebrating white terrorism.
A Free Speech Protection: Allison has stated he’s a video “artist” and doesn’t hate anybody. He denied inciting folks to commit violence and plans to struggle his case on First Modification grounds.
These highlights had been written by the reporters and editors who labored on this story.
Early final yr, Matthew Allison might be discovered on the Area Banana dance membership, awkwardly swaying to his personal beat. Clutching the most cost effective home beer, he’d greet folks with a bear hug, a broad grin and his acquainted, “Yo, bro!” salutations.
Allison, then a 37-year-old comfort retailer employee and Saturday-night DJ, appeared to love everybody he met in Boise, Idaho’s small digital dance music scene. And most of the people appeared to love him again.
He was so mild, former pals bear in mind, that for a time he eschewed honey in order to not trigger hurt to bees.
He was “a bit of goofy,” a former buddy, Tyler Whitt, recalled. “However bro goofy.”
However that cute persona hid a extra sinister core. When he was behind his laptop display, Allison used the deal with BTC, quick for BanThisChannel, he instructed ProPublica and FRONTLINE. On the social media and messaging platform Telegram, authorities say, Allison was a key determine in a community of white supremacist and neo-Nazi discussion groups and channels referred to as Terrorgram.
There, Allison held court docket, selling himself as “essentially the most notorious and prolific propagandist of our time.”
Hyperbole apart, BTC was notorious. Extremism researchers within the U.S. and in Europe studied his posts however didn’t know who he was. Leftist activists sought to show him. And legislation enforcement authorities tried to determine and jail him.
Final September, he was lastly arrested.
Prosecutors allege that Allison was one of many leaders within the Terrorgram Collective, a secretive group that produced propaganda and directions for terrorists, and disseminated that data via the Terrorgram ecosystem.
They say Allison used the Telegram platform to solicit “assaults on authorities infrastructure, corresponding to authorities buildings and vitality services,” to encourage the assassination of “‘high-value targets’ — like politicians and authorities officers” with a “hit record,” and to assist produce and distribute a Terrorgram Collective publication that featured directions for making “Napalm, thermite, chlorine gasoline, pipe bombs, and soiled bombs.”
About This Partnership
This story is a part of a collaborative investigation from ProPublica and FRONTLINE that features an upcoming documentary, “The Rise and Fall of Terrorgram,” which premieres March 25 at 10 p.m. EDT/9 p.m. CDT on PBS stations (verify native listings) and will likely be out there to stream on YouTube, the PBS App and FRONTLINE’s web site.
Authorities additionally contend in court docket filings that Allison had fantasies about committing grotesque violence and sexual assault, and that he could have been planning to behave on them.
Allison has pleaded not responsible.
For about 5 years, the Terrorgram community operated largely unchallenged on Telegram, which has almost one billion customers. The Dubai-based firm did little to forestall influencers like Allison from circulating their propaganda and inspiring remoted younger males to kill, a ProPublica and FRONTLINE investigation discovered.
The information organizations obtained a trove of now-deleted Telegram chats and channel logs and used them to hint Allison’s exercise and affect within the Terrorgram community.
Telegram has declined repeated requests to make its executives out there for interviews however stated in an announcement, “When the Terrorgram title first surfaced years in the past, we started eradicating teams and channels that used variations on the Terrorgram title. Requires violence from any group aren’t tolerated on our platform.”
Within the annals of white supremacist content material on-line, Allison’s work stood out. “It was a number of the most inflammatory propaganda that I had seen,” stated Jennefer Harper, a researcher who has amassed a big archive of neo-Nazi supplies from Telegram. Allison was additionally prolific. “This propaganda was being posted 24/7! The account wasn’t taking a break, it was like, ‘Don’t you may have the rest to do in your life?’”
He specialised in what he known as documentaries, and over greater than 5 years, he stated, he made and posted round 120 movies. There have been photos of riots, burning cities and Black folks brutalizing white folks. There was GoPro footage of massacres filmed by white killers as they murdered folks of colour.
Allison and the opposite Terrorgram leaders discovered a receptive viewers for his or her propaganda. A few of their followers acquired off their telephones and took motion: scoping out high-profile targets and even killing folks. ProPublica and FRONTLINE used the chat logs, court docket data and different sources to attach 35 legal instances to the Terrorgram community. Every case concerned a person who posted in Terrorgram chats, adopted Terrorgram accounts or was a member of an organized group whose leaders participated within the Terrorgram neighborhood.
Prosecutors have linked Allison and his co-defendant, Dallas Humber, to a trio of mass shootings that killed a complete of six folks and wounded a dozen others, and to a stabbing incident that injured 5, based on the indictment and a subsequent temporary.
In early 2024, Allison’s work caught the eye of a younger man from New Jersey named Andrew Takhistov.
Takhistov was in a Terrorgram group chat wherein somebody had posted a number of Allison movies, together with a 51-second clip exhibiting methods to disable overhead electrical traces, based on court docket data. In one other submit, Takhistov indicated that he’d seen one among Allison’s most notorious propaganda movies.
By that summer time, Takhistov, then 18, was planning his personal infrastructure assaults, scheming to disable two electrical substations in New Jersey utilizing the approach featured in Allison’s video, based on prosecutors. In court docket data, they are saying Takhistov was a fan of one of many Terrorgram Collective’s terrorism how-to guides, which Allison allegedly helped produce.
On Sept. 9, 2024, the Biden administration’s Justice Division introduced the arrests and indictments of Allison and Humber, his alleged co-conspirator.
“At present’s arrests are a warning that committing hate-fueled crimes within the darkest corners of the web won’t cover you, and soliciting terrorist assaults from behind a display won’t shield you,” declared then-Legal professional Common Merrick Garland in an announcement. “The USA Division of Justice will discover you, and we are going to maintain you accountable.”
Allison and Humber had been every charged with 15 felony counts, together with soliciting hate crimes, soliciting the homicide of federal officers and conspiring to offer materials assist to terrorists.
Arrested in Boise, Allison was extradited to California, the place Humber can be going through trial. They each pleaded not responsible.
Humber, visited in jail by a ProPublica and FRONTLINE reporter, stated she wouldn’t discuss to journalists. Her lawyer declined to remark.
Allison, towards the recommendation of his personal lawyer, granted two interviews. Wanting pale and gaunt and wearing jailhouse orange, Allison proudly acknowledged being BTC however denied he was a terrorist or that he had incited others to violence.
He known as the indictment “bullshit,” claimed to be a video “artist” and indicated that he supposed to struggle the case on First Modification grounds.
Allison stated the alleged hit record of targets for assassination was merely a doxing record, a response to efforts by anti-fascist teams “to dox me” and anybody who claimed “to be pro-white.” He insisted he didn’t hate anybody.
His attorneys, in a bail movement, stated the indictment was deceptive. They argued that there was no proof that Allison was a pacesetter of a transnational terrorist group. He was, they wrote, only a participant in chats that “‘are principally a chaotic mixture of hyperbole and posts with none acknowledged chief.”
Matthew Allison DJed in Boise, Idaho, earlier than being arrested and charged with supporting terrorism.
Credit score:
Excerpt from “The Rise and Fall of Terrorgram”
After Allison’s arrest, an FBI agent made his approach to rural Perry, Missouri, to see Matthew’s father, John Allison, who lives within the basement of a rambling and drafty decommissioned church he’s renovating.
“Matthew was an ideal little one,” John Allison remembers saying earlier than closing the door on the agent. The daddy stated the agent appeared solely in incriminating data, so he refused to cooperate.
The primary of 4 kids, Matthew had sandy blond hair and blue eyes. Early on, he confirmed musical promise. Like Mozart within the film “Amadeus,” John Allison remembers, Matthew might play the piano the other way up.
The boy wasn’t raised to hate, his father instructed ProPublica and FRONTLINE in an interview.
However from the time he was 10 years outdated, the youthful Allison took an curiosity in grotesque violence, prosecutors say. Matthew’s brother instructed federal brokers that the boy loved watching “graphic violent materials,” together with movies and pictures of “beheadings,” based on a prosecution temporary. His authorized crew declined to touch upon the allegation.
After highschool in Perris, California, Matthew acquired a proposal to attend an area school. He determined as an alternative to comply with his finest buddy to Idaho.
Allison’s attorneys stated in a court docket submitting that he spent 17 of the final 19 years in Boise, a comparatively liberal metropolis in a state that has change into a haven for antigovernment and white supremacist activists.
He labored quite a lot of low-wage service jobs and did lots of sofa browsing, his pals say.
In 2013, Allison acquired a job working the evening shift at a downtown espresso store and bakery. His boss and co-worker bear in mind him as quiet, well mannered {and professional}. He was in a long-term romance with a male co-worker and appeared very a lot in love.
“I at all times thought it was a really cohesive relationship,” stated Tyler Armstrong, who labored on the bakery with each males. “They had been collectively on a regular basis. We’d all get collectively, smoke weed and simply hang around.”
In Boise’s digital dance music scene, Allison discovered a welcoming, inclusive neighborhood. He hosted events the place he would DJ, enjoying progressive home music.
He lived in a Spartan house. He didn’t have a automobile, or perhaps a driver’s license. He instructed pals he wished to remain below the radar.
Over time, he lived in a number of upscale buildings, together with The Fowler, a midrise that boasts a well-appointed health heart and gorgeous views of the downtown.
Whereas some acquaintances puzzled how he afforded the lease on low-wage service jobs, 4 pals say that Allison had a bootleg facet hustle. As Tyler Whitt, one among his pals, put it, “He was a wonderful plug” — a drug supplier.
Allison bought cocaine packaged in signature blue-tinted vials, based on Whitt and three different individuals who bought medicine from him. Allison denied that he bought cocaine in an interview with FRONTLINE and ProPublica, and he has not been charged with any drug-related offenses.
In 2018, unbeknownst to his dance get together pals, Allison was making an attempt to interrupt via on social media as an nameless conservative influencer.
His early movies on YouTube below the Ban This Channel deal with served up customary conservative fare. He peppered the movies with Tucker Carlson clips and used titles corresponding to “The Russian Collusion Lie” and “Lies About Trump Uncovered.” Many of the movies landed with out discover.
Allison stored cranking out movies. They acquired extra racist, homophobic and antisemitic. Ultimately, after he posted the Nazi Social gathering anthem, YouTube banished him from the platform.
His tilt to extremism got here amid bother in his private life. Allison and his long-term boyfriend broke up, leaving him indignant and depressed, based on Armstrong. And his youthful brother in Nevada was imprisoned on drug prices, court docket data present.
In 2020, Allison abruptly left Idaho. He give up his job as a laborer for a flooring firm, citing a household emergency. For a time, he lived in Nevada, taking good care of his brother’s kids.
Allison additionally lived along with his father and stepmother in Utah for almost six months, however he spent more often than not holed up in his room on his laptop, his father stated.
“That was a tough day,” Matthew Allison stated after one 10-plus-hour session. His father stared at him, baffled.
Allison requested his father to assist him begin an internet site to host his content material, which included movies he’d created from outdated Nazi propaganda footage, John Allison stated.
“No, I’m not going to be a celebration to that,” he stated he instructed his son.
Allison quickly discovered one other house for his content material: Telegram.
Pete Simi, a sociology professor at Chapman College in Orange, California, has spent a lot of his profession finding out violent extremist teams and has carefully tracked their migrations to Telegram.
It was someday in 2021, throughout the pandemic, when Simi first turned conscious of BTC.
Simi had simply been admitted to a non-public Telegram chat group.
The administrator of the chat hadn’t been keen to let Simi be part of till he supplied proof of his whiteness. He’d thought his middle-aged pores and skin may elevate suspicion, so he’d shared a photograph of his grownup son’s forearm.
As quickly as he entered the chat, somebody shared a six-minute video known as “Final Battle.” Simi downloaded a replica.
Simi had studied lots of neo-Nazi propaganda — a few of it crude and ineffective. However this video stood out, although the general message was acquainted: It instructed the story of a nation being destroyed by drag queens, immigrant invaders, Black criminals, interracial marriage and a “Jewish communist takeover.”
What was compelling about this video, Simi thought, was the best way it blended violent imagery, ominous music and storytelling to impart a way of worry and white victimhood. The one salvation, the video urged, was for heterosexual white folks to face collectively and arm themselves.
“VOTING WILL NOT REMOVE THEM,” reads textual content on the display. “THEY WANT YOU DEAD.”
“I might say ‘Final Battle’ can be one of many simpler movies I’ve seen,” Simi stated.
Simi began educating the video in school for example of propaganda that might be compelling to many alienated younger males.
Allison, as BTC, turned a Terrorgram Collective chief in 2022 after a earlier chief was arrested, based on prosecutors.
He allegedly distributed prolonged digital how-to guides for making explosives and attacking essential infrastructure, in addition to audiobooks of murderers’ manifestos. Prosecutors say he helped create successful record of perceived enemies — politicians, executives and lecturers — offered as red-and-black buying and selling playing cards with assault weapon logos, which included headshots, addresses and pictures of the targets’ properties.
One in all his main contributions was the 24-minute film “White Terror,” which he instructed ProPublica and FRONTLINE that he edited. It was an homage to 105 white women and men who dedicated acts of terrorism. Humber narrates the script in a remorseless monotone, describing the victims with slurs and praising the terrorists as “saints,” an honorific the Terrorgram influencers bestowed upon white supremacist murderers.
As Allison’s content material turned extra excessive, Telegram began to take down his channels. Every time, the channel simply popped again up with a barely modified title. In December 2021, he bragged in a submit that fifty of the channels he had began had been banned by Telegram.
Utilizing knowledge from the social media evaluation platform Open Measures and different sources, ProPublica and FRONTLINE recognized greater than 20 channels within the Terrorgram ecosystem that had been run by Allison.
The channels had been “broadly shared and promoted by different members of the Terrorgram scene,” stated Pierre Vaux, a London-based researcher who has studied Terrorgram extensively. Vaux stated that Allison additionally belonged to 120 discussion groups and posted in them prolifically. “He’s a superspreader,” stated Vaux.
How a World On-line Community of White Supremacists Groomed a Teen to Kill
In October 2022, a Slovakian teen who had spent years being indoctrinated on Telegram opened hearth on an LGBTQ+ bar within the metropolis of Bratislava, killing two folks and wounding a 3rd.
The shooter had been in direct contact with Terrorgram influencers, and based on U.S. prosecutors, despatched his manifesto to Allison earlier than the assault.
One other Telegram account Allison ran known as BowlTurdsCoinInvesting shared the manifesto. In posts, Allison referred to the victims utilizing a slur for homosexual folks and known as the manifesto “fucking superb.”
Telegram shut the channel down.
However Allison rapidly resurfaced — this time as BigTittyChica. He reposted an audiobook model of the Bratislava shooter’s manifesto.
Round this time, Humber despatched Allison extra information that she discovered encouraging. She had been speaking with a Terrorgram fan who was considering a college taking pictures focusing on folks of colour, prosecutors stated in court docket filings. A few month later, the person acted, killing 4 and wounding 11 at an elementary and center faculty in Aracruz, Brazil.
Terrorgram consecrated one other saint.
Allison’s authorized crew has urged that the federal government could have misinterpreted the communications between Allison and the Slovakian killer. The proof, they stated, did “not present direct messages between Mr. Allison and the shooter however reasonably are messages that the shooter despatched to Telegram group chats that had been later forwarded between Mr. Allison’s purported two telephones.”
Sociology professor Pete Simi and ProPublica reporter James Bandler watch Allison’s propaganda movies.
Credit score:
Excerpt from “The Rise and Fall of Terrorgram”
Whereas the actual world and on-line lives of Allison may appear irreconcilable — a homosexual man who allegedly led a neo-Nazi terror group and advocated the homicide of gays and lesbians — Simi, the Chapman College professor, has seen such instances earlier than. It illustrates, he stated, “the propensity that each one of us have for main contradictory lives. Now we have an incredible capability for compartmentalizing as people.”
Simi as soon as interviewed a homosexual man who was additionally a member of Hammerskin Nation, a violent, hypermasculine Nazi skinhead gang whose members despise LGBTQ+ folks. Finally, the cognitive dissonance turned too nice and the person give up the white supremacist motion.
There are different more moderen examples. Taylor Ashley Parker-Dipeppe hid his transgender identification from fellow members of the neo-Nazi Atomwaffen Division, a violently homophobic group. His gender identification was revealed in court docket after he pleaded responsible in 2021 to conspiracy and stalking prices associated to threats towards journalists and activists.
Allison’s pals had no inkling that the person they partied with was celebrating the homicide of homosexual folks on Telegram. However one buddy, Tyler Armstrong, recalled a troubling second in 2020. He found a Snapchat submit wherein Allison repeated a white supremacist meme about excessive crime charges within the Black neighborhood.
When Armstrong requested how Allison, as a homosexual man, might demonize one other weak inhabitants, Allison replied, “Don’t get me began on the LGBTQ” neighborhood, based on Armstrong. Allison denied the alternate to FRONTLINE and ProPublica.
“Sup bro. do home events exist anymore?”
It was February 2024, and Allison was texting a buddy, making an attempt to attain DJ gigs. He’d been working a ton these days at a comfort retailer job he hated and solely partying Saturday nights. “Anybody else tapped in to the scene who would know what’s up?” he requested. “I’m killing it djing and acquired all of the gear.”
In the meantime on Telegram, Allison was placing the ultimate touches on a film trilogy, which he stated documented “one man’s means of radicalization each step of the best way.”
In July, Allison stuffed out an internet software for a part-time job at a preferred downtown Boise breakfast spot only a quick bike experience from his house.
“Hello there, my title’s Matt. I’ve related job expertise in baking, making New York fashion bagels from scratch,” he wrote. “I’m a pleasant, clear reduce, sociable, dependable, and extremely organized onerous employee.”
He was employed and commenced working instantly.
That very same month, federal brokers arrested Takhistov, the New Jersey man who had watched Allison’s movies and browse the Terrorgram Collective handbook.
Prosecutors say Takhistov was working with one other extremist to disable electrical energy stations. What he didn’t know was that his co-conspirator was an undercover investigator. Takhistov was charged with soliciting one other particular person to destroy vitality services. In constructing their case, investigators obtained his chat historical past, together with greater than 2,500 information.
Courtroom data don’t make it clear whether or not Takhistov has entered a plea. His lawyer declined to remark.
The feds had been getting nearer. But when Allison was frightened in regards to the arrest of this younger Terrorgram fan, he didn’t let on at work.
Over the following weeks at his new job, Allison was well mannered, skilled and pleasant. He instructed his father it was the perfect job he’d ever had.
On Friday, Sept. 6, armed federal brokers confronted Allison as he ready to bike to work.
He didn’t resist. And for 2 hours he spoke to investigators, waiving entry to a lawyer. Allison admitted to creating paintings for one Terrorgram manufacturing and to collaborating in a lot of Telegram channels with white supremacists, based on court docket data. He defined that he was simply sharing “propaganda” and “documenting” his “understanding of the world.”
He repeatedly demanded: “What a part of any of this was unlawful?”
However investigators discovered extra causes for concern. In his backpack, brokers discovered zip ties, duct tape, ammunition, a firearm, a knife, lockpicking tools, two telephones and a thumbdrive, court docket paperwork say.
In his house, they found an assault rifle, two laptops and a “go bag” with $1,500 money, a black balaclava and the form of cranium masks favored by members of Atomwaffen Division, court docket data present.
Federal authorities additionally searched his storage unit, the place they discovered disturbing handwritten letters titled “Commit Murder” and “Submit-Mortem Disembowelment” that contained graphic fantasies about murdering a child and her mom, adopted by the autopsy rape and dissection of the lady’s physique, based on the court docket filings. Prosecutors don’t allege that he dedicated these crimes.
At a detention listening to, Allison’s protection claimed the writings had been outdated music lyrics from his highschool dying metallic band, Putrid Flesh.
In a movement for bail, Allison’s attorneys argued that he was not a menace to anybody and that his speech was protected below the First Modification.
The decide denied Allison bail.
Late final yr in Boise, the 2 Tylers who partied with Allison — Tyler Whitt and Tyler Armstrong — sat right down to course of the confounding double lifetime of their former buddy.
The Rise and Fall of Terrorgram: Inside a World On-line Hate Community
However first they watched “White Terror,” the BTC manufacturing that coldly celebrates terrorist killers with a mixture of grotesque violence and dehumanizing language. Each males stated the video left them in shock.
“That’s any individual who spent lots of time considering and giving in to all this hate in his coronary heart,” Armstrong stated. “And I’m like, The place does that come from?”
Whitt, who’s homosexual, stated he was nonetheless struggling to know. “That’s acquired to be a completely damaged individual,” he stated. “It was like hating everyone else is extra essential than loving one a part of himself.”
However Whitt stated he had no sympathy for his former buddy and hopes Allison will spend the remainder of his life in jail.
“I’m glad they acquired him.”
Tom Jennings, Annie Wong and Karina Meier of FRONTLINE contributed reporting.
